Texas -- state Flock money stops: Abbott freeze, Comptroller grant ban, bills filed for 2027TX
Wrongful stop
TEXAS STOPPED STATE-AGENCY MONEY FOR FLOCK CAMERAS. Gov. Greg Abbott ordered state agencies not to fund Flock cameras, confirmed by his spokesman Andrew Mahaleris on Aug 27, 2026. The state has put at least $30 million into the network since 2023 through the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority, whose board Abbott mostly appoints, and the Department of Public Safety holds a $15.9 million three-year contract for about 1,200 cameras; at least 3,200 Flock cameras run statewide. THE LIMIT IS IN THE SAME SENTENCE: the spokesman said most of the money is federal, and federal and local funds are untouched. Abbott called the problem easily containable and said the cameras must be used responsibly if at all. The trigger was misuse: a Lufkin officer indicted on 100 counts, and at least six Texas agencies disciplining or investigating officers in a month. Robinson and Manor cited the freeze when they left Flock. NOT ESTABLISHED: a written order -- only a spokesman statement is on record -- and whether existing contracts end or only new spending stops. Ask DPS and MVCPA which grants are frozen. UPDATE, OCT 2, 2026: FLOCK PAUSED PAYMENTS FOR 90 DAYS SO SOME TEXAS AGENCIES COULD KEEP THEIR CAMERAS. The Texas Tribune reported that Flock offered certain agencies a 90-day payment hold with full camera access, and told Addison, New Braunfels and Johnson County they could exit the affected cameras without penalty if state money did not return; Addison police heard the offer at a Sep 10 meeting with Flock. Dallas accepted after CEO Garrett Langley met police, keeping more than 300 cameras that had been slated for removal, about half its fleet. All four used Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority reimbursement grants. El Paso instead voted to remove its 150 state-funded cameras, and the Tribune counted 13 other cities and counties that had shut cameras since the freeze. More than 900 DPS cameras are state-funded under a $15 million MVCPA contract; DPS will keep them but has not said how it will pay or whether it got the 90-day pause. Abbott also told TxDOT to stop installing new readers on state roads. Abbott's office has not said how long the freeze lasts; Johnson County Commissioner Rick Bailey called the timing political and some local officials expect funding to return after the Nov 3 election. Flock would not say whether the pause is statewide or case by case. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many agencies took the offer and what happens when the 90 days end in early 2027. UPDATE, OCT 13, 2026: THE COMPTROLLER BARRED ITS GRANTS FROM PAYING FOR PLATE READERS. Comptroller Don Huffines announced that no grant money his office administers may buy, contract for, extend or renew automated plate readers or systems that turn plate images into searchable data, naming Flock Group, Motorola Solutions and Axon Enterprise and their affiliates and resellers; the restriction is to be written into future grant solicitations and agreements and does not touch cameras bought with other funds, KBTX reported Oct 15. Huffines cited the Fourth Amendment and privacy. UPDATE, NOV 12, 2026: BILLS FILED FOR THE 2027 SESSION. As filing opened Nov 9, Sen. Carol Alvarado (D-Houston), whose 2023 bill created the $1 insurance fee, filed a bill with Sens. Roland Gutierrez, Jose Menendez and Taylor Rehmet to stop the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority funding roadside plate readers; Rep. John Bucy (D-Austin) filed a ban on public-agency use; Rep. Mary Gonzalez (D-Clint) and Rep. Brian Harrison (R-Midlothian) filed warrant requirements, Harrison's limited to violent-crime investigations, the Texas Tribune reported via Texas Public Radio. The Tribune counted 940 cameras erected under DPS's $15.9 million contract and an estimated 13,000 Flock cameras in Texas in late August, a number since falling. Governor-elect Hinojosa campaigned against Flock and said the cameras were never authorised and should come down with taxpayers repaid. NOT ESTABLISHED: bill numbers, whether MVCPA grants resume before the new governor takes office in Jan 2027, and what happens when the 90-day payment pauses end.
Monroe County, NY -- sheriff shares plate-reader data with 392 agencies in 20 statesNY
Wrongful stop
MONROE COUNTY'S SHERIFF SHARES PLATE-READER DATA WITH 392 AGENCIES IN 20 STATES. The Rochester Beacon reported on Nov 12, 2026, from a joint records project with Genesee Signal, that the Monroe County Sheriff's Office shares data from its 144 fixed Motorola plate readers, bought with $2.85 million in state grant money, with 392 state and local agencies in 20 states, according to a presentation to county legislators; the written policy allows sharing with New York and 22 other states. The agency list has not been made public. The county released 437 pages on Nov 4 in answer to an August request; an appeal is pending. The sheriff's own search log (Jan 2024 to mid-July 2026) shows at least 11 searches citing a federal agency or task force (DEA, U.S. Marshals, FBI), eight of which returned records; the office says it has no data-sharing agreements with federal agencies, and the Beacon found nothing showing data reaching immigration authorities. Searches rose from 102 in Oct 2025 to 628 in Apr 2026; about a third of readable log entries give only generic reasons such as 'inv'. Data is kept 12 months. Audits begun in February covered 79 of 164 users and found 24 procedural discrepancies and no misuse. A new sharing policy took effect Sep 21, 2026, about six weeks after Democratic legislators sent questions. Chief Deputy Michael Fowler said every outside search is visible and auditable and called the matter not a story; Legislator Rachel Barnhart asked the office to stop sharing with agencies holding 287(g) agreements with ICE; NYCLU's Daniel Schwarz called the 22-state limit no real limit. Patrol-car readers run under a separate Axon contract for 65 vehicles and feed only the state-run Monroe Crime Analysis Center. NOT ESTABLISHED: the names of the 392 agencies, how many outside searches have been run (the outside-search log has not been released), and the outcome of the records appeal.
Akron, OH -- three charged after 17 of the city's 145 Flock cameras were damaged or stolenOH
Wrongful stop
THREE PEOPLE FACE FELONY CHARGES AFTER 17 OF AKRON'S 145 FLOCK CAMERAS WERE DAMAGED OR STOLEN. Akron police said warrants issued Oct 2, 2026 led to arrests on Oct 22 of Jess Petonic, 23, Jackson Petonic, 20, and Mahayla Osborne, 22, each charged with fourth-degree felony vandalism over damage on or about Aug 10, WOIO reported Nov 10, 2026; Jess Petonic had already been arrested in July over another camera and charged with vandalism and disrupting public services. Since July more than 10 percent of the city's network has been hit: cameras spray-painted or taped over, wires cut, solar panels pried off and whole units taken from poles, concentrated in Goodyear Heights, Middlebury, Chapel Hill and North Hill. Eight cameras have been replaced at a cost of about $4,000. Lt. Michael Murphy Jr. said the cameras have figured in homicide investigations; because Flock cameras do not record video, police relied on nearby cameras and witnesses to identify suspects. The network remains active and other reports are under investigation. A former Akron officer was earlier found to have searched his own plate while on paid leave, and some council members have asked to pause or reassess the program. NOT ESTABLISHED: how the three were linked to the damage, whether they are connected to any group, court dates, and the total replacement cost.
West Virginia -- lawmakers call Flock back for a second interim hearing; bill planned for JanuaryWV
Wrongful stop
WEST VIRGINIA LAWMAKERS CALLED FLOCK BACK FOR A SECOND INTERIM HEARING ON NOV 9, 2026. Flock Safety representatives, including Dan Haley, appeared before a legislative interim meeting for the second time after lawmakers said the first appearance and the company's written replies to a series of letters on footage access, security and use left questions open, WSAZ reported. Del. Ryan Browning (R-Wayne) raised misuse and searches that reveal a person's movements when no crime is alleged, and said Flock did better this time but seemed unprepared for some submitted questions; Del. Tristan Leavitt (R-Kanawha) said the questions had been put in writing from the start and a second hearing should not have been needed. Flock said it stood by its public testimony and written answers; Haley said he was puzzled by some exchanges since the first appearance. Lawmakers are reviewing model legislation and want a plate-reader bill ready for the first day of the 2027 regular session in January; Leavitt said any law would cover other vendors too. NOT ESTABLISHED: the committee's name, the date of the first hearing, what the written questions asked, and the bill's text.
St. Louis County, MO -- two charged over five Flock cameras stolen or cut down over Halloween weekendMO
Wrongful stop
TWO MEN WERE CHARGED OVER FIVE FLOCK CAMERAS STOLEN OR CUT DOWN IN HAZELWOOD AND FLORISSANT OVER HALLOWEEN WEEKEND. St. Louis County prosecutors charged Caleb Melton II, 18, of Hazelwood and Logan Williams, 19, of Old Monroe on Nov 9, 2026 with four counts of stealing $750 or more and five counts of first-degree property damage, KSDK reported; the report was read through its Yahoo News syndication. A camera on Teson Road in Hazelwood went offline on Oct 31; four more (three in Florissant, one in Hazelwood) went dark between 12:30 and 2 a.m. on Nov 1. Home video showed two people in Halloween costumes leaving a Ford F-150 whose plate was registered to Williams and his father; other Flock cameras recorded the truck near the sites, and one clip showed one man standing on the other's back to cut a camera down, which struck the kneeling man as it fell. Police found camera parts, costume packaging and a band saw at a St. Charles home where the truck was parked. Each unit costs about $2,500; one was found damaged in woods and four are missing. Williams admitted the five incidents and, police say, claimed about 20 more that night, a claim not confirmed. Both were held on $75,000 bond. NOT ESTABLISHED: which agencies own the cameras, whether further charges follow the claimed additional incidents, and court dates.
Mobile, AL -- police will not say how they use Clearview AI as a $67,000 renewal goes to the councilAL
Wrongful stop
MOBILE POLICE WOULD NOT SAY HOW THEY USE CLEARVIEW AI AS A $67,000 RENEWAL WENT TO THE COUNCIL. NBC 15 reported Nov 9, 2026 that the Mobile City Council was considering a $67,000 annual renewal of Clearview AI facial-recognition software for the Gulf Coast Technology Center, a regional centre where more than 40 local, state and federal agencies are represented. The department declined an interview and did not answer how many searches officers run a year, how results are verified before an identification or arrest, or whether searches and user activity are audited; public-safety spokesman Blake Brown called the software items a matter of operational security. City invoices show Clearview payments of $8,495 in Feb and Apr 2023, $8,495 in Mar 2025 and $9,995 in Mar 2026; the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency has paid Clearview since Dec 2019. Clearview says police use it after a crime, not for live surveillance. ACLU of Alabama policy director A'Niya Robinson raised accuracy, consent and privacy concerns and said the group will push for legislation. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether and when the council approved the renewal, any written use policy, and search volumes.
Cleveland, OH -- EFF and ACLU ask the Sixth Circuit to require a warrant for plate-reader database searches (U.S. v. Sturdivant)OH
Wrongful stop
EFF AND THE ACLU ASKED THE SIXTH CIRCUIT TO REQUIRE A WARRANT FOR PLATE-READER DATABASE SEARCHES. In United States v. Sturdivant, a Cleveland-area robbery case, officers who knew only the make, model and colour of the getaway car ran an open-ended search of two plate-reader databases, Flock's and ELSAG's, found a matching car tracked near the robbery sites and arrested its owner. The district court denied suppression, reasoning that a plate is visible to the public so the defendant had no Fourth Amendment interest in his car's movements being tracked in public. EFF and the ACLU filed an amicus brief on Nov 9, 2026 arguing that the networked ALPR system tracks drivers across the country, that this is a search unlike a passer-by noticing a plate, and that the appeals court should reverse and require a warrant; the brief cites the Oct 2026 Kyle ruling that called ALPRs indiscriminate mass surveillance. NOT ESTABLISHED: the district court and date of the suppression ruling, the number of cameras and the period searched, and the argument date.
New York -- Assembly hearing on statewide plate-reader rules and a 48-hour deletion billNY
Wrongful stop
NEW YORK ASSEMBLY MEMBERS HEARD TESTIMONY IN ALBANY ON NOV 9, 2026 ON STATEWIDE RULES FOR PLATE READERS, INCLUDING A BILL REQUIRING DELETION WITHIN 48 HOURS. At the public hearing, led by the Assembly Consumer Affairs and Protection Committee, Tyler Nims of the Attorney General's Law Enforcement Investigative Office warned of the volume of data collected and the misuse risk that grows with retention; Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney, for the state DA association, said 30 days is too short and proposed sealing older records with court-authorized access; Albany County Sheriff Craig Apple, for the sheriffs' association, said readers solve crimes faster, that he dislikes retention limits but would negotiate, and described new limits after a senior investigator in his office searched an ex-partner and others thousands of times -- supervisor-only access, a case number for every search and more frequent audits (WAMC, Nov 9; FingerLakes1, Nov 11). Assembly bill A10808A would generally require government-held plate data to be deleted within 48 hours, with exceptions for evidence preservation and court orders, restrict access to privately collected records and set conditions on sharing outside New York. Lawmakers called the issue bipartisan and leaned toward a statewide standard in place of town-by-town rules; Assemblymember John McDonald said he respects home rule but wants a fuller discussion. Civil liberties witnesses stressed the risk of building movement histories of people suspected of nothing. The bill remains in committee. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Flock testified, the sponsors, the companion Senate bill's status, and whether the bill moves before the session ends.
Morehead, KY -- Attorney General finds October Flock discussion violated the open meetings lawKY
Wrongful stop
KENTUCKY'S ATTORNEY GENERAL RULED ON NOV 9, 2026 THAT MOREHEAD'S OCTOBER COUNCIL DISCUSSION OF ITS FLOCK CAMERAS BROKE THE OPEN MEETINGS LAW. The Attorney General's Office found the public had not received sufficient notice that the plate readers would be discussed at an October 2026 city council meeting (WKYT, Nov 10). The council voted the next day not to renew its two Flock contracts. NOT ESTABLISHED: the date of the October meeting, who filed the complaint, and whether the council must redo any action taken at it.
St. Louis, MO -- police drones begin answering 911 calls; transparency portal launchedMO
Wrongful stop
ST. LOUIS POLICE DRONES BEGAN ANSWERING 911 CALLS IN THE FIRST WEEK OF NOVEMBER 2026. Chief Robert Tracy presented an 'aerial response unit' order dated Oct 29 to the Board of Police Commissioners on Nov 2, 2026; the board took it up Nov 4, and KMOV reported the program was approved hours before the unit's first 911 call, which KMOV's linked coverage dated Nov 5. The St. Louis Police Foundation paid for six drones and a radar that tracks drones; four are ready at the Central and North patrol stations and a third dock is being installed at South Patrol. Drones fly from docks to calls under control of the Real-Time Crime Center; the order bars weapons, routine surveillance and facial recognition without a new policy, and allows observing rallies only for a stated public-safety purpose. A public transparency portal launched Nov 9 shows flights, flight paths, calls closed without an officer and average flight time. The ACLU's Jay Stanley welcomed the ban on routine surveillance but said retention and use of recordings were unanswered and warned against AI analysis of the video; Mayor Cara Spencer said she received the policy at the same time as the press. The department may spend part of a $300 million federal allocation on more drones or docks. NOT ESTABLISHED: the board's vote count, the vendor, the retention period for drone video, and the cost of the six drones.
Ninth Circuit -- EFF and ACLU ask the court to hold tower-dump warrants categorically unconstitutional (U.S. v. Spurlock)CA
Wrongful stop
EFF AND THE ACLU ASKED THE NINTH CIRCUIT TO HOLD TOWER-DUMP WARRANTS CATEGORICALLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL. In United States v. Spurlock, a California double-murder investigation, police found a victim's car several miles down a rural highway and obtained a tower-dump warrant for that stretch of road that returned location data on nearly 1,700 phones. The district court, following a Fifth Circuit geofence decision, held tower dumps are general warrants barred by the Fourth Amendment but refused to suppress under the good-faith doctrine. EFF and the ACLU filed an amicus brief on Nov 3, 2026 arguing that tower dumps and geofence warrants are the same kind of reverse location search, that the Supreme Court's June 2026 Chatrie decision strengthens the case against them, that courts should at minimum require limits on scope and duration, notice to affected people and deletion of irrelevant data, and that the court should decide the constitutional question rather than rest on good faith. NOT ESTABLISHED: the district court and judge, the carriers served, and the argument date.
Arizona -- voters approve Proposition 319 banning new photo traffic enforcementAZ
Wrongful stop
ARIZONA VOTERS APPROVED PROPOSITION 319 ON NOV 3, 2026, BANNING NEW PHOTO TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT AND REQUIRING LOCAL VOTER APPROVAL TO KEEP EXISTING CAMERAS. The legislatively referred measure bars new photo enforcement systems for traffic violations statewide; cities already running speed and red-light cameras, such as Phoenix, which reinstated them in 2026, and Tempe, which installed them in May 2025, keep theirs only if local voters approve at the next election (Arizona's Family, Nov 4; KJZZ, Nov 3). The Republican-led Legislature referred it after Gov. Katie Hobbs vetoed similar bills. The Associated Press called it at 1:34 AM on Nov 4 with 59% yes; Arizona's Family had it near 61% yes with about 84% counted. Supporters argued officers use discretion while cameras ticket automatically, and some cited wariness of how camera data is stored and used in the Flock era; Tempe Mayor Corey Woods cited a drop of more than 21% in fatal crashes and collisions, Phoenix Councilwoman Debra Stark said drivers were slowing, and Phoenix Councilwoman Anna Hernandez backed requiring voter approval. These are enforcement cameras that photograph plates for citations, not Flock-style reader networks; Arizona's plate-reader fights are on the community records. NOT ESTABLISHED: the certified count, the effective date, the referring bill number, and which election counts as the next one for Phoenix and Tempe.
Platte County, NE -- man charged with terroristic threats and criminal mischief over a Flock camera beaten with a poleNE
Wrongful stop
A PLATTE COUNTY MAN FACES FIVE CHARGES, INCLUDING TERRORISTIC THREATS, OVER A FLOCK CAMERA BEATEN WITH A METAL POLE. Caeden Hartman, 26, is charged with terroristic threats, use of a firearm to commit a felony, use of a deadly weapon to commit a felony, criminal mischief over $5,000 and second-degree criminal trespass after a Flock camera near 48th Avenue and 53rd Street in Columbus Township was damaged on Oct 11, 2026, KOLN reported Nov 2, 2026 from court records. A witness saw a man with a pole and a person in a ski mask crossing a field; a Platte County deputy stopped a man walking up a posted private driveway who refused to identify himself, and a handgun and a black metal pole were found in the field. Court records say he tried to recruit another person to go 'flocking' and lifted his shirt to show a holstered pistol. The camera is valued at $6,000 and the damage at about $550. He denies involvement. Bond was set at 10 percent of $15,000; his next court date was Nov 4. NOT ESTABLISHED: who owns the camera, the result of the Nov 4 hearing, and whether the terroristic-threats count relates to the recruitment allegation.
Flock Safety -- CEO tells police chiefs the backlash is not real, in audio leaked to 404 MediaGA
Wrongful stop
FLOCK'S CEO TOLD POLICE CHIEFS THE BACKLASH IS NOT REAL, IN AUDIO LEAKED TO 404 MEDIA. 404 Media reported Oct 26, 2026 on a recording of Garrett Langley speaking the day before, Sunday Oct 25, at a private police conference before an audience of chiefs. He said the anti-Flock protests around the country are not real, that social-media opposition is mostly bots and that someone had been paying for critical posts and then stopped, offering no evidence; he said chatter about Flock had fallen about 95 percent since July and tied the drop to a reported drone strike on a Russian data centre, a theory 404 Media notes has been disproven. He said his wife told him never to apologise and that he would rather stop giving press interviews. The remarks came as TechCrunch counted at least a dozen local governments moving to drop Flock since summer and after the company cut about 18 percent of staff on Oct 8. NOT ESTABLISHED: the conference, who leaked the audio, and whether Flock has responded.
Fresno, CA -- officer on leave over Flock and CLETS searchesCA
Data misuse
A FRESNO OFFICER IS ON LEAVE AFTER AN AUDIT FLAGGED FLOCK SEARCHES. A Fresno Police Department officer is on administrative leave pending an internal-affairs investigation into alleged abuse of Flock camera access, GV Wire reported Oct 23, 2026, from the Fresno Office of Independent Review's report on the first three quarters of 2026. Enhanced Flock audit features flagged the officer's access on Aug 25; investigators then found a possible search of the state CLETS database not tied to any case, and a failure to turn on a body camera during a traffic stop. Police said the conduct will be reviewed for possible crimes. The officer was not named. In July GV Wire reported that Fresno police run thousands of Flock searches a month and that audits looked at only a small share. NOT ESTABLISHED: the officer's name, what or whom was searched, how many times, and the outcome.
New Bedford, MA -- two officers fired for tracking partners with FlockMA
Data misuse
NEW BEDFORD FIRES BOTH OFFICERS. Mayor Jon Mitchell's office announced on Oct 22, 2026 that Officer Emily Pacheco and Sgt. James Marinelli had been fired on the recommendation of Police Chief Jason Thody, after a Professional Standards Unit investigation found both misused the department's Flock plate-reader system for personal reasons; Pacheco was also found to have entered inaccurate information and ignored procedures. Thody had recommended termination and sent both cases to the Bristol County District Attorney on Sep 3, 2026. Pacheco ran an ex-girlfriend's plate nearly 500 times between April and June 2026, often logging it as a traffic infraction; it came out through the woman's abuse-prevention-order affidavit, not an audit. Marinelli searched a woman he was dating and her ex's car under reasons such as trespass and welfare check; Flock's audit-assistance tool flagged him and an investigation opened Aug 5. The city switched Flock off on Aug 11 (the cameras stay up). The firings close phase one of the audit; a second audit covering Dec 20, 2024 to Dec 31, 2025 is under way and the city says it will publish the results, while the council weighs rules or scrapping the network. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the DA will charge either officer (no answer to reporters by Oct 22), and whether either will appeal.
Georgetown, IN -- officer arrested by state police over mislabeled Flock searchesIN
Data misuse
INDIANA STATE POLICE ARRESTED GEORGETOWN OFFICER JUSTIN CRAIG AT HOME OVER FLOCK SEARCHES, REPORTED OCT 23, 2026. Craig, a Georgetown Police Department officer in Floyd County who earlier served as Greenville town marshal and with the Floyd County Sheriff's Office, faces one low-level felony count of official misconduct and two misdemeanor fraud counts in Floyd Superior Court 1. Police say he ran numerous Flock plate-reader searches during 2026 on duty, entering reasons such as traffic violations, drug offenses, assault and vehicle theft when no related investigation existed. A tip about irregular search activity reached Chief Travis Speece, investigator Clay Boley reviewed the logs and sought a warrant, and state police arrested him with SWAT assistance, without incident. He posted $2,000 bond; his next hearing is set for Dec 17. His attorney, Matthew Lemme, told WDRB the conduct broke no law or policy and that Craig will move to dismiss. SOURCING: this record relies on Hoodline's relay of WISH-TV, WLKY and WDRB reporting; the local articles were not read directly. NOT ESTABLISHED: the search count, who was searched, the arrest date, and his employment status.
Summit County / Park City, UT -- plate data on a 4,000-agency network that includes ICE and Border Patrol; lawmakers open a bill fileUT
Wrongful stop
PARK CITY AND SUMMIT COUNTY PLATE DATA SITS ON A NETWORK OF MORE THAN 4,000 AGENCIES INCLUDING ICE AND BORDER PATROL, AND UTAH LAWMAKERS OPENED A BILL FILE. TownLift reported Oct 22, 2026 that Motorola VehicleManager data-sharing reports obtained in July for Park City police and the Summit County Sheriff's Office listed more than 4,000 agencies with access, including ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations, Homeland Security Investigations, CBP and U.S. Border Patrol; both agencies said they do not routinely monitor outside access, and the records did not show an outside agency searching local data in a specific case. TownLift counted more than a dozen Motorola Vigilant readers in the area in May. Summit County signed a $55,000 Flock Nova data-integration contract in Sep 2025 listing the Motorola data as a source; neither the reader program nor the Flock contract went to the County Council for a vote or hearing, and Councilor Canice Harte said he knew of no public outreach on outside access. Sgt. Skyler Talbot said deputies need an open case number to search. The Legislature's Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Interim Committee opened a 'Law Enforcement Technology Amendments' bill file for the 2027 session; Sen. Calvin Musselman (R-West Haven) said lawmakers see both value and legitimate privacy concerns, and the Salt Lake Tribune reported proposals to restrict access, speed deletion and add remedies for misuse. Current law limits searches to active investigations, warrants, missing or endangered persons and stolen vehicles. Two Motorola readers in the county were deliberately damaged within four months, part of more than $10,000 in device damage. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any immigration agency has searched Park City or Summit County data, and the bill's text.
Orange County, CA -- fusion center told police to watch for 'suspicious behavior' at council meetings about FlockCA
Wrongful stop
A CALIFORNIA FUSION CENTER TOLD POLICE TO WATCH FOR 'SUSPICIOUS BEHAVIOR' AT COUNCIL MEETINGS ABOUT FLOCK. 404 Media published on Oct 21, 2026 a July 2026 bulletin from the Orange County Intelligence Assessment Center, obtained under public-records law, which said council meetings on Flock cameras might be seen by extremists as a target and listed things for officers to watch for: excessive clothing, unusual questions or behaviour, loitering, unattended bags, large turnouts over room capacity, emotional confrontations, counter-demonstrations, media presence and social-media amplification. The bulletin said there were no specific or credible threats, suggested the Los Angeles Police Department's exit from Flock could raise turnout and pressure on other councils, and referenced the DeFlock movement; its file name referenced Costa Mesa. It closed by saying the centre safeguards constitutional rights and reports on First Amendment activity only for operational planning. NOT ESTABLISHED: which departments received the bulletin, whether any acted on it, and any response from the centre or Flock.
Macon County, NC -- deputy fired over plate-reader misuse; too late to chargeNC
Data misuse
MACON COUNTY FIRED DEPUTY JONATHAN BEAN, AND NO CHARGE IS POSSIBLE. The Macon County Sheriff's Office said on Oct 20, 2026 that it had fired Bean after a credible outside agency told it on Oct 16 that an employee had misused the license plate reader system. Bean was put on administrative leave, an internal-affairs detective confirmed the complaint, and he was terminated. Chief Deputy Dereck Jones said no charges were filed because the conduct fell outside the statute of limitations. The office said misuse will not be tolerated. It comes three months after county commissioners voted unanimously on Jul 14, 2026 to defund the sheriff's Flock program over the sheriff's objection. NOT ESTABLISHED: what or whom Bean searched, when, which outside agency raised it, and whether the case was sent to the SBI or the state training standards commission.
Brenham, TX -- officer fired over plate-reader misuse; Texas Rangers investigatingTX
Data misuse
BRENHAM FIRED OFFICER GABRIEL DURAN ON OCT 16, 2026 OVER PLATE-READER MISUSE. A routine audit in late August found searches outside department policy, which requires every search to serve a legitimate law-enforcement purpose. On Sep 4 Duran was put on administrative leave, an internal investigation opened, and the department asked the Texas Rangers to run a separate criminal investigation. The internal case closed Oct 14 and he was fired two days later. Chief Gary Boshears said people whose information was improperly searched have been notified, but the department has not said how many searches were flagged. The system was not Flock: Brenham runs two Vigilant (Motorola Solutions) cameras, and a watchdog post claiming Flock was wrong. Earlier, on Oct 6, the city had only confirmed an internal-affairs case; Councilmember Steve Soman said the Flock cameras in town belong to Washington County, TxDOT and private businesses. NOT ESTABLISHED: what or whom Duran searched, how many searches, and whether the Rangers' case leads to charges.
Richmond County, GA -- seventh deputy arrested over Flock searchesGA
Data misuse
SEVEN RICHMOND COUNTY DEPUTIES ARRESTED SINCE JUNE. The Richmond County (Augusta), Georgia Sheriff's Office arrested and fired Deputy Corey Whitfield, WRDW reported Oct 15, 2026, on charges of misuse of license plate readers and violation of oath of office, saying he knowingly searched plates in the Flock camera system for no official purpose. He was booked into the Charles B. Webster Detention Center; the office said he broke policies on unauthorized database access and conduct unbecoming, and Sheriff Eugene Brantley said personal use is strictly prohibited. Whitfield had been demoted in 2025 after a DUI arrest. He is the seventh in a case that began with Deputy Jaquarius Yarbrough, arrested and fired after a Jun 25 audit found multiple Flock queries over 28 days with no authorized need; the Augusta Press puts Yarbrough's count at 1,639 searches of one woman. On Jul 20 Lt. John McKenzie, Investigator Curtis Hoskins and Deputy Joshua Johnson were arrested, each accused of more than 100 unauthorized searches, and on Sep 1 Investigator Sean Morrow and Deputy Jose Ferrer were arrested and fired. WRDW (Sep 4, 2026): no supervisor approval was needed for any search before the cases surfaced; about 330 deputies had access to nearly 200 cameras; the May 9, 2022 LPR policy required a case number only when available. Brantley says access is now restricted and each search must carry a case number, call reason, request and badge number. WRDW counted 41 officers arrested or fired in Flock misuse cases across GA and SC as of early September. NOT ESTABLISHED: search counts for Morrow, Ferrer and Whitfield, whose plates they searched, and any conviction.
Sharonville, OH -- police lieutenant indicted on a felony over 29 personal Flock searchesOH
Data misuse
A SHARONVILLE POLICE LIEUTENANT WAS INDICTED ON A FELONY FOR PERSONAL FLOCK SEARCHES, WVXU REPORTED OCT 13, 2026. Lt. Walter Cordes, 48, is charged with unauthorized use of a computer, cable or telecommunication property, a fifth-degree felony carrying up to a year in prison, in a case handled by the Hamilton County Prosecutor's office. Chief Jim Nesbit said Cordes searched the Flock plate-reader system 29 times between December 2024 and April 2026 for someone he knew, for personal reasons; a department audit flagged the searches and Cordes then came forward and disclosed them. He is on administrative leave while an internal investigation runs. Nesbit said the department had adopted new policies and begun auditing its databases, including Flock, and is organizing new training. Prosecutor Connie Pillich said misuse undermines public trust and urged every department to audit its systems and adopt a policy barring personal use. NOT ESTABLISHED: the indictment and arraignment dates, who was searched, and whether Cordes is fired.
Bexar County, TX -- placeholder case numbers in sheriff's Flock logTX
Wrongful stop
1,800 SEARCHES IN A MONTH, 72 PERCENT OF THEM NATIONWIDE-SCALE. A month of Bexar County Sheriff's Office Flock audit logs, Aug 2 to Sep 1, 2026, shows about 1,800 searches, and more than a dozen carried a placeholder like '12345' instead of a case number, some for nearly a month, the News 4 I-Team reported Oct 12. Nearly three in four searches reached 1,000 or more outside networks. Sheriff Javier Salazar says placeholders must be replaced and supervisors check whether wide searches are justified. He also says he will not ask commissioners to keep paying for the county's 33 cameras when the anti-gang grant runs out in early 2027, and that if residents do not want them, so be it. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any search was improper, and what Commissioners Court will do.
Shelton, WA -- audit finds 943 outside searches tied to immigrationWA
Wrongful stop
SHELTON'S OWN AUDIT FOUND 943 OUTSIDE-AGENCY SEARCHES WITH A STRONG IMMIGRATION LINK. Shelton police reviewed about 2.67 million Flock audit entries from April 2025 to Jul 28, 2026, KIRO 7 reported on Oct 11, 2026. 943 searches by outside agencies gave reasons citing ICE, deportation, immigration enforcement, Border Patrol or human smuggling, and another 1,952 entries referenced Homeland Security Investigations or an immigration agency without showing a clear immigration purpose. All of the immigration-linked entries fall between April and October 2025, while the network ran nationwide-sharing settings; police say none came from Shelton staff. Shelton cut off all out-of-state agencies in fall 2025 and limited access to authorised Washington agencies for approved purposes, and Washington law bars use of the data for federal immigration enforcement. A second review of 74,697 entries from Jan 1 to Jul 28, 2026 found no immigration entries and no out-of-state access, but 193 testing or demo entries and 16 vague reasons, three left blank. Police note an audit entry does not prove a Shelton camera captured the car or that anyone viewed an image. Retention is 21 days. NOT ESTABLISHED: which agencies ran the searches and whether any result was used in an enforcement action.
Washington -- Wyden asks ONDCP to release the MITRE privacy review of HIDTA's plate-reader databaseDC
Wrongful stop
SEN. RON WYDEN ASKED THE WHITE HOUSE DRUG OFFICE TO PUBLISH A 2024 PRIVACY REVIEW OF ITS LICENSE-PLATE DATABASE, 404 MEDIA REPORTED ON OCT 9, 2026. The letter to ONDCP Director Sara Carter follows a Sep 30, 2026 404 Media investigation by Jason Koebler into the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area (HIDTA) program, a 1980s anti-drug grant program under the Office of National Drug Control Policy with 33 regional intelligence centers covering all 50 states, each run by a board of law enforcement and government lawyers. The investigation found that local agencies sign memoranda of understanding that send their Flock, Axon, ELSAG and Vigilant plate-reader data to HIDTA systems on federal servers, where federal, state and local agencies with no vendor contract can search it, and that a December 2024 DEA privacy assessment says the MOUs let HIDTA data flow on to the DEA's National License Plate Reader Program. Examples from the records: Brunswick, Georgia could not deploy Axon cameras without an agreement with the Atlanta-area HIDTA; Georgia state police policy requires a HIDTA MOU before a city puts readers on state rights of way, and Flock's Georgia page says those reads are searchable by Georgia users of the national HIDTA system; the Randolph County, North Carolina sheriff said all its data sits on the Houston HIDTA database and cannot be released; Houston HIDTA paid Recruitful LLC $306,800 for a database that combines several vendors' plate data. HIDTA records are not subject to FOIA, and the DEA has argued in court that it does not control them. The administration added $277 million to HIDTA in July 2026. Wyden's letter asks ONDCP to release a MITRE privacy review completed in 2024 that covers HIDTA's plate-reader and cell-phone data programs, which he says the office refused to give his staff and has never published, plus a separate analysis of ALPR systems and practices. ONDCP, the DEA, Flock, Axon and CBP did not respond to 404 Media. NOT ESTABLISHED: the letter's date and any response deadline, how many agencies feed HIDTA, retention periods, and whether ONDCP has replied.
Flock Safety -- about 270 jobs, 18 percent of staff, cut as backlash growsGA
Wrongful stop
FLOCK SAFETY PLANS TO CUT ABOUT 270 JOBS, ROUGHLY 18 PERCENT OF ITS STAFF, REUTERS REPORTED ON OCT 8, 2026. People with direct knowledge told Reuters that the Atlanta-based company, which employs about 1,500, would let the affected staff go at the end of October, following a buyout offer announced in September; the plan had not been made public. The sources tied the cuts to growing opposition from communities and lawmakers and to scrutiny from regulators and privacy advocates over the company's data-sharing practices. A Reuters/Ipsos poll found 38 percent of Americans supported Flock cameras in their community and 47 percent opposed them. Reuters also cited Florida's September ban on plate readers along state highways, a Virginia privacy suit calling Flock's network warrantless surveillance, and investor demands that Home Depot review its surveillance vendors after reports that Flock data reached immigration enforcement. Flock, valued at $7.5 billion in a $275 million round led by Andreessen Horowitz in March 2026 with more than $950 million raised in all, says it serves more than 4,800 law-enforcement agencies and nearly 1,000 businesses with about 120,000 cameras in 49 states. Flock declined to comment. NOT ESTABLISHED: a public confirmation from Flock, which teams are affected, and how many employees took the September buyout.
Chicago suburbs -- West Chicago, Channahon, Joliet, Bloomingdale, Itasca officers on leave or outIL
Data misuse
FIVE CHICAGO-AREA DEPARTMENTS IN TWO WEEKS. Between late August and mid-September 2026, officers in West Chicago, Channahon, Joliet and Bloomingdale were put on administrative leave, and an Itasca officer left the force, over alleged misuse of Flock plate-reader searches. West Chicago's case covers searches from late 2024 to early 2025 and has gone to the DuPage County State's Attorney; Joliet's two employees were referred to the city's inspector general and the Illinois State Police. None had been charged by mid-September. The state bill that would narrow use and require deletion within three days -- Rep. Nicolle Grasse's Automated License Plate Recognition System Act -- remains in committee. NOT established: who the officers are, whose plates were searched, and outcomes. Ask each department whether audits are now routine and published. PALOS PARK. Officer Cohen Piechocinski ran eleven Flock searches of personal vehicles with no case behind them; his access was revoked on Aug 3, 2026 and the chief was weighing discipline, ABC7 Chicago reported on Aug 27. ABC7's 130 records requests across Illinois and Indiana found at least 10 agencies investigating officers for Flock misuse. NOT established: Piechocinski's discipline. THREE CHARGED. 'None charged' no longer holds. On Sep 29, 2026 a DuPage County grand jury indicted former Itasca officer Marisa Ciccola on 21 counts (13 felony official-misconduct, 8 misdemeanor computer-tampering) over LEADS and Flock searches from June 2025 to May 2026, and former West Chicago officer Gerardo Solis on two counts over a single Flock search in the winter of 2024-25. Both surrendered and are due in court Nov 16. On Oct 7 Illinois State Police said a Will County grand jury had charged former Joliet lieutenant Jeremy Harrison with felony computer tampering and official misconduct for using the city's Flock system for personal benefit -- a case Joliet's inspector general referred a year earlier, in October 2025. Note the West Chicago charge: ONE search was enough to indict. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates were searched and why, and whether Harrison is one of the two Joliet employees put on leave in September.
Athens-Clarke County, GA -- officer fired, arrested over searches of ex-girlfriend's plateGA
Data misuse
A SECOND ATHENS-CLARKE EMPLOYEE IN TWO MONTHS, AND THIS TIME A SWORN OFFICER. The Athens-Clarke County Police Department said on Oct 7, 2026 that officer Tyler Vaughn had been fired after allegedly running his ex-girlfriend's license plate through the department's Flock system several times over about a week in 2025. A fellow officer noticed and reported it. The department asked the GBI to open an independent criminal investigation, and Atlanta News First reported him arrested. In August the same department fired a civilian intelligence-analyst supervisor, Nick Barker, accused of searching his ex-wife's plate over several months in 2025. ACCPD has now limited Flock searches to supervisors and above. Note the lag: both sets of searches date from 2025 and surfaced in 2026, after audit tools and statewide GBI cases put misuse on the agenda. NOT ESTABLISHED: the charges and statute, the arrest date, and the exact number of searches. Ask the GBI for the warrant.
Waukesha County, WI -- WILL and No Cams Muskego sue 11 municipalities and the county over warrantless Flock searchesWI
Wrongful stop
WISCONSIN'S FIRST WARRANT LAWSUIT OVER FLOCK NAMES 11 TOWNS AND THE COUNTY. On Sep 10, 2026 the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty and the citizens group NoCams Muskego sued Waukesha County and 11 of its cities and villages -- Muskego, Oconomowoc, New Berlin, Waukesha, Delafield, Brookfield, Mukwonago, Hartland, Menomonee Falls, Elm Grove and Pewaukee -- in Waukesha County Circuit Court. The suit asks a judge to declare that police need a warrant before searching the Flock database; it does not ask for the cameras to be removed. WILL counts more than 120 Flock cameras in the county. On Oct 7 the defendants moved the case to federal court, argued the cameras only record movement in public where there is no expectation of privacy, and asked the judge to pause the case until the Seventh Circuit rules in a similar Illinois case. NOT ESTABLISHED: the federal case number, which Illinois case the defense means, and whether the stay is granted. Two of the defendants, Oconomowoc and Waukesha, have already voted to leave Flock. UPDATE, OCT 2026: THE CASE IS IN FEDERAL COURT AND THE DEFENSE WANTS IT PAUSED. The defendants removed the suit to federal court on Oct 7 and asked the judge to hold it until the Seventh Circuit rules in a similar Illinois case. The Illinois case is not named in the reporting; the one pending appeal that fits is Scholl v. Illinois State Police, a challenge to state police plate cameras on Chicago-area expressways, argued Sep 29, 2026 before Chief Judge Michael Brennan and Judges Amy St. Eve and Rebecca Taibleson after a district judge dismissed it, ruling that photographing plates is not a search. No appellate decision has issued. NOT ESTABLISHED: the federal case number, whether Scholl is the case the defense meant, and whether the stay is granted. A Seventh Circuit loss for the Scholl plaintiffs would bind the federal court hearing the Waukesha case.
Washington -- 16 local governments pay $335,000+ over withheld Flock imagesWA
Wrongful stop
$335,000 AND COUNTING FOR REFUSING TO HAND OVER FLOCK IMAGES. Snohomish County paid $35,000 in September 2026 to settle a public-records lawsuit from Jose Rodriguez, who had asked for Flock camera images and did not get them, Cascadia Daily News reported Oct 7. The county admitted no liability and called it a risk-management decision; it still uses Flock. Rodriguez sent 53 requests to Washington local governments, and his lawyer, Tim Hall, says 16 counties and cities have now paid more than $335,000 between them; Sedro-Woolley paid $40,000 in August. Washington's new law, in force since March 2026, closed the data to records requests, but a Skagit County judge ruled in April that requests filed before then must still be answered. NOT ESTABLISHED: the other 14 governments and what each paid -- the $335,000 total is Hall's figure.
Oakland County, MI -- ex-deputy accused of searching Flock after he no longer worked for the countyMI
Data misuse
HE HAD LEFT THE JOB; THE ACCESS, ALLEGEDLY, HAD NOT. The Oakland County, Michigan Sheriff's Office confirmed on Oct 6, 2026 that it is investigating a former deputy accused of using the county's Flock plate-reader system after he was no longer employed by the county in any capacity, and said criminal charges are possible. It gave no name, search count or explanation of how a former employee got in. The case came up the same day before the county commission's public safety committee; a commission spokesperson would not say whether Flock use would be paused, and a resident group's call for an audit of every former employee's access has not been taken up. It mirrors the Acworth, Georgia case on this map, where an officer who had left kept access to his old department's cameras. Oakland County is also the county that approved Flock's seven-drone 911 program 13-4 in April. NOT ESTABLISHED: who, how, how often, and who is investigating. Ask the sheriff when the account was disabled.
Colorado -- woman cited on a Flock search sues Flock and two townsCO
Wrongful stop
A FLOCK SEARCH PUT HER AT A $25 PORCH THEFT; SHE WAS AT THE TAILOR. NOW SHE IS SUING. In September 2025 a Columbine Valley police sergeant, Jamie Milliman, used Flock records to place Chrisanna Elser's car in neighbouring Bow Mar near the time a package was taken from a porch, and cited her. Her car's own cameras, her phone's location data and the tailor's security video showed she was elsewhere; the summons was voided 18 days later. In early October 2026 she filed a federal lawsuit against Flock Safety, both towns, Milliman and Chief Bret Cottrell. It says Milliman pulled a month of her vehicle's history without a warrant, case number or supervisor sign-off, and asks the court to require all three plus audits for every Flock search in Colorado, on behalf of a class. Flock says its technology is accurate and it will fight the suit. Columbine Valley says it has not been served; the chief earlier reprimanded the sergeant over his demeanor. NOT ESTABLISHED: the court, case number and damages sought.
Fall River, MA -- under 3% of Flock searches carried a case numberMA
Wrongful stop
FEWER THAN 3 IN 100 SEARCHES HAD A CASE NUMBER. From 2021 through 2025, fewer than 3 percent of Fall River police Flock searches carried a case number, The New Bedford Light found in five years of usage data published Oct 6, 2026. Officers ran more than 15,000 searches in 2025 alone. Reasons typed in included a single period, lone letters, '123' and keyboard mash; one officer entered '99' more than 1,000 times. The rate of searches with a reference number jumped from about 9 percent in July 2026 to about 70 percent in August. Acting Chief J.T. Hoar calls it a training gap, says no misuse has been found, and says he now reviews logs daily. The city has 41 cameras and is adding more. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any of the vague searches were improper -- the city withheld the plate data that would show who was being looked up.
Bellingham, WA -- police drone-as-first-responder program launched with no fixed retention periodWA
Wrongful stop
BELLINGHAM POLICE LAUNCHED A DRONE-AS-FIRST-RESPONDER PROGRAM ON OCT 6, 2026, WITH NO FIXED RETENTION PERIOD FOR FOOTAGE. Salish Current reported Nov 12, 2026 that the department flies Skydio drones from docks at the police station, the Pacific Street operations center and Bellis Fair mall, with Axon providing services and evidence storage under the city's contract; a neighbour recalled equipment going in around Aug 17 and the public dashboard logged 'system testing' flights from Aug 21. Policy 605 allows flights for search and rescue, emergency calls, evidence collection, traffic and mapping, fire support and monitoring large gatherings that could raise safety concerns; a warrant is required to record places with a reasonable expectation of privacy absent exigency, and the city says the camera faces the horizon until the drone reaches a call. Footage follows the department's general records schedule rather than a set deletion period and is stored with body-camera video; pilots log flights and a coordinator reports monthly. A separate policy limits help to immigration enforcement but does not address drone footage. Neighbour Lawrence Slagle asked for transparency on when flights began and why; EFF's Beryl Lipton said public flight locations can expose sensitive calls, bystanders are captured, and access and sharing rules are unclear. NOT ESTABLISHED: the number of drones, the cost and funding source, which body approved the program and when, and whether the city's surveillance rules required a review.
Lowell, MA -- council switched Flock back on 8-1 in a closed session; vote surfaced in minutesMA
Wrongful stop
LOWELL'S COUNCIL REINSTATED ITS 37 FLOCK CAMERAS BY AN 8-1 VOTE TAKEN IN EXECUTIVE SESSION ON OCT 6, 2026; THE DECISION BECAME PUBLIC ONLY WHEN MINUTES WERE RELEASED. Boston.com reported Nov 12, 2026 that the vote reversing the Sep 22 public suspension (6-5) was taken behind closed doors and conditioned on no data sharing with other agencies. Councilor Sean McDonough, the lone no, said the vote should have been held in public. NOT ESTABLISHED: the stated basis for the executive session, whether anyone has filed an Open Meeting Law complaint, and when the cameras came back on.
Brunswick County, NC -- former deputy indicted on 18 counts over Flock searchesNC
Data misuse
FORMER BRUNSWICK COUNTY DEPUTY INDICTED ON 18 COUNTS AFTER A FLOCK AUDIT. Brunswick County Sheriff Brian Chism said on Sep 1, 2026 that a sheriff's office employee had resigned after an internal-affairs investigation into misuse of the agency's Flock plate-reader system, caught in a routine audit, and that the case had gone to the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. On Oct 5, 2026 a true bill of indictment was filed against former deputy Daniel Heith Little and the SBI arrested him the same day. He faces six counts of accessing a government computer, six counts of misuse of an automated license plate reader system and six counts of willful failure to discharge duties. The indictments allege he used a county-issued cellphone to look up several different plates in Flock with no legitimate law enforcement purpose between February and August 2026. County records show he resigned Aug 18. He was released on an unsecured bond and is due in court Dec 8. North Carolina is one of the few states with a statute that makes plate-reader misuse a crime in itself. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates he searched and why, and how many searches the six counts stand for.
Chesterfield County, VA -- police intelligence investigator charged under the state ALPR lawVA
Data misuse
CHARGED UNDER VIRGINIA'S PLATE-READER LAW ITSELF, NOT JUST A GENERAL COMPUTER CRIME. Rebekkah Robinson, a civilian intelligence investigator with Chesterfield County Police, was charged on or about Oct 2, 2026 with two counts of violating Va. Code 2.2-5517, the 2025 law that limits how police use automated license plate readers, and two counts of computer invasion of privacy brought by Virginia State Police. Coworkers raised concerns in late August; an audit opened Aug 27 found suspicious queries in both the state VCIN/NCIC database and the department's Flock cameras. Her access was revoked and she is on unpaid leave. Chief Frank Carpenter stressed that the case was reported internally, and the department has begun a 30-day review of every police system. It lands as Richmond's General Assembly debates a statewide ban for 2027 (see Virginia statewide). NOT ESTABLISHED: whom she searched, how many times, and the arrest and court dates.
Cheektowaga, NY -- three police dispatchers suspended for tracking a coworker's plate for monthsNY
Data misuse
THREE DISPATCHERS, ONE COWORKER, MONTHS OF SEARCHES. An internal audit at the Cheektowaga, New York Police Department found three public-safety dispatchers had used the town's Flock system for months to search another employee's license plate, and all three were suspended, Spectrum News reported on Oct 1, 2026. The department notified the Erie County District Attorney and says it is still determining whether any member of the public was searched, and that it has tightened rules on the system. It is another case where civilian staff, not sworn officers, held search credentials. NOT ESTABLISHED: names (the Institute for Justice, citing WKBW, lists three; Spectrum does not), the number of searches, why they tracked the coworker, and whether the DA will charge anyone. New York has no plate-reader misuse statute.
Congress -- Ban Flock Act (H.R. 10691) filed; Hawley unveils Stop Flock Abuse ActDC
Wrongful stop
THREE FEDERAL APPROACHES NOW, FROM BAN TO GUARDRAILS. In the week after the Senate hearing two more plate-reader bills appeared. The Ban Flock Act -- H.R. 10691, recorded as introduced Oct 1, 2026 and unveiled Oct 2 by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez with Sens. Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley -- would bar federal agencies from using plate readers or their data, cut federal grants to state and local governments that keep ALPR contracts, and let people sue the federal government. It was referred to nine House committees. Sen. Josh Hawley's Stop Flock Abuse Act, unveiled Sep 30, goes the other way: keep the cameras but delete data within 10 days unless tied to an investigation, ban facial recognition on the networks, require written approval and an audit log for every search, bar sale or sharing by local governments, and keep data encrypted in the US. Flock's CEO told the subcommittee Congress should write a federal framework. NOT ESTABLISHED: Hawley's bill number and cosponsors, the Senate number for the Ban Flock Act, and any markup date. None has had a committee vote.
Tulsa County, OK -- federal judge rules warrantless Flock location-history search unconstitutionalOK
Wrongful stop
A FEDERAL JUDGE HELD A WARRANTLESS FLOCK SEARCH UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND SUPPRESSED THE EVIDENCE. U.S. District Judge Sara E. Hill ruled in United States v. Melisa Susan Kyle, a drug case, that a Tulsa County deputy's warrantless search of a month of plate-reader location history was a Fourth Amendment search, CBS12 reported via OKC Fox on Oct 3, 2026. The deputy ran the California plate of Kyle's rental car through Flock and VehicleManager and got about 30 days of sightings, more than 50, across several states. The judge also found the deputy unlawfully extended the traffic stop without reasonable suspicion, and granted the motion to suppress. The ruling does not bar plate readers or treat a single scan as a search, and binds no other court. NOT ESTABLISHED: the exact ruling date (reported as the Thursday before Oct 3, likely Oct 1), the district, the case number, and whether prosecutors will appeal.
Lufkin, TX -- officer gets five years for Flock stalking of ex and her circleTX
Data misuse
FIVE YEARS IN PRISON. Former Lufkin officer Zachary Anthony Klein pleaded guilty on Sep 30, 2026 in Judge Todd Kassaw's Angelina County court to 100 counts of misuse of official information and was sentenced to five years in prison with 42 days' credit; the state agreed not to pursue stalking charges and a lifetime protective order was secured. District Attorney Amy Wren said investigators found more than 25,000 misuses, narrowed to 100 counts, and that the victims were his former girlfriend, her family and men she dated before and after the relationship. Two days earlier the judge had cut his bond from $500,000 to $250,000 over prosecutors' objection. Chief Travis Brazil said Flock use remains suspended. EARLIER: The largest ALPR misuse prosecution this map has recorded. A grand jury in the 159th Judicial District Court indicted Lufkin police officer Zachary Anthony Klein on Aug 21, 2026 on 100 counts of misuse of official information, each a third-degree felony, with bond set at $500,000. The 31-page indictment alleges he used his police access to locate vehicles belonging to 11 people from July 2024 through December 2025. THE SCALE IS DISPUTED BETWEEN SOURCES AND THE DIFFERENCE IS LARGE: the Lufkin Daily News, reporting from the indictment, describes searches on dozens of occasions; the Institute for Justice's database records that Klein allegedly searched for his ex-girlfriend and people she knew MORE THAN 10,000 TIMES. Both are recorded here rather than one being chosen, because the indictment charges 100 counts and a count is not the same as a search -- 10,000 searches yielding 100 charges is entirely consistent, and readers should know the count is a charging decision, not a measurement. Klein, an 11-year member of the department, was arrested the previous morning by Texas Rangers. TWO THINGS MAKE THIS DIFFERENT FROM THE OTHER MISUSE CASES HERE. First, it ran undetected from mid-2024 until the department happened to audit. Second, the response -- Chief Travis Brazil suspended the department's use of Flock entirely rather than disciplining an individual and carrying on, and asked the Texas Rangers to investigate from outside. A second officer was placed on administrative leave and has not been named. Mayor Mark Hicks said the allegations were serious, backed both investigations, and cautioned against reaching conclusions before the facts are known. Lufkin approved Flock in 2023. UPDATE, SEP 14 2026: the Texas Rangers cleared the second officer who had been placed on leave; Klein's case is unaffected. The department says its suspension of the cameras continues and is temporary. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Lufkin will restore Flock, and on what terms.
Hall County, GA -- seven sheriff's employees out in three weeks over Flock searchesGA
Data misuse
FIRST ARREST IN HALL COUNTY. The GBI arrested former Hall County Sheriff's Office investigator Justin Brown, 42, of Dahlonega on Sep 30, 2026 on two counts of misuse of a license plate reader system and two counts of violation of oath of office, saying he used the Flock system for non-law enforcement purposes; the GBI opened its case on Aug 18 after the sheriff's audit. SEVEN HALL COUNTY SHERIFF'S EMPLOYEES GONE IN SIXTEEN DAYS OVER FLOCK SEARCHES. An audit of the office's Flock use under Sheriff Gerald Couch removed two investigators by firing in August 2026 -- Brown (Aug 19, about 250 personal-use accesses) and Michael Atkins (Aug 24, at least four) -- then three deputies resigned in late August: Jason Orellana, who ran 10 searches at a co-worker's request, Taylor McArthur, the jail deputy who asked him to, and Austin Scott Flanagan (two personal searches). Investigator Melissa Wood was fired Sep 2 for repeatedly using Flock to follow one person's movements, and Deputy Brandon Sanders resigned Sep 4. The resignees were referred to Georgia POST. The request-a-colleague case matters: one deputy's credentials served another's personal curiosity, which a per-user audit only catches if someone reads it. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates Brown searched, whether anyone else in Hall will be charged, when the audit began, and the total search count. Sources disagree by one to two days on the resignation dates.
Pinellas County, FL -- two ex-deputies charged; one ran 381+ searches on a woman who turned him downFL
Data misuse
A MEDIA QUESTION, NOT AN AUDIT, FOUND IT. Former Pinellas County, Florida deputy Carl Gwynn is charged with four counts of unlawful computer access and one of official misconduct, accused of running more than 381 searches through Flock and other police systems on a woman who had turned down his advances; he first claimed the searches were official. A second former deputy, Travis Stanton, faces felony charges for allegedly using police databases to target a 17-year-old girl, showing up at her job and school. Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said a media inquiry prompted the review, called it a people problem rather than a product problem, and floated random checks and alerts on any plate queried unusually often -- none reported adopted as of Sep 30, 2026. Gualtieri is the same sheriff defending his 73-camera network against a county commissioner's resolution to end it (see Pinellas County). NOT ESTABLISHED: arrest and court dates, and whether Stanton's searches involved Flock.
Akron, OH -- officer fired over a fatal shooting searched Flock while on paid leaveOH
Data misuse
ON LEAVE FROM PATROL, STILL ON THE CAMERAS. Records first reported by the Akron Beacon Journal on Sep 30, 2026 show former Akron, Ohio police officer Davon Fields logged into the city's Flock plate-reader system several times while on paid administrative leave. Fields was put on leave in May 2026 and fired in August for policy violations in the 2024 fatal shooting of 15-year-old Jazmir Tucker, including failing to give medical aid. The city and the Summit County Sheriff's Office are both investigating the Flock access; he has not been charged, and the police union calls his firing political. The case raises the access question in its plainest form: in 2022 Akron police told council officers could reach Flock from cruisers or phones, and nothing reported shows access was cut when an officer was benched. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many searches, on whom, and whether Akron has changed who keeps access during leave.
Florida: 27 officers on leave, fired or arrested over plate-reader misuse (TCPalm count)FL
Data misuse
27 FLORIDA OFFICERS, BY ONE NEWSROOM'S COUNT. A TCPalm investigation counts 27 Florida law enforcement officers placed on leave, fired or arrested over plate-reader misuse, a total reached with two Pinellas County deputy arrests at the end of September 2026, as reported by the Florida Phoenix on Sep 30. The individual Florida pins on this map -- Haines City, Sarasota, Indian River County, Pinellas, a state trooper and others -- are part of that wave. Read the number both ways: it counts discipline that was discovered, much of it after reporters or audits started looking, so it measures detection as much as misconduct. It landed the same week Florida's deadline to clear plate readers off state highways passed. NOT ESTABLISHED: the period TCPalm covered, which agencies are on its list, and whether every case involved Flock rather than another plate-reader vendor. TCPalm's own story would settle all three.
Cobb County, GA -- Kennesaw man charged with knocking down Flock cameras in three jurisdictionsGA
Wrongful stop
A KENNESAW MAN WAS CHARGED WITH KNOCKING DOWN FLOCK CAMERAS IN THREE COBB COUNTY JURISDICTIONS. Cobb County police arrested James Ramirez, 20, on charges of interference with government property, criminal damage and criminal trespass, FOX 5 Atlanta reported Sep 30, 2026; police said he confessed. At Big Shanty Park he cut the cable to the solar panel, removed security screws and knocked the camera off its base; on Pine Mountain Road in Kennesaw he took down the top half of the pole and smashed the unit; at the Liberty Commons entrance on Old Highway 41 in Acworth officers found cut wires and a smashed camera. The Big Shanty camera photographed his white pickup and plate before it fell, which led police to him. No motive was released. NOT ESTABLISHED: the repair cost, whether other sites were hit, and the court outcome.
SoundThinking (ShotSpotter) -- owner agrees to go private at $8 a share as city renewals slipCA
Wrongful stop
SHOTSPOTTER'S OWNER AGREED TO GO PRIVATE AT $8 A SHARE AS CITY RENEWALS SLIPPED. SoundThinking announced on Sep 29, 2026 that affiliates of Transom Capital Group will buy the company by tender offer for $8.00 a share in cash plus a contingent value right worth up to $3.00 more, about $114 million in enterprise value, or $159 million if the CVR pays in full; the CVR pays only if 2027 ShotSpotter and SafePointe revenue reaches $73.5 million, scaling up to $87 million. Holders of about 33 percent of shares, including Veradace Partners and Gary Lauder's group, agreed to tender, the board approved unanimously, and closing is expected in the fourth quarter of 2026. The company's Nov 12, 2026 third-quarter report showed revenue flat at $25.0 million, a net loss of $8.5 million, cash down to $9.5 million, and about $1.0 million of revenue lost to non-renewals or delayed renewals by several unnamed customers; it cites more than 300 customers and about 2,100 agencies. Chicago ended ShotSpotter in Sep 2024, Denver's contract runs out Dec 31, 2026, and Detroit took a nine-month extension. NOT ESTABLISHED: the tender expiry date, which customers did not renew, and what the new owner plans for pricing or city contracts.
Lexington, KY -- armed officers surround innocent couple's home after Flock description searchKY
Wrongful stop
NO PLATE, ONE MATCH, AND GUNS AT THE DOOR. Before 4 a.m. on Sep 26, 2026 Lexington, Kentucky police investigating a road-rage assault searched Flock not by plate but by the victim's description of the vehicle's type and colour. Police say one truck came back. The victim, shown a photo, said it looked right, and officers went to the home of Will Penn and his fiancee. The couple says more than a dozen cruisers came; doorbell video shows an officer pounding on the door with a gun in hand, and the department says at least one other officer had a weapon out but not pointed. Officers saw the people did not match the suspect, apologized and left. Commander Daniel Burnett says plate readers help solve crimes. This is the description-search feature at work: no misread, just a resemblance treated as a lead. Mayor Linda Gorton has announced a Flock review panel. NOT ESTABLISHED: the panel's members and timeline, and whether bodycam footage the couple requested was released.
Hancock County, IN -- deputy charged with 441 counts over 6,190 Flock searchesIN
Data misuse
6,190 SEARCHES, ABOUT 40 OF THEM ON DUTY. Hancock County, Indiana sheriff's deputy James Heneghan, 33, was arrested in late September 2026 and charged with 441 counts of intimidation, official misconduct and fraud. Indiana State Police allege he ran more than 6,190 Flock searches between December 2024 and March 2026: over 1,100 on his wife's car, over 1,100 on a man who knew her, more than 200 on a high-school ex-girlfriend, and others on an ex's husband -- and that he pulled over an ex-girlfriend's child after running the plate. The case began not with an audit but with a family member reporting intimidating texts in April. He pleaded not guilty; bond was $5,000; a pretrial conference is set for Oct 29. Fifteen months of searches went unflagged by the agency. NOT ESTABLISHED: which counts are felonies, the exact arrest date, and whether the sheriff's office has changed access rules. Watch Oct 29.
Philadelphia City Council asks Harrisburg to ban or restrict plate readersPA
Wrongful stop
PHILADELPHIA COUNCIL, UNANIMOUSLY: BAN PLATE READERS STATEWIDE OR REGULATE THEM. On Sep 24, 2026 City Council passed Councilmember Rue Landau's non-binding resolution asking Pennsylvania lawmakers to ban automated license plate readers such as Flock, or at minimum set strong guardrails; Landau called the technology widely unregulated. It joins Gov. Josh Shapiro, who said in August he would welcome a bipartisan ban. NBC10 counts more than 2,000 readers in the Philadelphia metro area, over half of them Flock's. The resolution changes nothing on the street by itself. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Philadelphia police run Flock, and which Harrisburg bill, if any, it backs. Watch the House Transportation and Judiciary committees, which held a joint hearing on plate readers. THE CITY'S OWN POLICE RUN 137 FIXED READERS. Philadelphia police operate 137 fixed-location plate readers, and patrol cars carry more, the Northeast Times reported Sep 21, 2026, citing PhillyVoice; a crowd-sourced count puts the citywide total, public and private, as high as 656. The report does not say which vendor the police use. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether those readers are Flock, and the date of the joint House Transportation and Judiciary hearing.
N.D. California -- consolidated Flock class action; judge questions standingCA
Wrongful stop
A FEDERAL JUDGE IN SAN FRANCISCO QUESTIONED ON SEP 24, 2026 WHETHER DRIVERS SUING FLOCK OVER DATA SHARING HAVE STANDING. In re: Flock Group Inc. Automated License Plate Reader Litigation, N.D. Cal. No. 3:26-cv-02375, consolidates putative class actions against Flock Group Inc.; the lead case, Eldridge v. Flock Group, was filed in Contra Costa County Superior Court and removed to federal court on Mar 18, 2026. The plaintiffs say Flock collects and aggregates Californians' movements and let out-of-state and federal agencies search the data without a compliant privacy policy, in violation of Cal. Civ. Code 1798.90.5 et seq. On Jun 25, 2026 Judge Vince Chhabria appointed Philip Fraietta and Julia Venditti of Bursor & Fisher interim co-lead class counsel; Edelson PC also represents plaintiffs, and Arnold & Porter (Douglas Winthrop) represents Flock. At a Sep 24, 2026 hearing Chhabria asked what concrete injury the plaintiffs suffered, said a statutory violation alone is not an Article III injury, questioned whether sharing with additional agencies creates a distinct privacy harm, noted that California officers have reportedly shared Flock data with immigration authorities too, and pointed out that a standing dismissal would send the case back to state court -- which plaintiffs' counsel Michael Terlep said they would then seek by remand. He took the matter under submission. Law Street Media counted 23 federal suits naming Flock as of Aug 27, 2026, most filed in 2026 and five in March alone; the consolidated docket had 59 entries in five months. NOT ESTABLISHED: Chhabria's ruling on standing and whether the case is remanded to Contra Costa County.
A Senate subcommittee opens the first federal inquiry into FlockUS
Wrongful stop
Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri, who chairs the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism, wrote to Flock CEO Garrett Langley on Aug 26, 2026 opening an inquiry into the company's collection, retention and dissemination of camera data, with a Sept 8 deadline to produce documents. Citing Flock's own figures, the letter describes about 120,000 cameras across 49 states and more than 20 billion vehicle scans a month, and argues Congress never authorised such a network, leaving the company's internal policies as the only practical safeguard. WHAT MAKES THIS DIFFERENT FROM A STATEMENT is the specificity of the demands: every confirmed instance of misuse since Jan 1 2021, what a user must enter to justify a search, the restrictions on search purpose, the parameters for statewide and nationwide searches, camera placement, accuracy and security, contracts with local governments, and the company's revenue sources and investors. Flock spokesperson Paris Lewbel said the company had received the letter and would respond. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the documents will be produced. Axios reported the letter is a request and that a subpoena would be the next step if it is refused; none has been issued. Reporting also notes no bill has been introduced in Congress to ban ALPRs outright. The letter cites St Charles County, Missouri, which is on this map. UPDATE, 14 SEP 2026: THE DEADLINE PASSED ON 8 SEPTEMBER AND NO PUBLIC REPORTING ESTABLISHES WHETHER THE DOCUMENTS WERE PRODUCED. Searching six days after the date returns only coverage from the announcement week. Flock said at the time it would respond; nothing confirms it did, nothing reports a refusal, and no subpoena has been reported. A NON-EVENT IS STILL A FINDING and this map should say so rather than leave the record reading as though the deadline is still ahead. TWO DETAILS ADDED FROM THE SENATOR'S OWN RELEASE, which is now the primary source here rather than the news accounts of it. First, the letter did NOT mention or threaten a subpoena -- reporting noted Hawley COULD seek one, which is not the same thing, and the request was framed as an opportunity to cooperate voluntarily. Second, the letter ties the data question to MONEY: Flock's roughly $8.3 billion valuation creates pressure to monetise what it holds, and Hawley points to uncertainty over how the company or its customers might sell or repurpose driver information. That is a commercial-use concern from a Senate chair, and it is the same argument the Idaho tort claims make about AI training data, arriving from a different direction. The letter also cites a Milwaukee officer alleged to have searched his girlfriend's plate, alongside the St Charles County case already noted here. UPDATE, 22 SEP 2026: THE INQUIRY WIDENED TO THE WHOLE INDUSTRY AND BECAME A HEARING. On Sep 3 Hawley sent document demands to Flock's three main competitors -- Axon, Motorola Solutions and Verkada -- with a Sep 16 deadline, citing among other cases a Milwaukee officer who ran 124 personal plate searches. On Sep 18 he invited all four CEOs to testify on Sep 23 at a subcommittee hearing titled Always Watching: Flock's Nationwide AI Surveillance Network. That matters for the vendor-swap pattern on this map: a city leaving Flock for Axon or Motorola is now leaving one company under Senate inquiry for another. STILL NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Flock produced the Sep 8 documents, whether any CEO will appear, and whether a subpoena follows -- none has been mentioned. UPDATE, SEP 23: THE CEOS DID NOT COME. Flock's Garrett Langley, Axon's Rick Smith, Motorola's Greg Brown and Verkada's Filip Kaliszan all skipped the hearing. Testimony came from a woman jailed 13 days on a bad Flock hit, the Institute for Justice, the ACLU, researcher Benn Jordan and Pinal County, AZ Sheriff Ross Teeple, who had dropped Flock and told senators the company misled him about its use of AI. No subpoena was announced. A week later Hawley was reported to be readying a Stop Flock Abuse Act on data retention, security and AI-camera safeguards; it had no bill number as of Sep 30.
Indianapolis -- two IMPD officers face firing over Flock misuse; new search rulesIN
Data misuse
TWO INDIANAPOLIS OFFICERS SENT TO THE MERIT BOARD FOR FIRING. IMPD Chief Tanya Terry has recommended that two officers be fired for misusing Flock plate readers; the Civilian Police Merit Board will decide. The first used the cameras for personal reasons; the second surfaced when that case widened into a broader review in August 2026. Both lost police powers. IMPD now requires a case number and offence code for every search, stronger audits, and a signed acknowledgment from every officer who keeps access, and says it would back state legislation. No criminal referral has been reported. NOT established: the officers' names, how many searches, and whose plates. Ask whether the case numbers are checked against real cases -- Alexandria, Virginia found dozens of searches where they were missing. FIVE OFFICERS CHARGED, AND THE PROSECUTOR SAYS IT IS THE BEGINNING. On Sep 23, 2026 Marion County Prosecutor Ryan Mears charged five Indianapolis police officers over Flock searches found in IMPD audits in August and September: Michael Rogers, accused of thousands of improper searches; Jonathan Schultz, 26 counts including stalking, accused of running more than 1,000 plates including women he met in public; Cassandra Crawley and Abigail Cramer, hundreds of searches each; and Matthew Binford, accused of using a superior officer's laptop to track his ex-wife. The charges are fraud and official misconduct, with stalking for Schultz. All five were suspended and recommended for firing; Cramer resigned. Indiana has no plate-reader misuse offence, so prosecutors used general statutes. This replaces the earlier picture of two officers sent to the merit board with no criminal referral. NOT ESTABLISHED: court dates, pleas, and whether the two merit-board officers are among the five.
Naperville, IL -- officer ran a man's plate about 150 times, retired before disciplineIL
Data misuse
A NAPERVILLE OFFICER SEARCHED A STRANGER'S TRUCK ABOUT 150 TIMES IN FLOCK AND LEFT THE FORCE UNDISCIPLINED, ABC7 CHICAGO REPORTED SEP 23, 2026. Patrick Dowhen, never accused of a crime, says Naperville officer Oscar Maldonado tracked him after Maldonado began a relationship with Dowhen's ex-fiancee. Dowhen took his truck apart looking for a tracker before complaining to Chief Jason Arres; an internal investigation opened in September 2025 for official misconduct and stalking. In his interrogation Maldonado admitted using Flock for personal reasons; investigators found about 150 searches of Dowhen's vehicle over three months in 2025 and more than 100 pieces of evidence of ethics and policy violations, and rejected his claim that he was protecting his new partner's family. Maldonado resigned before his disciplinary meeting, which closed the case, and retired May 1, 2026; the department reported him to the Illinois Law Enforcement Training and Standards Board and updated its Flock policy in September 2026. Dowhen obtained a stalking no-contact order in Will County, later replaced by a two-year no-contact agreement. The Will County Sheriff referred the case to prosecutors in early March 2026; the State's Attorney would not confirm an investigation. Maldonado's lawyer, Jeff Tomczak, says misusing Flock violates policy but is not a crime. ABC7 counted 14 Chicago-area Flock misuse cases, at least five referred to prosecutors. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Will County charges him, and the exact search dates.
Which state plate-reader laws reach the vendor? None says trainUS
Wrongful stop
NONE OF THESE LAWS SAYS 'TRAIN'. TWO OF THEM STILL REACH THE VENDOR. Checked on the official legislature sites, read through a text-extraction tool, so check the exact wording before quoting: Minnesota, Maine, Montana, New Hampshire, with California read through the Assembly's own analysis. NEW HAMPSHIRE: plates may not be recorded or transmitted anywhere and must be purged within three minutes unless there is a hit, so no vendor holds anything to learn from. MINNESOTA: data may not be shared, sold or traded to anyone beyond qualifying police agencies. The duty lies on agencies, but state law binds government contractors as if they were the agency. Minnesota also covers private cameras whose data are shared with police. MONTANA: a 90-day cap binds the 'custodian' of the data, and police-gathered data may not be sold. MAINE: only listed public uses are lawful at all, with a 21-day cap. CALIFORNIA: the sale ban binds public agencies only, and there is no retention cap. The 2025 fix was vetoed. Vermont and Utah could not be read. Ask your council: does our contract let the vendor do what our state's statute forbids us to do? UTAH REACHES THE VENDOR; VERMONT DOES NOT. Utah's plate-reader law defines the 'governmental entity' it regulates to include anyone acting as the agency's agent or on its behalf, so a vendor holding plates for police is bound by the same rules: use only for listed purposes, a nine-month retention cap, no sharing beyond those purposes, and no sale. It does not cover a private company collecting plates for itself. Vermont's law, rewritten from July 2025, is stricter on police -- seven days of active access, everything sent to the Department of Public Safety, 18 months then destruction -- but places every duty on agencies and the department. It has no sale ban and says nothing about vendors. Ask your council in Vermont: does our contract stop the vendor from keeping a copy?
Washington, DC -- MPD investigating two potential Flock misuse casesDC
Data misuse
DC POLICE CONFIRM TWO POTENTIAL FLOCK MISUSE CASES. In a letter answering ten questions from Councilmember Brooke Pinto, Interim Chief Jeffery Carroll said the Metropolitan Police Department is investigating two cases of potential misuse of its Flock technology, one first flagged by Flock's auditing tool, WJLA reported Sep 21, 2026. The letter gave no details. It says Flock flags activity for review rather than misuse, for example a plate run repeatedly over more than 30 days with no open case, and that a department audit will be released later in 2026. The DC Police Union, led by Gregg Pemberton, alleges management misused Flock data in an internal investigation; MPD says that use was proper because the alleged misconduct was potentially criminal, and the grievance is headed to arbitration. MPD's April 2026 plate-reader policy requires a legal basis or reasonable suspicion for queries, and MPD says it is not in Flock's National Lookup. NOT ESTABLISHED: who is under investigation, what was searched, and the audit's findings.
A retired detective charged over 1,000 Flock lookups of an exMA
Data misuse
MORE THAN 1,000 LOOKUPS, ONE MISDEMEANOR. Former Braintree detective Mark Sherrick, 55, faces a criminal harassment charge, a misdemeanor, with arraignment set for Sep 29, 2026. Court documents allege he ran Flock more than 1,000 times on his ex-girlfriend's car after their 2024 breakup. They also allege he put a GPS tracker on her car and stood in her yard before dawn. Investigators matched tracker alerts in his department email to her movements. He retired in April 2025 while the investigation was under way, and the charge came about 17 months later. Braintree says it holds officers to the highest standards of conduct. Not established: why the database searches carry no separate charge, and whether Braintree audited Flock use by anyone else. Ask the prosecutor's office and Braintree PD.
Two House bills now target plate readers, one through highway moneyUS
Wrongful stop
TWO BIPARTISAN HOUSE BILLS NOW TARGET PLATE READERS, AND ONE USES HIGHWAY MONEY AS THE LEVER. The NO FLOCK Act, H.R. 10366, from Reps. Raja Krishnamoorthi (D-IL) and Michael Cloud (R-TX), would require every state to limit ALPR use to specified public-safety and toll-enforcement purposes or lose 10 percent of its federal surface-transportation funds each year after a two-year phase-in -- the same mechanism Congress used for the drinking age. A second bill, H.R. 9716, introduced July 15 by Rep. Keith Self (R-TX) and joined by Idaho's Russ Fulcher, would make federal agents get a warrant before tapping state and local camera data. Both follow Senator Hawley's inquiry into Flock. Neither has had a committee vote. NOT ESTABLISHED: the NO FLOCK Act's exact introduction date and committee referral, and what counts as a public-safety purpose -- the text will decide whether stalking-style searches are actually barred. WHAT TO WATCH: committee referral and cosponsor count on congress.gov. A THIRD HOUSE BILL: NO FEDERAL MONEY FOR PLATE READERS. Rep. Thomas Massie's Flock-Off Act, H.R. 10221, filed around Sep 2, 2026 with six cosponsors, would bar federal funds from paying for or supporting license-plate-reading and biometric camera systems, including the software and cloud services behind them. State, local and tribal governments running federally funded systems would have 180 days to shut them off. Exceptions: systems within a mile of the northern or southern border, and highway-funded readers used only for tolls. Cameras bought with local money are untouched. NOT ESTABLISHED: who the cosponsors are, which committees have it, and whether it has moved.
St. Lucie County, FL -- at least 14 unpermitted plate-reader cameras, owner unknownFL
Wrongful stop
FOURTEEN CAMERAS NOBODY ADMITS TO OWNING. St. Lucie County, Florida officials found at least 14 license-plate-reader cameras installed in the county without a permit, WFTV reported on Sep 17, 2026, and could not say who put them up or who can see the data. Commissioners said they would watch the cameras in case an owner came forward; county staff can switch them off. Later coverage, relayed by tech outlets and the Washington Post on Oct 1, said 11 of the 14 were still unclaimed. It surfaced as agencies were clearing cameras off state roads under Florida's Aug 31 order (see the FDOT record). The case is the clearest example on this map of the problem the access-list question raises: a plate reader feeds whoever holds the account, and a county can host a network it never approved. NOT ESTABLISHED: the owner, who has access, whether they are Flock units, and whether the county removed them. Ask the county for the permit file and Flock for the account holder.
GainSec: an independent researcher documents dozens of security flaws in Flock camerasUS
Wrongful stop
AN INDEPENDENT RESEARCHER HAS SPENT MORE THAN A YEAR TAKING FLOCK'S HARDWARE APART, AND THE FINDINGS ARE PUBLIC. Jon "GainSec" Gaines publishes the work on gainsec.com under the name Bird Hunting Season. Jun 27, 2025: flaws in Flock plate-reader firmware (through version 2.2) and Raven gunshot-detection devices (before 1.3) were published as CVEs -- an on-chip debug interface left without proper access control (CVE-2025-47822 and CVE-2025-47819, rated 6.4), plus hardcoded passwords and code stored in cleartext. Oct 2, 2025: CVE-2025-59403. The Android app that runs the camera feed on Falcon, Sparrow and Bravo devices exposed administrative functions on port 8080 with no login, including one that switches on remote debugging (ADB) and hands a shell to anyone on the same wireless network. CISA's scorers rated it 9.8 of 10, critical. Nov 2025: Gaines compiled the findings into a white paper on GitHub. In Senate Judiciary testimony on Sep 23, 2026, researcher Benn Jordan credited Gaines with 55 Flock vulnerabilities, some filed through MITRE, and described pressing a camera's button three times to reach its data or reprogram it in about a minute. Aug 9, 2026: Gaines presented the whole project, The Final Flight, on the main stage at Def Con 34. Sep 17, 2026: he published Molting, a review of a Flock Falcon/Sparrow firmware image released through Distributed Denial of Secrets, checking it against the flaws he had disclosed. A separate analysis of the same leak by Micah Lee found the camera running Android 8.1, last patched in June 2018, with API keys hardcoded in its software. FLOCK'S RESPONSE has shifted: at first it said exploitation needs physical access and detailed knowledge of the hardware; in January 2026 it called the findings theoretical and immaterial; in March 2026 its chief information security officer, Chris Castaldo, called them legitimate but low severity, saying the tested unit had never been deployed or updated. Gaines has since applied the same method to Verkada cameras and alarm hubs (Verkracked, Sep-Oct 2026) and to a Digital Ally/Uniview facial-recognition access terminal (Jul 2026). NOT ESTABLISHED: how many of the disclosed flaws are fixed on cameras now on US streets -- Flock has not published a per-finding remediation list.
Texas City, TX -- two misuse cases; search access cut by two-thirdsTX
Data misuse
TWO CASES, AND TWO-THIRDS OF USERS LOST ACCESS. Texas City police disclosed in mid-September 2026 two possible misuses of the department's Flock plate readers: a civilian employee, who has been disciplined, and a sergeant, whose case is still under investigation. Interim Chief James Patterson then cut the number of people who can search the system by about two-thirds, leaving only detectives and supervisors of sergeant rank and above; every search now needs three justification fields, including a case number; every user is audited monthly; and all staff, the chief included, went through an initial audit. The city runs 26 fixed Flock readers and two mobile units, in use since 2023. NOT ESTABLISHED: who the two employees are, what they searched, the sergeant's outcome, and whether either case was referred for prosecution.
Two months jailed on a false face matchND
Data misuse
Angela Lipps was arrested at gunpoint by US Marshals in Tennessee on Jul 14, 2025, on a Fargo, North Dakota warrant built on a face-recognition lead: West Fargo police ran a Clearview AI search and passed on a 'potential suspect'. She sat in a Tennessee jail for more than three months before extradition, then in Cass County, North Dakota, until prosecutors dismissed all charges on Dec 23, 2025 -- more than five months in custody, CNN reported. She lost her home, car and dog. In March 2026 Fargo's chief acknowledged errors and later resigned. The dismissal was without prejudice. UPDATE, SEP 15, 2026: SHE IS SUING FOR $10 MILLION. Lipps filed a federal lawsuit in North Dakota against the City of Fargo and Detective Lucas Heck, with five claims including false arrest, malicious prosecution and a policy-and-training claim against the city. The complaint says the face-recognition match, run through West Fargo police and a state intelligence centre, came from a photo on the suspect's fake ID rather than the bank footage, and that Heck did not disclose that. It says she was held on a $100,000 bond through Thanksgiving and her 50th birthday, sometimes without her dentures or medication, before prosecutors dropped all eight felony counts on Dec 24, 2025. Fargo's chief admitted investigative errors in March 2026 and resigned that month. These are allegations; the city had not responded.
Indian River County, FL sergeant: 574 searches of two platesFL
Data misuse
574 SEARCHES OF THE SAME TWO PLATES, LOGGED AS 'SUS'. An audit of Flock logs at the Indian River County, Florida Sheriff's Office found Sgt. John Finnegan, 41, ran the same two license plates 574 times between March and October 2025, entering reasons such as 'SUS' and 'daytime search for best result'. He was put on paid administrative leave in September 2026 -- nearly a year after the searches stopped. The sheriff's office under Sheriff Eric Flowers says its audit had already begun and is continuing. The free-text reason field is the lesson: Flock accepted a three-letter abbreviation as justification hundreds of times and nobody looked until 2026. A Vero Beach city officer is separately under investigation. NOT established: whose plates they were, whether prosecutors are involved, and the outcome.
Carson City, NV -- sheriff's employee resigns after audit; outside auditor hiredNV
Data misuse
AN EMPLOYEE RESIGNED, AND THE SHERIFF BROUGHT IN AN OUTSIDE AUDITOR. Carson City Sheriff Ken Furlong said in mid-September 2026 that an audit turned up questionable activity in a sheriff's office employee's Flock search and that the employee resigned. He did not say what was searched or whether the case was referred for criminal review. Two changes followed: an independent auditor, paid outside the department, will check whether searches were justified and tied to real cases, and the office opened a public transparency portal. Furlong said the old arrangement amounted to the agency overseeing itself, which he called never a good thing. Carson City has about 37 Flock cameras and keeps data 30 days. NOT ESTABLISHED: the employee's role, the searches, and any referral.
Atlanta -- department-wide audit flags 79 Flock searchesGA
Wrongful stop
79 FLAGGED OUT OF 115,578. Atlanta police audited every Flock search officers had made in 2026 -- 115,578 of them -- at Mayor Andre Dickens's direction, and flagged about 79 for further review, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported Sep 15, 2026. The city says a flag does not mean a rule or law was broken. Chief Darin Schierbaum said the follow-up investigation should finish within 60 days, and the department has begun monthly usage audits and tighter limits on outside agencies. Dickens wants new city rules on privacy and oversight and has asked for a council work session and public hearing. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many officers are involved, what the flagged searches were, any discipline, and the hearing date. The 60-day clock runs to about mid-November.
At least 20 Georgia officials arrested for Flock misuseGA
Data misuse
Georgia's running total reached at least 20 public officials arrested statewide for misusing the Flock license-plate system, per Reason's Jul 31, 2026 tally -- the densest cluster of ALPR-misuse prosecutions anywhere in the country, and the aggregate behind the individual Georgia pins on this map. Institute for Justice attorney Michael Soyfer called it just the tip of the iceberg, arguing the reason misuse goes undetected nationwide is that plate searches run with almost no oversight -- routinely without reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or a warrant, sometimes logged under a rationale as thin as the words criminal justice. BOTH READINGS OF THE NUMBER, per the standing caveat on every misuse aggregate here: Flock introduced its AI Audit Assistance tool in April 2026 and says it has helped agencies find cases that would otherwise have gone undetected -- so part of the arrest wave is better detection, not worse behaviour. Soyfer's counter is on the record too: there is little public information on how the audit tools work, Flock's customer is the police department, and relying on them is leaving the police to police themselves -- reactive Whac-A-Mole where the Fourth Amendment prescribes a prophylactic warrant requirement. Courts have so far declined to require one for plate searches; the Norfolk plaintiffs are appealing. Pinned at Georgia's centroid as a statewide aggregate. UPDATE, 14 SEP 2026: FOUR MORE, INCLUDING A STATE CORRECTIONS AGENT. Since the Savannah arrests the GBI has charged four more people with misusing Flock, each after the employing agency referred its own staff: former Covington officer Michael Canty (arrested Aug 26); Georgia Department of Corrections Special Agent in Charge Robert Keim (Sep 1) -- the first state-agency official in the wave; Anthony Trapani, accused of misuse at Acworth police that continued after he moved to Emerson police in 2025 (Sep 14); and former Colquitt County deputy Bentley Hughes, charged six days after his sheriff asked for the probe (Sep 14). With Clayton County on Sep 2, that is five Georgia agencies in under three weeks. The Trapani case is the one to note: misuse that followed an officer from one department to the next. NOT ESTABLISHED in any release: whose vehicles were searched, or how often. Earlier the same summer the GBI arrested a Conyers dispatch supervisor (Jul 22), a former Polk County officer who searched Cedartown's cameras (Aug 7) and the Dallas police 911 director (Aug 12). Each now has its own pin; these are the GBI's announcements, not a new statewide total. UPDATE, SEP 4: THE STATE'S OWN COUNT IS 38. Georgia's officer-certification body, POST, has 38 open cases stemming from discipline over alleged Flock misuse, its executive director Chris Harvey told WSB-TV on Sep 4, 2026. That is a separate measure from Reason's 20 arrests: it counts certification cases, and Harvey said agencies only have to report arrests, firings and suspensions of 30 days or more -- lighter discipline never reaches POST, so the real number is higher.
A council vote is a decision, not a removalUS
Wrongful stop
A COUNCIL VOTE IS A DECISION, NOT A REMOVAL. This map holds 167 records marked `removed`, and each assumes that when a jurisdiction ended its contract the cameras came down. TWO DOCUMENTED CASES SAY THAT IS AN ASSUMPTION. In LITTLETON, MASSACHUSETTS the Select Board ordered all six cameras powered down in May 2026 while it reviewed the technology and the governance policies -- and found the vendor had turned them back on by itself. The town moved to cancel outright, ordered the cameras removed and had the electricity cut. In EVANSTON, ILLINOIS the city terminated in late August 2025 and deactivated 19 cameras; Flock then BEGAN REINSTALLING CAMERAS ACROSS THE CITY, apparently without the knowledge of local officials or residents. Evanston issued a CEASE-AND-DESIST ORDER in September, after which the company said it would uninstall them. TWO TOWNS, TWO STATES, TEN MONTHS APART, THE SAME PATTERN: service a customer had ended was restored, and in both cases it took a further enforcement step -- an electricity cut, a legal order -- before the hardware actually stopped. WHAT THIS SHOULD CHANGE ABOUT HOW COUNTS ARE READ, INCLUDING OURS: every tally of cancellations on this subject, ours and the seven public trackers, records the DECISION. None of them verifies the removal. NOT ESTABLISHED: how often this happens. Two cases is a pattern worth naming and not a rate. THE QUESTION TO ASK any jurisdiction on a cancellation list is simply whether the cameras are physically gone and on what date -- which is answerable, and which nobody appears to be asking.
Four accuracy numbers, four different denominatorsUS
Wrongful stop
FOUR ACCURACY NUMBERS CIRCULATE AND THEY MEASURE FOUR DIFFERENT THINGS. This is the most misquoted area of the plate-reader argument and the confusion runs in both directions, so here they are with their denominators. FLOCK ADVERTISES 93 PER CENT READ ACCURACY -- the share of plates the camera transcribes correctly. THE EFF MEASURED STATE MISREADS AT ABOUT ONE IN TEN in November 2024, the same kind of measure from an outside party. ROSEVILLE, CALIFORNIA FOUND 71 PER CENT OF ALERTS WRONG across 1,427 alerts in 2023 and 2024, from the police department's own analysis -- but that is the share of ALERTS, not of reads, and the two are not comparable. A VALLEJO POLICE STUDY reported in Police Chief magazine put HIT-LEVEL error as high as 37 per cent. AND THE LAPD INSPECTOR GENERAL FOUND 32.3 PER CENT OF STOLEN-VEHICLE ALERTS FALSE across two months, WITH THE CAMERAS READING CORRECTLY -- that one is database error, not recognition error. WHY THE 71 PER CENT FIGURE IS BOTH ACCURATE AND MISLEADING: a system can read plates correctly almost every time and still produce mostly false alerts, because genuinely wanted vehicles are rare. A high alert-error rate is arithmetically compatible with a high read-accuracy rate. Anyone citing 71 per cent as the camera's error rate is wrong; anyone citing 93 per cent as evidence the alerts are reliable is also wrong. THESE RATES COMPOUND RATHER THAN SUBSTITUTE. A misread can produce a false alert; so can a correct read against a stale hotlist; and the Institute for Justice found MACHINE ERROR ACCOUNTS FOR ONLY ABOUT A THIRD of its 27 documented wrongful-stop cases. AT FLOCK'S OWN STATED SCALE of more than 20 billion vehicle scans a month, even the vendor's 93 per cent implies on the order of 1.4 billion misreads monthly -- which is why a per-read rate is the wrong unit for arguing about consequences, and why the alert and hit-level rates are the ones that reach people.
Colquitt County deputy arrested six days after the referralGA
Data misuse
THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE REFERRED IT ON SEPT 8; THE GBI ARRESTED HIM SIX DAYS LATER. Former Colquitt County deputy Bentley Hughes, 37, was arrested on Sept 14, 2026 on two counts of misusing a license plate reader system and two counts of violating his oath of office, after the sheriff's office asked the GBI to look at allegations that he used its Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes. The case goes to the Southern Judicial Circuit District Attorney. It is one of two Georgia Flock arrests the GBI announced that day and part of a run of state referrals that no other state matches -- because Georgia has a specific misuse offence and departments are referring their own audit findings. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates were searched, how many times, or how the allegation surfaced.
He left the department; his access to its cameras apparently did notGA
Data misuse
HE LEFT THE DEPARTMENT; HIS ACCESS TO ITS CAMERAS APPARENTLY DID NOT. The GBI arrested Anthony Trapani, 32, on Sept 14, 2026 on two counts of misusing a license plate reader system and one of violating his oath. According to the GBI, he used the Acworth Police Department's Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes while he worked there, and the misuse continued after he transferred to the Emerson Police Department in 2025. Acworth asked for the investigation. The detail that matters is the one the release implies without explaining: searches of Acworth's system continuing after he was no longer an Acworth officer, whether through credentials never revoked or through Emerson's shared access. Either answer is a governance failure other departments can check today. NOT ESTABLISHED: how he reached Acworth's data after leaving, and whose plates he searched. ASK: when an officer leaves, how long until their credentials and any inter-agency sharing are cut?
The reason field, read at scale, says LOLUS
Wrongful stop
THE REASON FIELD, READ AT SCALE, SAYS 'LOL'. The Electronic Frontier Foundation analysed Flock search logs obtained through public-records requests, covering networks of more than 82,000 cameras, and published on Sept 14, 2026 the reasons officers typed to justify searches. Barberton, Ohio police logged searches as 'LOL' for more than two years; Richmond, California as 'Hehe'; Corona, California as 'WEIRD KID'; Lake County, Indiana as 'LMAO'; Eatonton, Georgia and Lake County, Ohio entered keyboard mashing. Accountability varied: Richmond counselled its officers, Columbus said a 90-day union-contract limit barred discipline, and Thornton said its 'weird' searches checked out. Flock replaced free text with a dropdown of offence categories in late 2025, which makes nonsense harder to type and false reasons easier to pick -- Mooresville's officer chose motor-vehicle infraction 29 times. Read it with Norfolk's 'la la la la': the justification field records whatever is typed, and nobody reads it unless a records request forces them to. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many searches carried nonsense reasons in total.
Officer fired for passing Flock data to DV-suspect cousinCA
Data misuse
FIRED FOR HANDING FLOCK LOCATIONS TO A DOMESTIC-VIOLENCE SUSPECT. A San Jose police officer, not named, was fired in September 2026 after using his personal phone to pull Flock plate-reader data and share vehicle locations with his cousin -- a suspect in a domestic-violence case. Chief Paul Joseph said an officer who violates public trust that severely cannot keep the badge, and referred the case to California POST for decertification. NOT established: how it was detected, what the victim's exposure was, and whether anyone will be charged -- neither the officer nor his cousin had been as of Sep 13. This is the misuse case with the worst direction of harm: not an officer watching someone in his own life, but the network used to help an alleged abuser find a target. San Jose runs about 474 Flock cameras and is already the subject of an IJ Fourth Amendment suit.
University of Georgia police -- IT employee demoted after 85 personal Flock searchesGA
Data misuse
A CAMPUS POLICE IT WORKER RAN 85 UNAUTHORIZED FLOCK SEARCHES ON HIS OWN MATTERS. A University of Georgia Police Department IT employee -- not a sworn officer, investigator or analyst, though he sometimes assisted cases with digital forensics -- was suspended without pay for 20 days and demoted after an internal-affairs investigation found he searched the department's Flock system 85 times without authorization, the university said on Sep 11, 2026; WSB-TV reported the details again on Oct 20. He ran 19 searches for a vehicle in a hit-and-run involving his wife and 66 for a red pickup tied to a theft at a fencing business where he was a customer. A department-wide audit ordered by Chief Jeffery Clark found it. He will return to a role outside the police department and faces no criminal charges. NOT ESTABLISHED: his name, when the searches ran, and whether the case was referred to the GBI.
Braselton, GA -- officer fired over 2024-25 Flock misuse, sent to GBIGA
Data misuse
BRASELTON FIRES AN OFFICER FOR FLOCK MISUSE, A YEAR AFTER ITS CHIEF WAS CHARGED. The Braselton, Georgia Police Department said on Sep 11, 2026 that an officer was terminated on Aug 20 after an investigation found he improperly used the Flock camera system in 2024 and 2025. A comprehensive audit found no other misuse, and the case went to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation. The officer was not named. Braselton's former police chief, Michael Steffman, was charged in 2025 with stalking women through the same kind of cameras. NOT ESTABLISHED: the officer's name, what he searched and why, how many times, and whether the GBI will bring charges.
Los Angeles, CA -- U.S. v. Riley: eight plate-reader photos of two cars not a Fourth Amendment searchCA
Wrongful stop
A FEDERAL JUDGE IN LOS ANGELES HELD ON SEP 10, 2026 THAT PULLING ABOUT EIGHT PLATE-READER PHOTOS OF TWO CARS WAS NOT A FOURTH AMENDMENT SEARCH. In United States v. Riley, Judge Virginia Phillips of the Central District of California denied a motion to suppress by Melvin Riley and Kenneth Holley Jr., charged with Hobbs Act robbery, kidnapping and related conspiracies arising from investigations in Culver City and Carson; detectives had queried plate-reader databases and obtained roughly eight photographs of a white Dodge Charger and a gold Chevrolet Malibu. The court found the queries did not build a comprehensive record of movements, reveal intimate details of private life or amount to dragnet enforcement, and distinguished Carpenter and Chatrie as involving far more extensive data. Three weeks later Judge Sara Hill in Tulsa reached the opposite result in United States v. Kyle, where a Flock query returned about 50 sightings across several states in a month (recorded separately); the split turns on how much data makes a lookup a search. A 2024 Eastern District of Virginia ruling, United States v. Martin, likewise found three photos in 30 days not a search. This account is secondhand: The Auto Wire (syndicated by Yahoo, Nov 5, 2026) relied on Reason and Reclaim The Net, and the order itself was not read. NOT ESTABLISHED: the docket number, the span of time the eight images covered, and whether the defendants have sought review.
Sheriff's investigator charged over 4,000+ Flock searchesNY
Data misuse
CHARGED WITH TWO MISDEMEANOURS FOR 4,000 SEARCHES. Albany County Sheriff's Office investigator Laurie Moore was charged on Sep 9, 2026 with official misconduct and falsifying business records after the office found more than 4,000 Flock plate searches over roughly two years -- about 3,000 of them on an ex-girlfriend, the rest on four other people she knew. The office did not find it itself: an outside tip on Sep 5 about irregularities in the database started the review, per Sheriff Craig Apple. Moore, a 13-year veteran, is suspended indefinitely; an unnamed command staff member was suspended in a related investigation. Two years of searches at that volume passed any routine audit the office ran. NOT established: what the command-staff suspension concerns, and the outcome -- her first appearance was set for Sep 24, 2026 in New Scotland town court. The county's Flock contract runs to Jun 27, 2027.
Florida trooper arrested for passing Flock and NCIC data to a dozen people over SnapchatFL
Data misuse
A STATE TROOPER, THREE FELONIES, AND FLOCK DATA SENT TO A DOZEN PEOPLE BY SNAPCHAT. Florida Highway Patrol trooper Alain Fernandez was arrested Sep 9, 2026 after a Florida Department of Law Enforcement investigation found he passed Flock plate-reader results, NCIC records, medical records and plate-tracking information to about a dozen people by text message and Snapchat -- among them an Alabama man who had been impersonating a police officer. He faces three felony charges and was fired. This is the case where the data left the building entirely: not an officer checking on an ex, but law-enforcement databases fed to private contacts on a disappearing-message app. NOT established: which statutes, how long it went on, how it was detected, and whether any recipient used the data. Ask FDLE how many searches Fernandez ran and whether the recipients are under investigation.
Wrightsville Beach, NC officer indicted for Flock misuseNC
Data misuse
INDICTED UNDER NORTH CAROLINA'S PLATE-READER LAW. A New Hanover County grand jury indicted former Wrightsville Beach police officer Tonya Baker on one misdemeanour count of misusing a license plate reader system, and the State Bureau of Investigation charged her on Sep 9, 2026. The town had said a day earlier that the employee was no longer with the department. An internal audit prompted the SBI inquiry in July at the district attorney's request. First court date is Oct 12. NOT established: what she searched, for whom, or how many times -- officials have released nothing on the nature of the misuse. Unlike South Carolina, North Carolina has a statute that makes this a crime.
Ex-officer charged with four felonies over 382 Flock searchesFL
Data misuse
FOUR FELONIES, ONE FOR EACH DATABASE. Former Fort Pierce, Florida police officer Josepher Crutchfield was arrested on Sep 8, 2026 on four felony counts of unauthorized computer access, accused of running an ex-girlfriend's plate through Flock 382 times between October 2025 and July 2026 and also pulling her up in FCIC/NCIC, the state DAVID driver database and TLO, in records going back to 2023. It surfaced when journalists contacted the department on Aug 7, not through an audit. He was put on leave, resigned Aug 18, and was held on an $80,000 bond. NOT established: court outcome.
Gwinnett County, GA -- two more police officers fired and charged over FlockGA
Data misuse
TWO MORE GWINNETT OFFICERS FIRED AND CHARGED, SEVEN COUNTS BETWEEN THEM. Gwinnett County, Georgia police fired officers Derric Holmes and Matthew Lau in early September 2026 and charged them with misuse of license plate data -- six counts for Holmes, one for Lau. They follow officer Renee Downer, arrested in May on stalking and battery charges and since fired. The department says the cases surfaced after it got Flock's expanded auditing in June 2026. Its response: a supervisor must now approve the reason for each search, officers are being retrained, and plate data is kept 15 days instead of 30. Chief J.D. McClure said more charges could follow. NOT established: whose plates Holmes and Lau searched and which agency is prosecuting. Ask the county how many searches the new audit has flagged in total.
Columbus, OH -- council-security officer searched one plate hundreds of times; a second officer relievedOH
Data misuse
A COLUMBUS OFFICER ON THE COUNCIL'S SECURITY DETAIL WAS RELIEVED OF DUTY OVER FLOCK SEARCHES. Officer Melvin Tellis is accused of running one plate unconnected to police work hundreds of times (more than 200, per the city), activity an internal audit earlier in the year did not catch. Mayor Andrew Ginther relieved him of duty, called for an investigation and an independent audit, and on Sep 4, 2026 crews covered Flock cameras at 66 locations; the program is paused. On Sep 25 a second officer, 32-year veteran Stephen O'Brien, was relieved of duty as the review went on, and the Franklin County Sheriff said on Sep 10 that a review had flagged one of his deputies' searches. Earlier, a network audit released Jul 14, 2026 counted 19,664,308 searches of the Columbus network from Nov 1, 2023 to Jun 30, 2026: zero by ICE, 3,962 by Border Patrol and HSI (657 with a possible immigration reason) and 15,577 immigration-related overall, under 0.1 percent; none in the first half of 2026 after filters were added and sharing with 287(g) agencies ended. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose car Tellis searched, the outcome of either internal case, and any criminal referral. The contract expires in December and renewal is Council's decision.
Officer back on duty after 3-day suspension for tracking exMA
Data misuse
THREE DAYS' SUSPENSION, THEN BACK ON PATROL. Revere, Massachusetts police officer Michael Tiso used the department's Flock system and the state criminal-records database more than a dozen times on four occasions to track his ex-girlfriend, according to an internal-affairs report obtained by the Boston Globe (reported Sep 2, 2026). The investigation began with her complaint in December 2025. He served a three-day unpaid suspension and returned to work; he denies wrongdoing. She now also alleges he was abusive. Set this next to Georgia, where the same conduct brings arrest: in Massachusetts it produced a three-day penalty. NOT established: any criminal referral, and the dates of the searches.
Alexandria, VA -- 56 Flock searches with no case number; police say none were misuseVA
Wrongful stop
56 SEARCHES WITH NO CASE NUMBER -- MISUSE OR PAPERWORK, DEPENDING ON WHO YOU ASK. The Alexandria Times found, in Alexandria, Virginia police audit reports, 56 Flock searches run without the case number or explanation department policy has required since at least September 2025, and counted at least 81 plate-reader cameras in and around the city against 65 disclosed. The police department told council on Sep 18, 2026 it reviewed all 56 over three years and found none used for an improper purpose -- missing or mistyped case numbers, it says. It has since cut off 12 Virginia agencies that hold 287(g) immigration agreements, and says an outside audit by Ohio State criminologist Robin Engel will start by Oct 1. Police credit the cameras with 266 arrests and 134 stolen cars since 2023. The contract runs to April 2027. NOT established: what the 56 searches were for, and why the camera count differs. Listening sessions are pencilled for Sep 24 and Oct 7.
A state corrections agent arrested for misusing its Flock accountGA
Data misuse
A STATE PRISON AGENCY HAS A FLOCK ACCOUNT, AND ITS SENIOR INVESTIGATOR WAS ARRESTED FOR MISUSING IT. The GBI arrested Robert Keim, 45, a Special Agent in Charge at the Georgia Department of Corrections, on Sept 1, 2026 on one count of misusing a license plate reader system. The Department of Corrections asked for the investigation on Aug 18 after allegations that he used its Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes. The case goes to the Ocmulgee Judicial Circuit District Attorney. Two things set it apart from the police cases on this map: the misuse was by a supervisor, and the system belonged to a corrections agency -- a reminder that the network's user base extends well beyond city police and sheriffs. NOT ESTABLISHED: what or whom he searched, and what the corrections department uses Flock for.
Maine -- Leonardo plate cameras kept data past the 21-day legal limit; DA says the law can't be enforcedME
Wrongful stop
THE LAW SAYS 21 DAYS; THE SOFTWARE KEPT EVERYTHING, AND NOBODY CAN BE CHARGED. Leonardo plate-reader cameras used by Brewer and Veazie police, the Waldo and Washington county sheriffs and Penobscot Nation public safety did not delete plate data after Maine's 21-day legal limit, because of a software bug the company could not fix. Veazie found it on Jul 13, 2026 and told Leonardo; Brewer only learned on Aug 31 and cut power the next day, as did Waldo County. Brewer's safety director faulted Leonardo for warning no one else. The Penobscot County district attorney says prosecution is all but impossible: breaking the limit is a Class E misdemeanour, the servers sit outside Maine, and there is no one obvious to charge. A retention law is only as good as the vendor's delete button and someone checking it. NOT established: how far back the data goes, and whether any over-age records were searched.
Lee County, AL -- deputy fired after audit found non-law-enforcement Flock useAL
Data misuse
FIRED AFTER AN AUDIT. Lee County Sheriff Jay Jones dismissed a deputy in late August 2026 after an internal audit found the deputy had used Flock plate-reader data for something other than legitimate law enforcement, WTVM reported on Sep 1, 2026. Jones said the office adopted rules several years ago limiting all plate-reader information to law-enforcement purposes, and that the firing shows personnel are held to them. The deputy was not named. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many searches, whose vehicles, and whether the case was sent to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency or the district attorney -- the report mentions no criminal referral. In the same state, Decatur police did refer a Flock case to ALEA.
Fourth Georgia agency in six weeks, every referral from its own auditGA
Data misuse
Clayton County Sheriff's Deputy Errol Farrell Jr., 40, surrendered to the GBI in the first days of September 2026 after the sheriff's office itself requested a state investigation into potential misuse of its Flock system. Preliminary information from the GBI is that he used the plate-reader system for non-law-enforcement purposes; he was booked into the Clayton County Jail and the GBI's Atlanta regional office is leading an active investigation. THE PATTERN THIS SITS IN: it is the fourth Georgia agency in about six weeks -- Savannah (six fired, four arrested), Albany (five fired), Paulding County (a 911 director arrested), and now Clayton. In every case the referral came from the department's OWN audit, and in every case the GBI rather than the department made the arrest. Georgia is producing criminal cases at a rate no other state on this map approaches, and the difference appears to be that departments are auditing and the GBI is willing to charge. Sheriff Levon Allen, who requested the probe, took office in 2023 after his predecessor was federally convicted on civil rights charges. NOT ESTABLISHED: what was searched, or how many times.
Same conduct, a resignation instead of an arrestSC
Data misuse
TWO DEPUTIES RESIGNED, AND NEITHER WILL BE CHARGED. Anderson County deputy Eric Center, sworn in in 2023, resigned around Sep 9, 2026 during an internal investigation into using the Flock plate-reader system for purposes outside its authorized reasons; deputy Caleb Dixon resigned on Sep 14 over unauthorized personal use of the same system. In both cases the sheriff's office consulted the 10th Circuit Solicitor's Office and concluded the conduct broke agency policy but did not warrant a criminal investigation. Reporting ties the outcome to a statutory gap: South Carolina has no specific offence for misusing a plate reader, while Georgia's GBI has charged a string of officers under such a statute. Senate Bill 447 would create South Carolina's first framework. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many searches either deputy ran, and on whom.
One stolen camera: 1.6 million pictures and the key left beside themUS
Wrongful stop
ONE CAMERA, THREE WEEKS, 1.6 MILLION PICTURES -- AND THE KEY LEFT NEXT TO THE LOCK. A group calling itself stegan0gram dismantled a Flock camera taken from a roadway and, according to reporting by WIRED and 404 Media relayed by The Auto Wire, recovered about 1.6 million images and more than 27,000 video clips from roughly 21 days: about 50,200 vehicles, some 28 photos of each passing car. The media was encrypted, but the encryption keys sat unencrypted on the same storage. Flock's response was that removing a camera is illegal and that nobody had filed a detailed report through its disclosure programme -- the programme it launched in August alongside a promised independent security review. The finding matters beyond the stolen unit: retention limits describe the cloud database, and this is data sitting on a pole. NOT ESTABLISHED: where the camera came from, and whether Flock disputes the key finding on the merits. SOURCING: relayed by The Auto Wire from WIRED and 404 Media, whose pieces have not been read directly.
Student's new car flagged twice on stale Flock dataGA
Wrongful stop
A NEW CAR, FLAGGED TWICE IN TWO DAYS ON OLD DATA. WSB-TV reported in September 2026 that a DeKalb County, Georgia student's newly bought car was flagged by Flock cameras twice within 48 hours; her family blames out-of-date records. Later write-ups say the flag was for missing insurance and that an officer ticketed her even after she showed proof of coverage -- that detail is from secondary sites and needs confirming from WSB. NOT ESTABLISHED: which agency stopped her, whether the ticket stands, and which database kept the stale entry. Ask the agency who is responsible for clearing an outdated insurance flag.
Peachtree City, GA -- two officers out, both cases sent to GBIGA
Data misuse
TWO SEPARATE CASES, TWO OFFICERS GONE, BOTH HANDED TO THE GBI. Peachtree City, Georgia police said in September 2026 that audits of Flock use turned up two unrelated incidents of misuse; neither officer still works for the department, and each case has gone to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, which confirmed it is investigating but released no names. It sits alongside Fayetteville's firings in the same county in July. NOT established: who was searched, how many times, and whether charges will follow. A GBI arrest would add these to Georgia's statewide misuse count.
Morehead, KY -- six of eight Flock cameras destroyed by vandalsKY
Wrongful stop
SIX OF MOREHEAD'S EIGHT FLOCK CAMERAS WERE DESTROYED BY VANDALS IN SEPTEMBER 2026. WKYT reported Nov 10, 2026 that six of the city's eight plate readers had been destroyed in September and that the city's contracts require it to replace damaged cameras at up to $3,000 each even if it stops using them; the council voted Nov 10 not to renew the two contracts (see the Morehead community record). NOT ESTABLISHED: the date of the vandalism, how the cameras were damaged, whether anyone was charged, and whether the city has paid for replacements.
Fayetteville, NC -- drone-as-first-responder program bundled into a $17.4M Axon contractNC
Wrongful stop
FAYETTEVILLE BUNDLED A DRONE-AS-FIRST-RESPONDER PROGRAM INTO A $17.4 MILLION, SIX-YEAR AXON CONTRACT APPROVED IN SEPTEMBER 2026; DRONES ARE DUE TO FLY IN EARLY 2027. The City Council approved the Axon contract, which also covers body cameras and Tasers, in September 2026; Chief Roberto Bryan Jr. says bundling saves $12.5 million, and the department aims to launch drone responses to 911 calls in the first quarter of 2027 once dock sites are chosen, with a public dashboard showing call types, reasons and response times (WRAL, Nov 2). Council member Shaun McMillan, who voted on the contract, said he worries about the amount of power being authorized. The city's separate ShotSpotter fight is on the community record. NOT ESTABLISHED: the vote count, the number of drones, recording and retention rules, FAA authorizations, and whether council adopted a drone use policy separate from the contract.
Florida orders plate readers off its state highways within 30 daysFL
Wrongful stop
FLORIDA REVOKED PLATE-READER PERMITS ON ITS STATE HIGHWAYS AND GAVE AGENCIES 30 DAYS TO TAKE THE CAMERAS DOWN. A Florida Department of Transportation memo signed by Chief Operating Officer Will Watts -- dated Aug 31, 2026 in the Ocala Gazette's account, signed Sept 1 in ABC News' -- withdraws permission for law-enforcement readers on the state highway system, including I-10 and I-75, and says no new permits will be issued. Gov. Ron DeSantis announced it on Aug 31, citing growing signs of misuse, and alluded to an officer who used the data to track an ex. It does NOT cover city and county roads, where most readers sit. Scale, attributed: Pasco County had 70 cameras on state roads and Tampa 17; Hillsborough declined to give its count. Reaction split along the lines this map sees everywhere: Polk Sheriff Grady Judd called readers the best tool to keep people safe and will keep those off state roads; Ocala police said they would comply; Pembroke Pines suspended its whole programme; Brevard, Bradford, Volusia and Jacksonville were reported discontinuing; Franklin, Liberty and Putnam county sheriffs ended their programmes; Miami Beach's mayor and two neighbours asked the state to pause enforcement and let the Legislature write safeguards. THE CONTRADICTION IS THE STORY: the same administration had approved about $4.6 million in grants for roughly 440 readers for 18 agencies, much of it for immigration enforcement. THE LIMIT DeSantis named himself: an agency order can be undone by the next governor, who takes office in January 2027, so he asked the Legislature to write it into law. NOT ESTABLISHED: the statewide count and whether removal is complete by the deadline. SCOPE OF THE RESPONSE, confirmed Sep 2026: Brevard's and Volusia's sheriffs shut down all their readers, and Bradford's and Jacksonville's ended use countywide; Nassau (34 cameras), the Alachua sheriff (27 of 42), Marion, Union, the Orange sheriff and Tallahassee police removed only state-road cameras. Most Panhandle sheriffs paused (WFSU). Individual agencies are now separate records.
Deputy ran one plate 2,055 times, charged with felonyIN
Data misuse
2,055 SEARCHES OF ONE PLATE, EACH LABELLED 'CITY PLANNING'. Jackson County, Indiana sheriff's deputy Skylar Thompson ran the same licence plate through Flock 2,055 times between Dec 31, 2025 and Aug 2, 2026 -- roughly nine a day for seven months -- typing 'City Planning/Traffic Analysis' as the reason each time, a duty he never had. A routine audit caught it; he was arrested Aug 31, 2026 and charged with official misconduct, a low-level felony, and fraud. Other outlets report the plate belonged to a girlfriend. The detail that matters for every audit regime: a free-text reason field accepted the same false justification two thousand times before anyone read it. NOT established: the court outcome -- an initial appearance in Jackson Circuit Court was pending.
Fired officer charged with 78 counts for tracking colleague's exTX
Data misuse
78 COUNTS OF TAMPERING WITH A GOVERNMENT RECORD. Former Amarillo police officer Christian Slade Eder was charged on Aug 31, 2026 after an audit found he searched Flock 76 times and the TLOxp records database twice between February and June 2026 for a man who had once dated a female officer Eder was interested in -- entering a false reason each time. The charge counts the lies, not the tracking: each false justification is a separate Class A misdemeanour. It began with a citizen complaint, not an automatic flag. Eder left the department on Jul 17, 2026; the Potter County Attorney's Office has the case. NOT established: a plea or trial date.
Hahira, GA officer arrested on six counts after department auditGA
Data misuse
SIX SEARCHES, TWELVE CHARGES. Former Hahira, Georgia police officer Daniel Lindsay was arrested Aug 31, 2026 on six counts of misuse of license plate data and six counts of violating his oath of office -- a pair of charges for each non-work Flock search an internal audit found. He had been fired days earlier and the GBI investigated. He was booked into the Lowndes County jail and released the same day. Chief Stryde Jones called the misuse a breach of the trust communities place in police. In a town of about 3,000 the audit still turned up a case, which is the argument for auditing everywhere. NOT established: whose plates he searched.
Tift County, GA -- deputy demoted for searching his own dataGA
Data misuse
DEMOTED, NOT CHARGED -- IN GEORGIA. Tift County Sheriff Gene Scarbrough demoted a deputy from a recent promotion and cut off his access to all confidential data systems after internal audits found he had used the office's Flock plate-reader system to search his own personal data, WALB reported on Aug 31, 2026. The sheriff issued a zero-tolerance memo and ordered every deputy to review the data-system policies. The reporting mentions no referral to the GBI -- notable in a state where the GBI has charged more than 20 officials under Georgia's plate-reader misuse statute. NOT ESTABLISHED: the deputy's name, how many searches he ran, what 'personal data' covered, and whether the case was referred for criminal review. Ask the sheriff's office whether the GBI was notified.
At least 56 cancellations in 2026, and no government keeps the listUS
Wrongful stop
At least 56 US cities and towns deactivated, rejected or cancelled Flock contracts during 2026 by DeFlock's tally reported in Newsweek. THE SENTENCE THAT MATTERS MOST: there is NO CENTRAL GOVERNMENT DATABASE tracking these local decisions. Every count that exists -- DeFlock's, IJ's, Newsweek's, and this one -- is assembled by advocacy groups, journalists and volunteers from local reporting. There is no authoritative denominator, and any figure is a floor built from what someone happened to notice. THE COUNT MOVING IN REAL TIME MAKES THE POINT BETTER THAN THE ARGUMENT DOES: the Institute for Justice launched a dedicated cancellations database on Aug 26, 2026 listing 92 local governments; its own page said 128 as of Aug 27, and 137 as of Aug 28, with 140 entries displayed when we read it on Aug 30. Four figures in five days from one source, because it is updated daily as volunteers find more. IJ's rule is also STRICTER than DeFlock's: it excludes jurisdictions that only paused operations or switched provider, counting cancellations only. The gap between the counts is therefore DEFINITIONAL, not contradictory, and any figure this site publishes should say which rule it uses. Reading that database also found a duplicate in it -- one Michigan township listed twice, once under a county that does not exist -- which is the same caution applied to the best available source.
One vendor, several systems: eleven communities the vendor count could not seeUS
Wrongful stop
ONE VENDOR IS NO LONGER ONE TECHNOLOGY, and this map could not see it until now. The stacked category counted VENDORS: a community appeared only if two or more companies had readers on its streets. That test cannot catch a council that bought plate readers and got an aerial programme from the same company, because the vendor count never moves. Applying a technology count instead adds ELEVEN communities the map already held records for and had never grouped: six running Flock (Dunwoody GA, Green Bay WI, Alameda County CA, Oakland County MI, Stockton CA, Fort Worth TX) and five running Axon (Syracuse NY, Knoxville TN, Denver CO, Douglas County CO, Grand Chute WI). Stacked goes from 12 to 23. THE CLEAREST CASES ARE IN THE DATA ALREADY. Dunwoody's vendor line literally reads plate readers, 911 dispatch and drones together, and the renewal that expanded it passed unanimously after the council had twice refused to vote. Green Bay signed a five-year, roughly $1.3 million extension that added Flock's drone-as-first-responder programme ON TOP OF the plate readers, in December 2025, while neighbouring Fox Valley cities were dropping Flock. Alameda County approved a $2.4 million extension 3-2 whose package runs well past plates. WHY IT MATTERS PRACTICALLY, and it is the same reason vendor stacking matters: a retention limit, an audit rule or a cancellation is written against ONE thing. A council that ends 'the Flock contract' may find the drone programme, the dispatch product or the data feed sat in a different line item and continues. The Asheville case recorded separately on this map is the same problem arriving from the other direction -- plate-reading rights bundled inside a body-camera contract. WHAT IS NOT ESTABLISHED: whether these eleven are the whole set. They are the ones whose existing records happened to name a second technology in a structured field. A community whose second system is mentioned only in prose, or not at all, is still invisible, and the answer to that is the same records request already noted -- ask for the FULL vendor agreement rather than the plate-reader line.
Police analyst supervisor fired for tracking ex-wifeGA
Data misuse
THE ANALYST WHO RAN THE SYSTEM. Athens-Clarke County police fired Nick Barker, a civilian criminal-intelligence analyst supervisor, in late August 2026 after his ex-wife complained that he had searched her plate on Flock numerous times over several months in 2025. Chief Jerry Saulters terminated him immediately and the GBI opened a criminal investigation. The case is a reminder that misuse is not only sworn officers: the people who supervise intelligence work have the widest access. NOT established: the number of searches and whether the GBI will charge -- it had not as of Aug 29, 2026. The searches went unnoticed for more than a year until the target herself reported them.
Lieutenant demoted for Flock search on woman he was seeingIN
Data misuse
DEMOTED, SUSPENDED, BARRED FROM FLOCK -- NOT CHARGED. The Porter County, Indiana Sheriff's Office demoted and suspended without pay a lieutenant, reported as Michael Piazza, and barred him from Flock indefinitely after a citizen complained that he had run her plate for no policy reason; national reporting says she was a woman he was having an affair with. Sheriff Jeff Balon announced it around Aug 27, 2026, said it happened under an older policy, and says searches now need a case number and pass an automated audit. NOT established: search count and whether prosecutors looked at it -- no criminal action has been reported.
Florida governor calls plate readers out of control and asks for a state reviewFL
Wrongful stop
Speaking at Florida International University in Miami on Aug 26, 2026, Gov. Ron DeSantis said plate-reader use in the state is out of control and warned against Florida becoming a surveillance state, while saying he backs law-enforcement tools generally. THREE CONCRETE THINGS FOLLOWED THE LANGUAGE: he said he has asked for an overview of how state agencies use the readers, noting state use is small next to city police and sheriffs' offices; he said any statewide restriction would have to come from the Legislature; and he named New Hampshire's approach as a possible model, which bars installing the cameras along public roads while allowing in-vehicle use with rapid purging. He tied it to an AI bill of rights that passed the Florida Senate last session and was not taken up by the House. THE OPPOSING VIEW, STATED: Florida Democratic Party chair Nikki Fried said Republicans have held power for 30 years and let the technology spread without meaningful safeguards, and that the governor now wants credit for sounding the alarm. SCALE, ATTRIBUTED TO WHOEVER COUNTED IT: GovTech reported last year that at least 100 Florida agencies use Flock, and WUFT put the number of readers in the state at nearly 7,500. UPDATE: A DIRECTIVE FOLLOWED FIVE DAYS LATER -- on Aug 31 the state transportation department revoked plate-reader permits on state highways and gave agencies 30 days to remove them (separate record). No bill has been filed.
Covington refers its own officer; the GBI arrests himGA
Data misuse
ANOTHER GEORGIA DEPARTMENT REFERRED ITS OWN OFFICER. Covington police asked the GBI on Aug 6, 2026 to investigate officer Michael Canty, 29, over allegations that he accessed the department's Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes; the GBI arrested him on Aug 26 on a charge of misusing a license plate reader system and one count of violating his oath of office. He is a former officer, and the case goes to the Alcovy Judicial Circuit District Attorney. It is one of at least six Georgia Flock-misuse arrests the GBI announced between Aug 7 and Sept 14 -- Polk County, Paulding/Dallas, Covington, the Department of Corrections, Colquitt County and Acworth -- on top of Savannah and Clayton, each starting with a department's own referral. NOT ESTABLISHED: what he searched or how often.
2,000 searches of his child's mother, 200 under a protective orderKY
Data misuse
2,000 SEARCHES OVER FIVE MONTHS, MORE THAN 200 OF THEM WHILE A PROTECTIVE ORDER WAS IN FORCE. Shively police officer Asad Zahir was arrested in late August 2026 on counts of official misconduct and unlawful computer access. He is accused of running more than 2,000 unauthorized Flock searches from January to May 2026 to follow a woman he shares a child with. Over 200 of those searches came while an Indiana protective order barred him from contacting her. Flock's AI audit tool flagged the pattern, and police confirmed within a day that none of the searches had a legitimate purpose. That was months after the searches ended. He is suspended without pay. Chief Andre Bottoms said the tool's value does not excuse its misuse. The department now requires a case number on every search. Not established: his plea. Ask Shively PD: who reviewed Flock searches between January and August?
Georgia woman's nationwide class action against FlockGA
Wrongful stop
A NATIONWIDE CLASS ACTION, FILED IN FLOCK'S HOME COURT. Grace Schulte of Dahlonega, Georgia sued Flock Group Inc. on Aug 25, 2026 in federal court in the Northern District of Georgia, where the company is based, on behalf of everyone in the US whose plate Flock has logged since Jan 1, 2024. The five counts are invasion of privacy, negligence, negligent design, failure to warn and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The complaint leans on the summer's Georgia Bureau of Investigation arrests of officers accused of tracking people for personal reasons, says Flock writes such abuse off as a few bad apples, and argues that even at Flock's own claimed accuracy, 20 billion reads a month would produce more than a billion wrong records. It asks for damages and a court order forcing design changes. A judge must certify the class before it can go forward. NOT ESTABLISHED: the case number, Schulte's lawyers, and Flock's response.
Denton County, TX -- 2026-2029 Clearview AI agreement for the sheriff's facial recognition programTX
Wrongful stop
DENTON COUNTY'S COMMISSIONERS COURT TOOK UP A 2026-2029 CLEARVIEW AI AGREEMENT FOR THE SHERIFF'S FACIAL RECOGNITION PROGRAM ON AUG 25, 2026. The Commissioners Court agenda for Tuesday Aug 25, 2026 lists item 12.A, approval of the 2026-2029 agency agreement between Clearview AI, Inc. and the Denton County Sheriff's Office for its facial recognition program; the agenda gives no cost. A meeting-summary aggregator reports the item was approved, but no local news account or minutes were read, so the approval is recorded as aggregator-relay. Clearview's database is built by scraping photos from the web. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the item passed and by what vote, the cost, the policy governing use, and whether the sheriff's office already used Clearview under an earlier agreement.
Savannah: six fired, four arrested, and a second agency under investigationGA
Data misuse
Six fired, four arrested, and the department is only now writing a policy. The Savannah Police Department opened an internal investigation on Jul 27, 2026 after its own proactive review found Flock searches that appeared unrelated to law enforcement, asked the GBI to take it over two days later, and fired SIX employees -- four sworn officers and two civilians -- on Aug 7. On Aug 21 the GBI arrested FOUR of the six: former corporal Marquis Dillard, 48, a 13-year and 10-year veteran pair with former corporal Matthew Rich, 39, former officer Donald Phillips, 23, and Calandic Thomas, 34, a community service specialist. Each is charged with misuse of a license plate reader system; the three sworn officers also face violation of oath of office. They are accused of running searches on family members and personal acquaintances. THE DETAIL THAT REACHES BEYOND SAVANNAH: one officer is alleged to have given an OUTSIDE LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY unauthorised access to Savannah's Flock system, and the GBI has confirmed a SECOND investigation into that agency while declining to name it. The shared-access problem this map records as a policy failure elsewhere is here a criminal matter with a second agency attached. TWO THINGS ARE NOT ESTABLISHED and the reporting says so: whether the two fired but unarrested employees face charges, and whose vehicles were searched or what was done with the results. THE GOVERNANCE FINDING: Chief Lenny Gunther said he is working to add a formal policy governing Flock use -- meaning a department running 106 cameras in a state with the second-most Flock cameras in the country did not have one. The GBI case goes to the Eastern Judicial Circuit District Attorney. This is the third Georgia entry in this wave, after the Cherokee County deputies and the Ogeechee Circuit DA investigator. THE AUDIT'S OWN NUMBERS, which arrived after this record was first written: of roughly 39,000 Flock searches the department ran in 2026 to the date of the audit, 127 were flagged for review and 34 were determined to be unjustified. That is about one search in eleven hundred -- a small share, and the one that matters, because it is the share that reached the GBI and produced six firings and four arrests. As of 14 September 2026 the outside agency under the second investigation has still not been named. SEP 22, 2026: THE EARLIER CASES NOBODY ANNOUNCED. At a Civil Service Board appeal on Sep 21 by fired corporal Matthew Rich -- who admitted six unlawful plate searches, two on his wife and four on her coworker -- the department's internal investigator confirmed that Savannah police had handled earlier Flock misuse in-house, without the GBI: one officer was fired in a case linked to aggravated stalking, and another got a verbal warning for what was called a paperwork error and stayed on. Testimony also said the department has no formal Flock training and no disciplinary guidelines for misuse. Mayor Van Johnson said the next day he had not known of the earlier cases, that they would be handled differently today, and that he had told the city manager and chief the public has a right to know. NEXT: the board's recommendation is due within 7-10 business days, the city manager decides, and another Flock appeal is set for Oct 13. NOT ESTABLISHED: when the earlier cases happened and how many there were. OCT 16, 2026: ONE OF THE SIX GAVE HER LOGIN TO HER HUSBAND, AN ICE AGENT. WJCL reported that fired officer Amber Harpe let her husband, ICE agent Tyler Harpe, use her access to Savannah's Flock system; an internal investigation found 983 searches of 97 plates from January to July 2026 across six states, 788 of them in South Carolina, and most registered owners of the searched vehicles were Hispanic. He said every name he ran was an ICE target with an arrest warrant. Savannah shares Flock data with more than 1,700 agencies and ICE is not one of them. Harpe was fired in August with the other five but was not among the four the GBI arrested; she appealed and later appears to have withdrawn the appeal. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Harpe's case is the outside-agency access now under the second GBI investigation, and whether either Harpe faces charges. OCT 15, 2026: HARPE CANCELED HER CIVIL SERVICE APPEAL AND THE GBI DECLINED TO CHARGE HER. WTOC reported that Harpe's Civil Service Board hearing, set for Oct 13, was canceled by her. The department confirmed she was fired for giving her Flock login to her husband, an ICE agent, and said it shares credentials with various agencies but ICE is not one of them; the list is to appear on a transparency portal WTOC had earlier reported would open by the end of September. The GBI chose not to file criminal charges against her; ICE confirmed it is investigating because its agent was involved. The city said another agency's investigative purpose does not by itself authorize access to the SPD system. WTOC's Sep 16 report has the board hearing Rich's and Donald Phillips's appeals on Sep 15 with no decision that day; this record does not resolve whether Rich's hearing ran on Sep 15, Sep 21 or both. NOT ESTABLISHED: any board recommendation on Rich or Phillips, the ICE inquiry's outcome, and whether the Harpe access is the outside-agency matter under the second GBI investigation.
Police chief resigns amid probe he tracked ex-wife via FlockIL
Data misuse
THE CHIEF, NOT A PATROL OFFICER. Creve Coeur, Illinois Police Chief Justin Egan resigned on Aug 21, 2026 -- along with his deputy chief and one officer -- as Illinois State Police opened an investigation into allegations, in court filings by his ex-wife, that he used the village's Flock cameras to monitor her and ordered subordinates to do the same. Stalking/no-contact and protective orders were sought against him in Peoria County on Aug 28. When the person who runs the audit is the one misusing the system, the internal-audit model has no answer. NOT established: any criminal charge (none as of Sep 12, 2026), and what the other two resignations relate to. Illinois law already bars some ALPR data-sharing; ask ISP what it will charge under.
Chandler, AZ -- officer resigned before plate-reader probe ended, referred to AZ-POSTAZ
Data misuse
A FORMER CHANDLER OFFICER WAS REFERRED TO THE STATE DECERTIFICATION BOARD. Councilman OD Harris told KJZZ on Aug 21, 2026 that former officer Maurisio Miranda resigned before an investigation into his license-plate-reader use was finished and has been referred to AZ-POST, which can revoke an officer's certification. Harris said officers who misuse the cameras should lose certification permanently and be charged. Chandler had dropped Flock on Aug 7 after its own audit found, for the first time in three years, a search pattern ordinary police work could not explain, and cut access to all 40 fixed cameras. AZ-POST had not confirmed it was reviewing the case. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether Miranda is the employee behind the Aug 7 audit finding, what he searched, and whether charges follow.
The renewal date is the decision, and 290 of 305 do not have one on recordUS
Wrongful stop
EVERY FLOCK CONTRACT HAS AN END DATE, AND ALMOST NOBODY KNOWS THEIRS. Flock sells on subscription -- typically two to five years, at roughly $2,500 to $3,000 per camera per year on published cooperative price lists. That means the decision point is not the day cameras go up but RENEWAL DAY, which arrives on a schedule nobody publicises. THE MEASURE OF HOW HIDDEN IT IS comes from the Who Approved This public-records project, which tracks 305 contracts across 46 states and $83.1 million in documented spending: only FIFTEEN of those 305 records carry a future end date, and two more a scheduled vote. For the overwhelming majority of communities on that tracker, the contract's expiry is simply not on any public record anyone has found. A cancellation campaign that does not know its own deadline is arguing on the vendor's timetable. WHAT ELSE THE RECORD SHOWS ABOUT HOW THESE ARRIVE: 158 of the 305 records carry an approval method of UNKNOWN -- the largest single group in the file -- and only 27 carry a vote stored name by name. Just 47 records carry both a dollar figure and a camera count, which is why per-camera costs are so rarely checkable. AND THE THRESHOLD TRICK IS DOCUMENTED: after Denver's council rejected a $666,000 Flock renewal, the city signed a $498,500 extension -- $1,500 under the amount that would have required a council vote. THE PROJECT IS EXPLICIT ABOUT WHAT IT LEAVES OUT, which is why it is usable: privately owned Flock cameras bought by homeowner associations and businesses are not contracts any public body approved, so they are absent even where police can search them, and agencies whose documents have not been obtained are absent too -- so the real national total runs above 305. Empty fields are left empty rather than estimated. THAT IS THE SAME DISCIPLINE THIS MAP APPLIES, and it makes the tracker a usable source rather than another tally to reconcile. ITS OWN COUNT OF ENDINGS -- 97 documented, 83 cancelled, expired, rejected or suspended -- is a THIRD figure alongside DeFlock's and the Institute for Justice's, and the site says plainly it counts contract trails rather than jurisdictions, which is why the numbers differ.
158 of 305 contracts do not say who approved themUS
Wrongful stop
MOST OF THESE CAMERAS WERE NEVER VOTED ON, AND THAT IS MEASURABLE. The Who Approved This public-records project holds 305 Flock contracts and finds that 158 OF THEM -- THE LARGEST SINGLE GROUP IN THE FILE -- carry an approval method of UNKNOWN, meaning no public document anyone has obtained states how the contract was approved. Only 27 records carry a vote stored name by name. This map records the fights; the fights are the exception. HERE ARE THE ROUTES, each documented on this map. THE PROCUREMENT THRESHOLD. Cottonwood, Arizona had four readers by 2021 and eleven by 2025 without a single council vote, because the cost sat inside the police department's budget below the level at which councils decide. The programme only reached the council when a package hit $199,000 -- and that one included two drones. Procurement thresholds, not privacy policy, decided what got debated. THE THRESHOLD USED DELIBERATELY. Denver's council REJECTED a $666,000 Flock renewal. The city then signed a $498,500 extension -- $1,500 under the amount that would have required a council vote. The council said no and the cameras stayed. THE CONSENT AGENDA. Broken Arrow, Oklahoma approved its contract as item K on a consent agenda, file 23-1170: a block of items passed together without separate discussion. It is a recorded council approval with no debate attached. NO MEETING AT ALL. In Wilder and Greenleaf, Idaho, cameras went up with no public meeting and no council vote; in Wilder the police chief and the mayor approved them between them. NO CONTRACT TO VOTE ON. Avondale, Arizona reaches 192 Home Depot cameras and four from an HOA with no memorandum of understanding and no contract at all -- the department requests access and the owner grants it. There is nothing for a council to approve or refuse. AND THE EXIT HAS THE SAME PROBLEM. Sierra Vista, Arizona ended its contract by council CONSENSUS rather than a numeric vote, so no roll call exists and nobody is on record as having been for it. Asheville's mayor found the contract barred removing the cameras without terminating the whole agreement, so a moratorium was not available as an option. WHY IT MATTERS FOR EVERY COUNT INCLUDING OURS: a map built from reported decisions sees the places where a decision happened. The 158 unknowns are not places without cameras -- they are places where the public record does not say who said yes. WHAT WOULD SETTLE IT is not a search. It is asking a department, in writing, which agenda item authorised its ALPR programme and on what date, and publishing the answer or the absence of one.
One civilian employee's searches ended a county's Flock programmeMO
Data misuse
ONE CIVILIAN EMPLOYEE'S SEARCHES ENDED A COUNTY'S FLOCK PROGRAMME -- BUT NOT ITS PLATE READING. On Aug 20, 2026 St. Charles County Police Chief Kurt Frisz said the department would stop using Flock after Flock's audit tool flagged an abnormal pattern of searches by a civilian employee, who admitted using the data for personal reasons, was placed on unpaid leave and resigned after receiving a termination notice. An outside agency is investigating; no charge has been reported. The 28 Flock cameras -- 20 of them in county parks -- were bagged pending removal. Frisz said the county will keep reading plates with another vendor's cameras, crediting the technology with 30 to 50 felony arrests a year. Senator Hawley's letter to Flock six days later cited this case. Two points to keep: the searcher was not an officer, and the vendor's own tool found it. NOT ESTABLISHED: the number of searches, whose plates, and which vendor replaces Flock.
Lynn, MA -- audit finds 'concerning pattern'; two officers on leave, and a Swampscott officer using Lynn's camerasMA
Data misuse
ONE AUDIT, TWO DEPARTMENTS. An Aug 12, 2026 audit of Lynn, Massachusetts police Flock use with the vendor's Audit Assist tool found what the city called a concerning pattern in some searches; two Lynn officers went on paid leave and access was restricted to lieutenants and above. None of the searches involved immigration, police said. Weeks later neighbouring Swampscott put one of its own officers on paid leave for possibly misusing LYNN's cameras through shared partner access -- and switched off all its plate-reader access pending a review. The detail that travels: a camera network's exposure is not only its own officers but every partner agency's. NOT established: what the searches were, who the officers are, and the outcomes.
Reidsville man detained in his driveway on a Flock hit; a Wendy's receipt cleared himNC
Wrongful stop
DETAINED IN HIS OWN DRIVEWAY, CLEARED BY A FAST-FOOD RECEIPT. On 20 Aug 2026 a Flock camera tied Amadeus Purcell's car to an investigation into someone driving about 100 mph on Scale Street in Reidsville. Several police units detained him at home. What cleared him was a Wendy's receipt in his cup holder showing he had been elsewhere, after which officers noticed his car did not match the suspect's. Reidsville police declined to explain, citing an ongoing investigation, and gave WXII no incident report. Purcell complained to the Justice Department and gathered 400-plus signatures to remove the cameras. Within weeks the department stopped using Flock and said it would not renew, though the chief cited privacy concerns generally, not this stop. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the camera misread a plate or officers acted on a loose match, and how many other hits were checked the same way. Ask Reidsville PD for the alert log for 20 Aug.
Oklahoma City -- sergeant suspended for personal Flock useOK
Data misuse
THREE DAYS UNPAID FOR PERSONAL FLOCK SEARCHES. An Oklahoma City police internal audit found Sgt. Keenan Heskett used the department's Flock system for personal reasons between December 2024 and April 2025, KOKH reported Aug 20, 2026. He received a Class 3 reprimand, a three-day unpaid suspension and a year of disciplinary probation. In a separate case the department sustained a complaint that another officer misused the cameras and applied what it called corrective action, without saying what. The reports came weeks before the City Council renewed Flock 5-3 with new guardrails. NOT ESTABLISHED: whom or what Heskett searched, how many times, and the second officer's name and penalty. Ask OKCPD for the audit and both discipline records.
Highland Heights, OH -- dispatcher resigns; one account ran 20,292 searchesOH
Data misuse
A PART-TIME DISPATCHER RESIGNED OVER YEARS OF UNAUTHORIZED FLOCK SEARCHES. Highland Heights, Ohio Police Chief Dennis Matejcic said a part-time dispatcher resigned on Aug 20, 2026 after an internal investigation found numerous unauthorized searches in the department's Flock account over about two years, all for similar plates with no traffic stop or report number behind them; he said she would otherwise have been fired. News 5 Cleveland said the Washington Post had alerted the chief. Records posted by HaveIBeenFlocked show one department user ran 20,292 searches from Oct 24, 2024 to Nov 22, 2025, searching six plates more than 1,000 times each and one 5,369 times; the next most active user ran 930 in 17 months. The department, which leases six Flock readers, had no plate-reader policy until this case; it has drafted one and ordered monthly audits of every user. The city prosecutor is reviewing possible charges. NOT ESTABLISHED: the dispatcher's name, confirmation that she is the 20,292-search user, whose plates were searched, and any charge.
Kenosha County, WI -- ex-deputy charged with two felonies for tracking a coworkerWI
Data misuse
FORMER KENOSHA COUNTY DEPUTY FRANK MCGRATH WAS CHARGED WITH TWO FELONIES ON AUG 19, 2026. The Kenosha County District Attorney filed two counts of misconduct in public office under Wis. Stat. 946.12(2), each a Class I felony, according to circuit court records cited by the Sheriff's Office. The complaint says McGrath ran a coworker's personal plate 16 to 17 times in Flock, logging the reason suspicious, and while off duty tracked the coworker's live squad-car GPS and body-camera location about 40 times; Gray TV's 12 News report says the coworker was his then-girlfriend and also a deputy, and dates the Flock searches to Sep 30, 2025. He allegedly used the GPS to contact her with her location, drove past her home and had a trainee deputy drive 13 miles outside his sector to confront her at an I-94 weigh station. In internal documents he said he was testing new Flock features and admitted he suspected she was seeing someone else. An internal audit flagged the activity in fall 2025; he resigned (December 2025 per Gray TV), and the Sheriff's Office referred the case to the Racine County Sheriff's Office for an outside criminal investigation, which sent it to the DA. Sheriff David Zoerner then let any sworn supervisor audit searches, required a reason and case number for every plate search, cut Flock retention from 30 to 7 days and ordered remedial training for all sworn staff. THE CONFLICT RESOLVED: earlier reporting that he had not been charged (and a Mar 6, 2026 John Doe petition by a local editor seeking a criminal investigation) predates the Aug 19 filing; the earlier claim that he resigned with severance comes from the Institute for Justice tally and is not confirmed in the county release. His first court appearance was set for Sep 17, 2026. He is the third officer in southeastern Wisconsin charged over Flock misuse, after Milwaukee's Ayala and Chapman. NOT ESTABLISHED: what happened at the Sep 17 appearance, any plea, and severance terms.
Thirteen days in jail while four pieces of evidence sat unexaminedFL
Wrongful stop
THE CAMERA WAS NOT WRONG. THE INVESTIGATION STOPPED. On Oct 4, 2025 a car travelling over 100mph swerved across lanes in Sanford, Florida, hit a motorcycle and a Ford Focus, caused a pileup and fled. Three people died at the scene. Witnesses described a speeding Dodge Durango; the Florida Highway Patrol used Flock data on a Durango seen nearby to arrest Lindsey Isaacs, 23. She was charged with EIGHT FELONY COUNTS and spent 13 days in jail. FOUR PIECES OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE CONTRADICTED THE ARREST AND WERE AVAILABLE THE WHOLE TIME. When crash investigators later took the case over they found her car was not damaged, though troopers had reported that it was; the paint colour did not match paint left on another vehicle; the driver airbag had never deployed, though witnesses said the airbag in the car involved had; and a partial plate reported by a 911 caller did not match her tag. Prosecutors dropped the charges in May 2026 after investigators arrested Alisa Lee Montalvo, whose Durango had damage consistent with the crash and matched the partial plate. Montalvo faces felony charges and has not been convicted. A Volusia County assistant state attorney who had misgivings about the case is credited with pushing for the detailed investigation that unwound it. THE SUIT: Isaacs is suing the Highway Patrol and Sgts Tiffany Jateff and Joshua Buday, alleging they insisted her impounded vehicle showed crash damage when photographs showed otherwise. She was publicly named as a criminal defendant and was sued by relatives of the people who died. WHY THIS RECORD IS ABOUT PLATE READERS EVEN THOUGH THE READER READ CORRECTLY: a Flock hit is a lead, and here it functioned as a conclusion. The technology produced a name fast enough that the ordinary work of testing it against the physical evidence did not happen for seven months. Every accuracy statistic on this map measures whether the camera read the plate; this case measures what a correct read is allowed to substitute for.
A reporter reading the log caught what the department did notFL
Data misuse
A REPORTER READING THE PUBLIC LOG CAUGHT WHAT THE DEPARTMENT DID NOT. Sarasota police fired and arrested officer Cory Waiters on Aug 19, 2026 on felony computer-offense and official-misconduct charges plus a misdemeanour public-records count. He is accused of searching a single license plate, belonging to someone he knew, hundreds of times -- 335 times between May 20 and July 16, 2026 per Patch and Mysuncoast, including 121 searches in one June day; one Gray News version says 358 searches from May to October 2025, and the two accounts have not been reconciled. The case began when USA Today reporter Jack Lemnus spotted the pattern in Flock's search records, called the plate's owner, and emailed the department on Aug 6. The department then ran an agency-wide audit and says it found everyone else in compliance -- an audit it did not run until a journalist asked. This is detection by outsider, the pattern most misuse records on this map share. It came about a week after the Haines City arrest, and a week before Manatee County refused cameras on county property. NOT ESTABLISHED: the correct search count and period.
Flock cameras shot, burned and cut down across northeast IndianaIN
Wrongful stop
AT LEAST FIVE FLOCK CAMERAS DESTROYED OR DAMAGED ACROSS NORTHEAST INDIANA IN MID-AUGUST 2026, and the public comment ran toward the vandals. Two cameras were destroyed in Adams County on the morning of Aug 18, two damaged in Wells County, and one cut down on State Road 218 in Berne -- solar panels shot, units burned, poles cut. Days later cameras were reported damaged in Fort Wayne and Allen County, and in Toledo, Ohio lenses were spray-painted and wires cut. A local station's post drew more than 3,500 comments, many calling the vandals heroes and doubting a jury would convict. The Adams County sheriff said charges could run from misdemeanor vandalism to felony criminal recklessness for the gunfire. Recorded without endorsement: destruction is a crime, and this map also records Virginia's camera-sawing prosecution. NOT ESTABLISHED: any arrest, and the total count.
Deputy fired for 3,200+ searches of ex-fiancee over yearsLA
Data misuse
3,200 SEARCHES, FOUND BY A REPORTER. Jefferson Parish Sheriff Joe Lopinto fired Deputy Nathan Rome on Aug 18, 2026 after he admitted running his former fiancee's plate through Flock more than 3,200 times over several years. The sheriff's office opened its inquiry only after a reporter asked about it -- years of searches had not been flagged internally. The woman declined to file a criminal complaint and asked that he not lose his job; the agency said it had not ruled out a case, but no arrest was made. NOT established: whether any charge follows, and why a single plate queried thousands of times did not trip an audit.
Henrico County, VA -- 10 fire marshals lose Flock access; state law bars themVA
Wrongful stop
TEN PEOPLE HAD ACCESS THE LAW DID NOT GIVE THEM. Henrico County found on Aug 18, 2026 that 10 members of its Fire Marshal's Office could search the county's Flock plate-reader system, and pulled their access. Virginia's plate-reader law, in force since Jul 1, 2025, limits access to police, sheriffs and certain other law-enforcement agencies; fire marshals are sworn and armed but are fire-department employees. They had used Flock in five arson investigations, one of which produced an arrest. The police division and County Attorney Andrew Newby, who acknowledged the oversight, made the call; no one was disciplined, because the searches were for investigations. The consequence the county described: the Flock evidence cannot be used when those cases reach trial. NOT ESTABLISHED: how long the access existed and who granted it. Ask other Virginia localities who else holds logins.
Temple, TX -- officer resigns after audit flags Flock search; Texas Rangers asked to investigateTX
Data misuse
CAUGHT BY THE NEW TWICE-MONTHLY AUDIT. An enhanced internal audit on Aug 18, 2026 flagged a Temple police officer's Flock plate-reader search as inconsistent with authorized use; internal affairs found no legitimate law-enforcement purpose, and the officer, placed on leave, resigned, KWTX reported on Aug 21. The department asked the Texas Rangers to investigate independently. Chief Coy Brown, in office since May 1, had started twice-monthly enhanced audits that same month. Local group DeFlock Temple is organizing against the cameras. NOT ESTABLISHED: the officer's name, how many searches were run and on whom, and whether the Rangers will present a case to prosecutors.
Menasha, WI -- officer jailed six months for tracking an ex with FlockWI
Data misuse
MENASHA OFFICER JAILED SIX MONTHS. Cristian Morales, a Menasha, Wisconsin police officer, was placed on leave and charged in 2025 after his ex-girlfriend complained that he used the Flock system to track her. Charged first with stalking, he pleaded no contest in Outagamie County and on Aug 17, 2026 was sentenced for felony misconduct in public office to six months in jail followed by three years of probation, the Wisconsin Examiner reported. The criminal complaint describes seven off-duty searches, each run across somewhere between 15,234 and 92,702 Flock cameras. It is one of the cases the Institute for Justice has compiled of officers using plate readers to follow romantic interests, and one of several Wisconsin prosecutions in 2026 alongside Milwaukee's Josue Ayala and Tehrangi Chapman. NOT ESTABLISHED: the exact dates of the searches.
School resource officer suspended after Flock auditGA
Data misuse
SUSPENDED PENDING TERMINATION, SENT TO THE DA. Houston County, Georgia sheriff's deputy Sierra Carroll, a school resource officer, was suspended without pay on Aug 17, 2026 after an internal audit found she misused Flock plate-reader data; the office referred the case to the district attorney. Sheriff Matt Moulton said misuse would not be tolerated. National reporting says the searches were of family members and co-workers; the sheriff's announcement did not say. She is the fifth Middle Georgia officer accused this summer, after three Bibb deputies. NOT established: search count, whether the DA charges, and whether termination was finalised.
192 Home Depot cameras, and no contract to cancelAZ
Wrongful stop
NO CONTRACT MEANS NO RECORD, AND NO RECORD MEANS NO COUNT. Every tracker of Flock deployments -- the Institute for Justice's, DeFlock's, Who Approved This, and this map -- counts contracts a public body approved. Avondale, Arizona shows what that structurally cannot see. Asked how its police reach privately owned cameras, the department said plainly that THERE ARE NO MEMORANDA OF UNDERSTANDING AND NO CONTRACTS governing the sharing of Flock data from the Roosevelt Park HOA or from Home Depot: the department submits a request for access and the private owner either grants it or does not. Access by request and grant leaves no agenda item, no vote, no dollar figure and no renewal date. It cannot appear in a contract tracker because there is no contract. THE NUMBERS IN ONE MID-SIZED CITY: four cameras from one HOA, and 192 FROM HOME DEPOT. A single retailer supplied roughly forty-eight times as many cameras as the neighbourhood association, to a department whose own council debates its public contract. Avondale says its internal policies govern officers' use of that data the same way they govern its own ALPR data -- which is the department's answer, and it is a policy commitment rather than a contractual one, because there is nothing to breach. AND THE ACCESS TREE RUNS FURTHER THAN THE CITY. As of Aug 16, 2026 Avondale appeared alongside SIXTY-ONE other law enforcement agencies and organisations granted access to University of Arizona CAMPUS POLICE Flock data, among them the Arizona Department of Public Safety and Northern Arizona University campus police. A camera on a university campus, reachable by 62 named parties, none of whom the university's students voted for. HOW BIG THE GAP MIGHT BE, attributed: Flock says it operates in more than 5,000 communities across 49 states and performs over 20 billion vehicle scans a month, and it markets directly to homeowner associations, places of worship, retail, healthcare, property management, banking, logistics and manufacturing. DeFlock ILM counts more than 200 HOAs signed up, and notes that an HOA which integrates with law enforcement turns its private street into a node any participating agency can query -- local, out-of-state or federal. THE HONEST POSITION IS THAT NOBODY KNOWS THE DENOMINATOR, INCLUDING US. Who Approved This says so explicitly, excluding private cameras because no public body approved them EVEN WHERE POLICE CAN SEARCH THEM. This map has the same hole, and holds only two records on private integration. A resident who cancels their city's contract has not necessarily removed a single camera from their street. WHAT THE RETAILERS SAY. All three big-box chains now disclose plate readers in their parking lots, and none says whether police get standing access to them. Home Depot says it shares ALPR data outside the company only with service providers, who get anonymized aggregates, and with law enforcement for safety, security and legal compliance. It keeps the data 'as long as necessary'. Lowe's discloses on legal process or when it believes disclosure protects safety or property, including on police request, and keeps data typically no more than 90 days. Walmart keeps its ALPR data 60 days and points to its general disclosure terms. Avondale described 192 Home Depot cameras reachable by request-and-grant. Nothing in these policies tells a shopper whether that grant is one search or a standing login. Ask your police department which retailer cameras it can search, and under what written terms.
Undetected for a year, flagged the day after the audit was switched onSC
Data misuse
TWO THOUSAND SEVEN HUNDRED UNAUTHORISED SEARCHES IN A YEAR, AND THE AUDIT TOOL FOUND THEM IN ONE DAY. An internal Flock audit at the Colleton County Sheriff's Office found that a lieutenant, Ruben Carter, had used the plate-reader system without authorisation more than 2,700 times over one year, searching himself, friends, other deputies and former associates. He was fired and Sheriff Guerry Hill Jr. asked the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division to investigate. THE TIMELINE IS THE RECORD. The sheriff assigned his Office of Professional Responsibility to audit the system on 11 August 2026, switched on Flock's audit-assistance tool on 12 August, and Carter's searches were flagged THE NEXT DAY. Two thousand seven hundred searches sat undetected for a year and surfaced within twenty-four hours of someone turning the audit on. Nothing about the searches changed; what changed was whether anyone was looking. That is the strongest evidence on this map for a claim the misuse records keep circling: the detection rate measures the auditing, not the misuse. WHAT THE COUNTY DID NEXT: it revoked deputies' individual access to the system entirely, and now requires CASE-SPECIFIC APPROVAL from the sheriff or chief deputy for each search -- the most restrictive access model recorded here for a department that kept its cameras. SCALE BEHIND IT, attributed: a Cato Institute analysis puts South Carolina's plate-reader database at nearly 150 million scans a year, 99.8 per cent of them with no connection to any criminal activity. South Carolina Senate Bill 447 would create the state's first statutory framework for the technology. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether SLED brings charges. UPDATE, SEPT 2026: A SECOND LIEUTENANT, KEVIN SMALLS, WAS ALSO FIRED, according to South Carolina Public Radio as relayed by Hoodline -- not yet confirmed from the station itself; Carter was terminated on Aug 20. As of mid-September no criminal charge has been reported against either, and the SLED investigation the sheriff requested has produced nothing public. That is consistent with the statutory gap recorded at Anderson County: South Carolina has no offence specific to plate-reader misuse. NOT ESTABLISHED: how many of the 2,700 searches were Smalls's rather than Carter's, and whether SLED will refer anyone for prosecution.
Flock cuts its default retention to 7 days -- for new customers onlyUS
Wrongful stop
FLOCK MOVED ITS DEFAULT RETENTION FROM 30 DAYS TO 7 ON AUG 13, 2026 -- AND LEFT EVERY EXISTING CONTRACT WHERE IT WAS. The company's own announcement says current customers keep their approved retention, so the thousands of agencies already running Flock are unaffected unless their council or chief opts in. The 7-day default applies to new deployments, sweetened with a free Evidence Mode for those who adopt it. The same post makes two controls mandatory by the end of 2026: Audit Assistance, the tool that flagged Colleton County's 2,700 searches within a day of being switched on and that only about a third of customers used, and a case code on every search, with emergency searches flagged for review. It also promises automatic account lockouts for abnormal activity, mandatory multi-factor login, and a Bishop Fox security review due in September. READ IT AGAINST THE MAP: every control here is the vendor's, applied through a contract the vendor can rewrite, and Mooresville shows a required justification field can be filled in falsely every time. WHAT A RESIDENT CAN ASK: has your council voted to adopt the 7-day default, and is Audit Assistance switched on today? NOT ESTABLISHED: how many existing customers have changed retention.
Greenville County, SC -- deputy and communications supervisor fired, SLED investigatingSC
Data misuse
A DEPUTY AND A DISPATCH SUPERVISOR, BOTH FIRED. The Greenville County, South Carolina Sheriff's Office fired deputy Richard Mann and communications supervisor Lauren Wilkinson in August 2026 for misusing their Flock plate-reader access, and the State Law Enforcement Division is investigating. It is one of at least five Upstate and Lowcountry agencies -- with Greer, Mauldin, Sumter police and Colleton County -- to send Flock misuse to SLED in the summer of 2026. As with Paulding and Conyers in Georgia, a civilian in the dispatch chain held search credentials. NOT established: what they searched, for whom, and whether South Carolina, which has no plate-reader-specific offence, will charge anyone.
181 documented ALPR abuses, and the audit trail that hides the restUS
Wrongful stop
The Institute for Justice's database of ALPR abuse lists 181 documented incidents across 33 states, each with its own source, sorted into four kinds: stalking, error, non-law-enforcement use, and other misuse. It is the most comprehensive public list that exists, and IJ says plainly it may be the tip of the iceberg. THE REASON WHY IS THE MOST IMPORTANT FINDING ON THIS PAGE. In IJ's litigation against Norfolk, Virginia, the three most common search justifications -- cj, stolen, and inv -- accounted for nearly a third of 230,000 searches over two years. One officer repeatedly typed la la la la as his reason, and nobody noticed. Officers rarely record a specific reason, the volume is far too large to audit by hand, and so the searches that were improper are indistinguishable from the ones that were not. Every count on this map is therefore a floor. WHAT THE 181 SHOW WHEN READ TOGETHER: the stalking cases overwhelmingly involve current or former partners, and several ran for years -- a Haines City officer searched his estranged wife more than 700 times over 22 months, a Jefferson Parish deputy searched his ex-fiancee's plate thousands of times, a Katy officer more than 2,000 times in 11 months. The error cases end the same way over and over: guns drawn on people who did nothing, including grandparents detained while a three-year-old watched from the car after a camera read an O as a 0. And in Roseville, California, Flock sent 1,427 alerts over two years flagging cars as stolen or used in a felony, and 71 PERCENT of them were misreads. Detection is the variable, not conduct: a great many of these surfaced only through an internal audit, a reporter's query, or a victim checking HaveIBeenFlocked. Departments that do not audit do not find them. TWO NEWSROOM COUNTS, EACH WITH ITS OWN RULE. The Washington Post's review of police and court records, published in early August 2026, found at least 50 officers accused of or charged with plate-reader misuse, 46 of them on Flock's network; a follow-up said it had found officers whose own departments did not know. InvestigateTV, on Aug 10, counted more than 70 cases in which officers or employees were investigated, disciplined, fired or arrested for misusing Flock, most found by internal audits. IJ's 181 covers all ALPR abuse including misreads; the Post counts officers; InvestigateTV counts cases at any stage. Every one is a floor.
A police 911 director, caught by her own departmentGA
Data misuse
A CIVILIAN 911 DIRECTOR, CAUGHT BY HER OWN DEPARTMENT. The GBI arrested Heidi Taylor, 52, former 911 Director for the Dallas (Georgia) Police Department, on Aug 12, 2026 on two misdemeanour counts of misusing a license plate reader system. The Dallas Police Department asked the GBI to investigate on July 7; the GBI says she used the department's Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes during 2024 and 2025. Secondary reporting puts the searches at about 1,200; the GBI release gives no number. The point that survives is the role: dispatch leaders are not sworn officers, yet they hold search credentials, and the population able to query these networks is wider than any published officer count. Conyers police had a dispatcher supervisor arrested a month earlier for the same offence. The case goes to the Paulding Judicial Circuit District Attorney. NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates she searched and the court outcome. CORRECTION: an earlier version said she was Paulding County's 911 director searching a neighbouring city's network; the GBI release says she ran Dallas PD's own system. The genuine cross-agency case is the Polk County officer who searched Cedartown's cameras.
US -- fusion centers in at least five states circulated bulletins on anti-Flock social media accounts and organizersUS
Wrongful stop
FUSION CENTERS IN AT LEAST FIVE STATES CIRCULATED BULLETINS ON ANTI-FLOCK SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS AND ORGANIZERS. 404 Media reported Aug 12, 2026, from public-records requests including to the New Mexico All Source Intelligence Center, that law-enforcement-sensitive bulletins from the Central Florida Intelligence Exchange, Wisconsin Statewide Intelligence Center, New Jersey State Police, Colorado Information Analysis Center and North Florida Fusion eXchange tracked viral anti-Flock Instagram, TikTok and Facebook posts and DeFlock's Aug 16-22 National Week of Action; a July 28 North Florida bulletin listed 11 Florida cities that had signed up and advised more patrols near camera sites. One document summarised a 404 Media article for an FBI headquarters listserv. The records describe a June 25 University of South Florida police stop in which officers found a device that could locate Flock cameras, about seven Florida damage incidents, and a Colorado bulletin naming the Instagram account Nomark.Project and a neo-Nazi group said to recruit saboteurs, with no evidence it targeted any camera. DeFlock founder Will Freeman said the project has never called for vandalism or disabling cameras and credits public engagement with more than 100 cancelled contracts; Flock said vandalism reports are few and it assists investigations. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any named individual was investigated or charged, and how many fusion centers produced such bulletins in total.
717 searches of his estranged wife's car over 22 monthsFL
Data misuse
SEVEN HUNDRED AND SEVENTEEN SEARCHES OVER TWENTY-TWO MONTHS, AND HIS OWN DEPARTMENT ARRESTED HIM. Haines City police arrested officer Christopher Goodson on Aug 11, 2026, charging him with computer offenses and official misconduct. The affidavit says he ran his estranged wife's vehicle through the Flock system 717 times between September 2024 and June 2026, on duty and off. His explanation, per FOX 13, was that he was tracking where his children were when they were with their mother -- a reason no search policy permits and one that would never appear in the log. He was put on paid leave and said he would resign. Twenty-two months is the number that matters: the searches ran for almost two years before anyone looked, which is what an unaudited log produces. When the governor ordered plate readers off state highways on Aug 31, he alluded to a Florida officer using the data to track an ex. NOT ESTABLISHED: who alerted the department, and the court schedule. ASK HAINES CITY: when was the Flock audit log last reviewed before Aug 11, and by whom?
Milledgeville, GA -- commander of detectives charged with Flock misuseGA
Data misuse
THE HEAD OF DETECTIVES, CHARGED. Milledgeville, Georgia police Maj. Brandon Sellers -- commander of the criminal investigations division and the SWAT-style response team -- turned himself in on Aug 11, 2026, charged with misuse of license plate data and the felony of violating his oath of office, and was fired. His own chief flagged the suspected misuse; two colleagues pulled his Flock account and found searches with no work purpose. He was released on a $10,000 cash bond and the case went to the Ocmulgee circuit district attorney. The rank is the point: the person who supervises investigations was using the investigative tool for himself. NOT established: whom he searched or how many times.
Millcreek, UT -- city finds a Flock camera nobody authorized on its property and takes it downUT
Wrongful stop
A CAMERA NOBODY ORDERED. Millcreek city staff found a Flock plate reader mounted on city property near Millcreek Common during a routine review of surveillance devices, and took it down, KUTV reported on Aug 11, 2026. Neither the city nor the Unified Police Department has a Flock contract. The camera is in city storage while officials try to find out who put it there; Flock did not answer questions about who authorized it. Councilmember Thom DeSirant said the city took it down and is trying to work out why it was there at all. The city is now reviewing every Flock camera inside its limits. NOT ESTABLISHED: who owns the camera, whose account it reported to, and how long it had been running.
Tracked his wife 50 miles, then asked another city for its dataAZ
Data misuse
TWO SETS OF PEOPLE STOPPED HIM, AND NEITHER WAS AN AUDIT TOOL. Apache Junction officer Joshua McDaniel asked dispatchers to run his wife's plate as a supposed welfare check and used the department's plate readers to find her car in Casa Grande, about 50 miles away. The dispatchers found the request suspicious and told their supervisor; Casa Grande police raised concerns after he told them he had used Apache Junction's system and asked for theirs. He resigned rather than be fired. Chief Michael Pooley said the department audits plate-reader use weekly and runs 35 cameras. The case shows the request route as well as the direct one: a pretext welfare check to a neighbouring agency is a way to reach its cameras without an account. AUG 21, 2026: REFERRED FOR DECERTIFICATION. KJZZ reported that Apache Junction police referred McDaniel to AZ-POST, the board that can strip an Arizona officer's certification; AZ-POST had not confirmed a review. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether AZ-POST acts, whether any criminal charge follows, and the exact dates of the searches.
Three Bibb deputies arrested after Flock flagged their searchesGA
Data misuse
THREE DEPUTIES ARRESTED THE SAME DAY. Bibb County, Georgia deputies Coznavian Stubbs, Joseph Callaway and Toni Lewis were arrested on Aug 10, 2026, a week after Flock itself notified the sheriff's office of irregular searches. Each is accused of using the plate network on someone in a personal relationship; all three face violation-of-oath, ALPR-data and stalking charges, Callaway with three stalking counts and an unauthorized criminal-history disclosure. All resigned and were released on bond. Sheriff David Davis has since cut the number of deputies with Flock access. NOT established: search counts per deputy and any court outcome. Part of Georgia's statewide wave, where the 2026 arrest count now runs well past 20.
Flock strips officer names, plates and reasons from cross-agency audit logsUS
Wrongful stop
THE AUDIT TRAIL GOT THINNER. As of summer 2026, Flock's Network Audit logs no longer show, for searches run by other agencies, the searching officer's name, the plate searched or the free-text reason, InvestigateTV reported on Aug 10, 2026. Flock said it made the change at the request of customer agencies, citing concern that activists were using audit records to identify undercover officers. Those fields are how outsiders have found misuse: the same report counted more than 70 cases of officers or employees investigated, disciplined, fired or arrested for misusing Flock, and victims and researchers found several by reading public audit logs. NOT ESTABLISHED: the exact date of the change, and whether a host agency can still see the full record of who searched its cameras. Ask your department for its unredacted network audit.
A task-force officer searched a neighbouring city's camerasGA
Data misuse
THE SEARCHES WERE ON ANOTHER AGENCY'S CAMERAS. The GBI arrested Tracey Royston, 51, a former Polk County police officer assigned to the Northwest Georgia Drug Task Force, on Aug 7, 2026 on four misdemeanour counts of misusing a license plate reader system. The system he is accused of misusing belonged to the Cedartown Police Department, not his own employer; the GBI says he searched it multiple times in 2024 and 2025 for non-law-enforcement purposes. Polk County police requested the investigation on July 31. This is the shared-access problem in criminal form: a task-force assignment gave an officer credentials on a neighbouring department's network, and the misuse ran for up to two years. ASK ANY DEPARTMENT IN A TASK FORCE: whose networks can your detached officers search, and who audits those searches -- you, or the camera owner? NOT ESTABLISHED: what was searched and how the misuse was detected.
DeKalb County, GA police -- eight officers suspended, none chargedGA
Data misuse
FIVE OFFICERS TRACKED PEOPLE FOR PERSONAL REASONS; THE HEAVIEST PENALTY WAS TWO WEEKS' PAY. DeKalb County, Georgia police suspended eight officers in August 2026 over Flock plate-reader use. Five ran searches for personal reasons -- including on people in their personal relationships -- and three had a legitimate purpose but skipped required procedures. Suspensions ran from 16 to 80 hours. None was charged. In the same county, the sheriff's office had a sergeant jailed in July for the same kind of conduct, and across Georgia the GBI has arrested dozens under a statute that makes personal plate searches a crime. Police Chief Gregory Padrick called the system invaluable. NOT established: whose vehicles were tracked and why the department did not refer the five personal-use cases for prosecution. Ask the DeKalb DA whether they were reviewed.
Guns drawn twice in a week over an alert Milwaukee forgot to clearWI
Wrongful stop
A STALE HOTLIST ENTRY, NOT A MISREAD, PUT GUNS ON THE SAME DRIVER TWICE IN ONE WEEK. On Aug 6, 2026 Brookfield police stopped Amber Newell on I-94 at gunpoint and ordered the occupants out with hands raised because a Flock camera matched her vehicle to a Milwaukee homicide alert. The camera read the plate correctly. Milwaukee police had cleared the vehicle from the investigation and never removed the alert -- MPD told FOX6 it was a personnel issue, not a Flock malfunction. Newell says Milwaukee officers had already stopped her at gunpoint earlier that week, towed the car and let her go without explanation; she had retrieved it from evidence with paperwork. Brookfield's chief said his officers acted on the information they had, which is the problem: nobody at the stopping agency can see that an alert is stale. This is the failure mode the LAPD Inspector General documented at scale -- correct reads against an uncorrected list -- and no camera accuracy improvement touches it. ASK MILWAUKEE PD: who is responsible for clearing an alert when a vehicle is released, and how many active entries have not been reviewed in 90 days? NOT ESTABLISHED: the date of the first stop or whether a claim has been filed.
Twenty-nine of thirty-one searches carried a false reason codeNC
Data misuse
THE AUDIT WORKED, AND THE REQUIRED-REASON FIELD DID NOT. Mooresville Police Officer Elizabeth Anne Snowman, 36, was charged on Aug 5, 2026 with misdemeanour accessing computers under North Carolina General Statute 14-454(B), after the department's ROUTINE 30-DAY AUDIT of its Flock system found she had used it to track her boyfriend's ex-wife. THE NUMBER THAT MATTERS IS 29 OF 31. Chief Ron Campurciani said Snowman ran 31 Flock searches, of which 29 were logged as motor-vehicle infractions and two as burglary or robbery -- and that she was untruthful about why she accessed the system. Two of the 31 were off duty. Mooresville requires officers to enter a reason before searching, which is the safeguard vendors and departments most often point to. This case shows what that safeguard is worth on its own: the field was filled in every time, with a plausible category, and it was false. What caught her was not the reason field but a person reading the log against the searches a month later. A required justification is a record, not a restraint. The department has since made its second major revision to its Flock procedures. She was held on a $5,000 secured bond.
Coweta County, GA -- three sheriff's employees quit before audit finishedGA
Data misuse
THREE RESIGNED BEFORE THE AUDIT COULD FINISH. The Coweta County, Georgia Sheriff's Office said in early August 2026 that a self-initiated audit of Flock use flagged several employee accounts, and that three employees resigned before the audit was done and before any internal investigation had opened. The office asked the GBI to investigate independently and named no one. Resigning early ends the internal case but not a criminal one -- in Georgia, personal plate searches are a crime. NOT established: who they were, what they searched, and whether the GBI will charge. Ask the sheriff whether the audit has since been completed and what it found.
Officer fired after 166 searches of ex's carSC
Data misuse
FIRED AFTER 166 SEARCHES OF AN EX'S CAR. Mauldin, South Carolina police officer Ellie Hammond was fired on Aug 3, 2026 after running a former partner's vehicle through Flock 166 times from March to July 2026, according to state Criminal Justice Academy records -- entries disguised as warrant checks, traffic infractions and welfare checks. She was the fifth Greenville County law-enforcement employee fired over Flock misuse in about two months. NOT established: any criminal charge or SLED review -- none was reported as of Aug 14, 2026. South Carolina has no ALPR statute, so the question to ask is whether the solicitor treats this as a crime at all.
Brentwood officer used Flock on ex-wife; no crime under Missouri lawMO
Data misuse
SUSTAINED -- AND NOT A CRIME. A Brentwood, Missouri police officer, not named, ran his ex-wife's plate through Flock during their divorce to find where she was. Brentwood's internal investigation sustained policy violations, but St. Louis County Police concluded the conduct broke no Missouri law, so no charges were filed and the discipline was treated as a private personnel matter (reported Aug 3, 2026). That is the gap: in states with ALPR-specific crimes, officers doing the same thing have been charged; Missouri has none. What would settle it is a statute, not an audit. NOT established: the officer's name and the discipline imposed.
Joplin, MO -- former officer charged over Flock checks of girlfriendsMO
Data misuse
A FORMER JOPLIN OFFICER WAS CHARGED IN AUGUST 2026. Kenneth Andersen faces four counts of misuse of official information by a public servant, filed in Jasper County, KOAM reported on Sep 3, 2026. Prosecutors say he made 22 unauthorized Flock checks in 2025 of vehicles and plates belonging to two of his girlfriends and the current boyfriend of one of them. Earlier national reporting (Yahoo, 2025) described a Joplin officer who ran one woman's plate nearly 400 times -- about a quarter of the department's searches -- with bogus reasons. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the 400-search case and Andersen are the same officer, whether he was fired or resigned, and the court schedule.
How to buy surveillance without a vote: stay under the lineUS
Wrongful stop
A procurement pattern this map has now documented twice, and it explains how cameras arrive in places that never debated them. Most councils require a vote above a spending threshold. Below it, a department buys on its own authority. FORT WAYNE: police spent $25,200 in July 2024 and $92,995 in 2025 -- each under the $100,000 that triggers council approval -- and ended up with 36 cameras. The renewal only reached the council at all because the cumulative figure finally crossed the line, and when it did, the council rejected it 8-0. DENVER: an extension was written at $498,500 after the council had rejected a $666,000 renewal, coming in $1,500 under the amount that would have required a vote. NEITHER IS ALLEGED TO BE UNLAWFUL, and that is the point. Both are ordinary uses of delegated spending authority. But the effect is that the public debate happens, if it happens, only after the system is already installed and relied upon -- which is a much harder argument to win than one held before the first camera goes up. Fort Wayne is the clearest illustration in both directions: it took two years of sub-threshold purchases to build the network, and one vote to refuse to renew it. WHAT WOULD SETTLE HOW COMMON THIS IS: a comparison of ALPR contract values against each jurisdiction's own approval threshold. Two cases is a pattern worth naming, not a measurement.
The data does not stay where it was collectedUS
Wrongful stop
The failure that recurs most often across this map is not an officer misusing a search. It is a sharing configuration nobody locally approved, and in several cases nobody locally knew about. SAN FRANCISCO: out-of-state authorities ran more than 1.6 million searches of the city's plate data, including for immigration enforcement, which California law forbids. DAYTON: more than 140 agencies nationwide searched the city's system for immigration purposes over several years, against city policy. SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS: an Illinois Secretary of State audit found Customs and Border Protection had obtained access to state plate-reader data in violation of state law. EAGAN, MINNESOTA: out-of-state agencies searched Twin Cities suburbs' data for civil immigration enforcement, though Minnesota law limits it to criminal cases. STORY COUNTY, IOWA: other agencies had obtained access without permission. RICHMOND, VIRGINIA: the system administrator granted access to a federal ATF analyst, who then ran immigration searches against departmental policy; separately a sergeant shared data with the FBI in breach of a policy barring federal sharing. SPARKS, NEVADA: the department receives immigration-violation hot-list alerts from ICE despite its own policy prohibiting immigration use. PFLUGERVILLE, TEXAS: a RESIDENT'S open records request revealed hundreds of outside agencies holding unauthorised access -- and the city responded by shutting the system down and covering the cameras. THREE THINGS THIS SET SHOWS. The violated rule is usually the jurisdiction's OWN policy or its state's law, not an absence of rules. Discovery is almost always external -- an audit, a reporter, a records request by a resident -- rather than routine oversight. And the destination is disproportionately federal immigration enforcement, in places whose policies specifically excluded it. A council can vote on whether to have cameras; these cases turn on who can search them afterwards, which is rarely what the vote is about.
The second vendor nobody voted forUS
Wrongful stop
This map flags 23 communities under two or more surveillance systems at once -- 12 running several VENDORS, and 11 more running several TECHNOLOGIES bought from a single vendor, which a vendor count structurally cannot see (recorded separately as inc-us-one-vendor-many-systems). That number is still almost certainly low, and Asheville shows a third reason why. WHEN ASHEVILLE'S COUNCIL VOTED TO TERMINATE ITS FLOCK CONTRACT ON AUG 25, 2026, THE MAYOR NOTED THAT THE CITY'S EXISTING AXON CONTRACT -- for police body and dash cameras -- ALSO INCLUDES STATIONARY LICENCE PLATE READERS. The city had not voted for a second ALPR vendor. It acquired the capability inside a contract about something else. A council can end the ALPR programme it debated and still hold plate-reading rights it never discussed. THAT IS A DIFFERENT MECHANISM FROM THE STACKING THIS MAP ALREADY RECORDS. Renton, Lenexa, Berkeley and the rest chose several systems. Bundled capability arrives as a line item in a procurement about body cameras, evidence storage or a real-time crime centre -- so it does not appear in an ALPR debate, an ALPR budget line, or an ALPR vote, and a records request asking about ALPR contracts may not return it. HOW BADLY IT SKEWS THE COUNT IS NOT KNOWN, and this record does not guess. What is known: 15 community records in this dataset name a second vendor somewhere in their text without being flagged as multi-vendor, most of them Axon appearing alongside Flock, and each needs reading to establish whether it is a switch, an evaluation, a bundle, or genuine simultaneous operation. WHAT WOULD SETTLE IT: for each community, the full vendor contract rather than the ALPR line -- whether the body-camera, evidence-management or crime-centre agreement carries plate-reading rights. That is a records-request question, not a search question, and it is the single most likely source of undercounting in the stacked category.
Katy officer indicted for 2,386 Flock searches of ex-wifeTX
Data misuse
INDICTED ON TWO FELONIES AFTER 2,386 SEARCHES. A Fort Bend County grand jury indicted former Katy, Texas police officer Sergio Rodriguez on third-degree felony charges of stalking and misuse of official information, alleging he used Flock to track his ex-wife from November 2024 to April 2025; KHOU counted 2,386 searches, and Houston Public Media reports he also put a tracking device on her car. It began with her complaint, not an audit. He was fired, has pleaded not guilty and faces up to 10 years; the case is in the 268th District Court. NOT established: the trial date. Sources disagree on the arrest year (see notes).
Deer Park, TX detective: 165 plate searches, 10-day suspension, no chargesTX
Data misuse
165 SEARCHES IN SEVEN MONTHS, A 10-DAY SUSPENSION, AND NO CHARGES. A Deer Park, Texas police detective ran 165 Flock plate searches that had nothing to do with police work between December 2025 and June 2026, records obtained by ABC13 show. He was suspended ten days, moved from criminal investigations to patrol, and had his database access restricted. Prosecutors in both Harris and Fort Bend counties looked at it and declined to charge, saying it did not reach the level of a crime. Texas, unlike Georgia, has no specific offence for plate-reader misuse, so the same conduct that brings a GBI arrest in Georgia ends in a suspension here. NOT established: whose plates he searched and why. Ask Deer Park how the searches were found and whether audits are now routine.
Sumter, SC police ask SLED to investigate Flock misuseSC
Data misuse
A REFERRAL, AND LITTLE ELSE ON THE RECORD. The Sumter Police Department asked the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division to investigate alleged misuse of its Flock plate-reader system, according to a FOX Carolina timeline of SLED Flock inquiries published on Aug 21, 2026, which described the case as active and ongoing. The station gave no officer names, dates or details. It sits alongside SLED referrals from Greer, Greenville County, Mauldin and Colleton County in the same summer. NOT ESTABLISHED: who was investigated, when the referral was made, what was searched, and any outcome. South Carolina has no specific plate-reader misuse offence, so ask SLED and the solicitor what charge, if any, is under review.
Union Township, OH -- grand jury declines to indict man charged with dismantling a Flock cameraOH
Data misuse
NO INDICTMENT. A Clermont County, Ohio grand jury declined to indict Cody Morelock, who had been charged with felony vandalism for allegedly taking apart a Flock camera, its pole and its solar panel in Union Township on June 13, and the charges were dismissed, Straight Arrow News reported Aug 20, 2026, citing WKRC. Police had put the damage at more than $1,000, and he had posted $10,000 bond. Grand juries do not explain their decisions. NOT ESTABLISHED: when the grand jury met, and whether the township put the camera back up.
Port St. Lucie, FL -- resident's federal suit against Flock, the city and the mayorFL
Wrongful stop
A PORT ST. LUCIE RESIDENT IS SUING FLOCK, THE CITY AND ITS MAYOR IN FEDERAL COURT. Dr. Steven Greer, a former surgeon representing himself, filed the suit in August 2026 against the City of Port St. Lucie, Mayor Shannon Martin and Flock Safety, and has filed an amended complaint, CBS12 reported Oct 12, 2026. He claims the collection and sharing of plate data allows warrantless tracking under the Fourth Amendment, that cameras at the entrance to a gun range chill Second Amendment activity, and violations of Florida's privacy protections and public-records law. The amended complaint alleges 53 Flock and 73 Axon readers in the city. He seeks a declaration, an injunction against national sharing without a warrant, records, statutory damages and costs. No judge has ruled on the merits and motions to dismiss are expected. NOT ESTABLISHED: the court docket entries (a secondary source gives S.D. Fla. No. 2:26-cv-14319), the filing date, and the city's formal response.
Deputy fired and arrested after plate-reader auditGA
Data misuse
The Habersham County Sheriff's Office in north Georgia announced on Jul 31, 2026 that Deputy Christian Brewer had been fired and arrested for misusing license-plate data -- the misuse, per NowGeorgia via Reason, involving an individual with whom Brewer had a personal relationship at the time. The same shape as Springville AL and the Washington Post's national pattern: not a wrong plate or an overbroad dragnet, but an officer pointing a public surveillance network at someone in his own life. Surfaced by an audit rather than a complaint, which cuts both ways -- the audit worked, and every department without one shows a clean record that proves nothing. One of at least 20 Georgia arrests in the statewide wave. SECOND DEPUTY IN A MONTH, AND A NEW RULE. Habersham County, Georgia fired and arrested Deputy Jonathan Thomas in August 2026 on violation-of-oath and plate-data misuse charges, accused of running Flock for someone in his personal life -- the office's second such arrest after Deputy Christian Brewer on Jul 31. Sheriff Robin Krockum responded with a restriction: searches now need documented supervisor approval, a case number and a call to dispatch to log them. NOT established: the arrest date, search count and court outcome.
71 percent of felony alerts misread the plateCA
Wrongful stop
The accuracy number behind every wrongful-stop record on this map: an analysis of alerts sent to the Roseville Police Department found that in 71 percent of cases where Flock flagged a vehicle as stolen or tied to a felony, the system had misread the license plate -- 1,427 alerts over 2023-2024, per Business Insider via Gizmodo. Roseville PD had reported bad reads to Flock dozens of times over four years, and spent roughly $450,000 on the system. BOTH SIDES, in full: Flock called the figure a mischaracterization, said performance has significantly improved (Roseville PD disputes that), blamed a unique deployment -- older hardware, non-standard mounting higher and farther from vehicles than recommended, and rear-only scanning the city chose to avoid capturing faces -- and cited its own testing of over 99 percent capture and over 96 percent OCR accuracy in optimal conditions. Read that defence carefully, because it concedes the asymmetry: the system is extremely accurate at logging every passing car into the searchable database, and far less accurate in the moment it accuses a specific driver. Roseville says it never stopped or arrested anyone on a bad scan. Other departments were not as careful -- the Institute for Justice counts at least 27 drivers pulled over, detained at gunpoint, or jailed on Flock misreads, including an Arkansas family held at gunpoint over a one-letter misread and a San Diego man jailed nearly a month over a car that was five miles from the crime.
Kingsville officer ran 5,283 Flock searches on Bishop city officialsTX
Data misuse
6,370 PLATE SEARCHES IN FIVE WEEKS, NONE TIED TO A CASE. Kingsville, Texas police officer Gabriel Garcia ran 5,283 Flock searches and 1,087 Axon plate-reader searches between Jun 21 and Jul 25, 2026 -- one plate 609 times -- targeting officials of the neighbouring city of Bishop, one of whom the department's investigation says he was friends with or dating. Confronted on Jul 31, he resigned the same day; the internal investigation closed Aug 28 and his state licensing file records an indefinite suspension for violating a policy that limits the readers to official law-enforcement needs. What is NOT established: any criminal charge -- none was reported as of Sep 8, 2026 -- and why five weeks of searches at that rate were not flagged while they were happening. The volume is the point: at more than 180 searches a day by one officer, the audit found it only after the fact.
Misuse allegations in at least 12 statesUS
Data misuse
Newsweek's Jul 30, 2026 review of criminal cases, internal investigations and disciplinary actions found officers accused of misusing Flock license-plate systems in at least TWELVE states -- Alabama, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, Missouri, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas and Wisconsin -- with the dominant pattern being personal: tracking romantic partners, relatives or acquaintances. This is the national frame for the state pins around it, and it carries the company's own position at the top: founder and CEO Garrett Langley told Newsweek the cases are disappointing but show the system working -- accountability regardless of the badge -- and said the Audit Assistance tool was built after customers and communities demanded more responsibility. The standing caveat cuts the same way it always does: detection tooling arriving in April and arrests clustering in the months after is consistent with better auditing, not just worse behaviour, and departments without the tooling prove nothing by their clean records. The pushback is now federal as well as local: Rep. Thomas Massie introduced legislation to deny certain federal funding to agencies using Flock readers, and Republican lawmakers in several states have filed bills limiting retention, restricting sharing agreements, or forcing transparency. The ACLU's Chad Marlow put the underlying stake plainly in earlier comments: tracking a vehicle over time reveals deeply personal information about the person driving it. Pinned at the US centroid as a national aggregate.
Richland County, SC deputy fired and arrested after routine Flock auditSC
Data misuse
A ROUTINE AUDIT, AND FIVE DAYS LATER AN ARREST. Richland County, South Carolina deputy Russell Kenton II, 35, was fired and arrested on Jul 29, 2026 and charged with misconduct in office after the sheriff's Professional Standards Division, in a routine Jul 24 review of deputies' Flock use, found him looking up information with no law-enforcement purpose. Sheriff Leon Lott said any breach of that trust will not be tolerated. It is one of the few South Carolina cases to reach a criminal charge: with no plate-reader-specific offence on the books, Richland used the general misconduct-in-office charge, while Anderson County's resigning deputy faced none. NOT established: whom he searched, how many times, and the case outcome.
Auburn, WA -- Flock hit led police to arrest the wrong man in a shootingWA
Wrongful stop
THE CAMERA FOUND THE CAR; POLICE ARRESTED THE WRONG MAN. After a shooting between two vehicles in Auburn, Washington at 3 a.m. on Jul 28, 2026, Flock cameras read the suspect vehicle's plate and police arrested a Des Moines man in his 40s. He was later cleared of the shooting; a police spokesperson called it a miscommunication. What he told detectives led to a different Auburn resident being arrested for felony harassment. The department still describes Flock as having led directly to an arrest and a quick resolution -- both statements are true, and one of them was the wrong person. NOT established: how long he was held, his link to the vehicle, and whether any charge was filed against him. The general point: a plate read identifies a car, not who was in it.
DA investigator charged over 60+ searchesGA
Data misuse
Andrae Wright, an investigator with the Ogeechee Circuit District Attorney's Office northwest of Savannah, was arrested Jul 27, 2026 and charged with illegally accessing the Flock license-plate system more than 60 times between Jun 15 and Jul 5, per the GBI via WSB-TV. The detail that distinguishes this from the officer cases surrounding it: Wright worked for a PROSECUTOR'S office -- the arrest wave that began with deputies and patrol officers has reached the offices that charge them. Sixty-plus searches in three weeks is also not a moment of weakness; it is a pattern that ran daily until an audit caught it. The twentieth-or-so entry in Georgia's statewide arrest count, and the reason the aggregate record above carries the detection-versus-behaviour caveat.
Is training the model a law-enforcement purpose?ID
Wrongful stop
A LEGAL THEORY THIS MAP HAS NOT RECORDED BEFORE: that letting the vendor learn from your residents' plates is a COMMERCIAL USE, not a law-enforcement one. On Jul 27, 2026 Tyler Cain, a Wilder resident and chair of DeFlock Idaho, filed a tort claim against the City of Twin Falls alleging it allows Flock to use residents' captured plate images to teach and improve the company's recognition software. The argument is not about who can search the data. IT IS THAT TRAINING THE PRODUCT ON CAPTURED FOOTAGE AMOUNTS TO A COMMERCIAL, NON-LAW-ENFORCEMENT PURPOSE that Idaho's statute does not permit -- the state passed a law in 2025 restricting Flock data access to authorised law enforcement. A separate claim was filed against Idaho Falls. BOTH CITIES MOVED RATHER THAN LITIGATE. Idaho Falls' council voted to amend its contract so the company cannot use the images to train its artificial intelligence systems; its public information office said the city does not believe its contracts breach Idaho law but had heard residents' concerns and was already amending them. Twin Falls' police chief proposed the same amendment. WHY IT GENERALISES: every ALPR contract on this map was argued over retention, access and audit. None of those terms addresses whether the vendor may keep learning from the images after the search is over. If a state statute limits data use to law enforcement, and model training is not law enforcement, the argument reaches every jurisdiction with a comparable statute -- and it does not require proving anyone was harmed by a search. NOT ESTABLISHED: neither claim has been decided, and a tort claim is a precursor to suit rather than a ruling. THE CONTRACT CLAUSE EXISTS, AND IT IS BROADER THAN 'TRAINING'. Flock's standard terms (last updated Aug 21, 2026) give the company an irrevocable, perpetual licence to use captured Customer Data to support and improve its products and services, and define the models built through the service as Flock's property. The terms never use the word 'train'; they do not need to. Until December 2025 the terms required data to be stripped of identifying information before being used for improvement; the February 2026 rewrite deleted that condition, per an analysis by Footnote4a, and the ACLU notes the licence outlives the contract. The August 2026 version restores an explicit promise not to sell data -- sale, not use, is what it rules out. THE STATUTE SIDE IS WEAKER THAN THE IDAHO CLAIMS IMPLY: Idaho's 2025 law bars non-law-enforcement use by agencies and never mentions vendors. Virginia's 2025 law is the one checked that reaches the vendor directly, allowing access only at the agency's request for maintenance and quality assurance. ASK YOUR COUNCIL: does our Flock order form carry the standard section 4.1, and did we amend it as Idaho Falls did? THE SENATE HAS NOW MADE THE SAME ARGUMENT: Sen. Hawley's Aug 26 letter to Flock ties its roughly $8.3 billion valuation to pressure to monetise the data it holds.
Baytown, TX -- officer investigated for Flock misuse; Harris County DA assistingTX
Data misuse
A CRIMINAL REFERRAL IN HARRIS COUNTY. Baytown Police Chief John Stringer opened both an internal-affairs and a criminal investigation into an officer accused of misusing the department's Flock plate-reader system, and asked the Harris County District Attorney's Office to assist throughout, KPRC reported on Jul 27, 2026. The DA's office confirmed it received a referral. Stringer said the employee would be held accountable to the fullest extent of law and policy if the allegations are sustained. The officer was not named. The Institute for Justice's database lists the officer as having resigned; the KPRC report read here does not say so. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether the officer resigned, what was searched, and whether the DA will file charges.
A dispatch supervisor, caught by an internal auditGA
Data misuse
A DISPATCH SUPERVISOR, CAUGHT BY AN INTERNAL AUDIT, ARRESTED THE NEXT DAY. Conyers police asked the GBI on July 21, 2026 to investigate dispatcher supervisor Paige Forte, 30, after an internal audit; the GBI arrested her on July 22 on one count of misusing a license plate reader system. Preliminary information is that she ran Flock searches more than 30 times between April and July 2026 for non-law-enforcement purposes. She is civilian staff, not a sworn officer -- as were the Dallas police 911 director, a Savannah community service specialist and a St Charles County employee in cases that followed within weeks. Dispatchers are routinely credentialed into these networks; departments publish officer headcounts, not user counts. ASK: how many non-sworn employees hold Flock credentials in your department? NOT ESTABLISHED: whose plates were searched.
Goodyear, AZ officer investigated for Flock misuseAZ
Data misuse
AN AUDIT FLAGGED A GOODYEAR OFFICER'S FLOCK SEARCHES AND HE WAS PUT ON LEAVE. Goodyear police ran an internal-affairs audit of all Flock activity on Jul 21, 2026 and the next day found an officer's use that raised concerns about misuse. The officer was placed on administrative leave with computer access restricted, and the department asked Glendale police to investigate independently; ABC15 reported the leave is pending a criminal investigation. Goodyear runs 33 Flock readers with about 200 authorized users, and the department said one person's actions should not undermine the tool. It surfaced in the same weeks as the Apache Junction, Chandler and Surprise cases. The audit is the useful part: ask any department how often it audits searches and whether results are published. NOT ESTABLISHED: what was searched, the officer's name, and the outcome.
Fayetteville fires 3 officers over Flock searchesGA
Data misuse
The Fayetteville Police Department fired three officers on July 17, 2026 after a new auditing feature for its Flock cameras flagged searches outside the scope of their work, including officers running their own plates or those of friends and family with no legitimate law-enforcement purpose. The three were placed on administrative leave before being terminated, and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation opened a criminal inquiry. The department said it would not speculate about the officers' intent.
DeKalb deputy jailed for Flock misuseGA
Data misuse
DeKalb County sheriff's Sgt. Kabiru Salawu, employed since 2009, was fired and jailed without bond on July 17, 2026 after an internal investigation found he used Flock license-plate technology for unauthorized purposes. He faces charges of violation of oath of office and misuse of license-plate data. Sheriff Melody Maddox said misusing law-enforcement technology for any unauthorized purpose is a serious breach of public trust. THE CONTRACT BEHIND THE CASE: DeKalb County commissioners approved a ten-year, sole-source Flock agreement worth close to $19 million in a single sitting, branded Digital Shield, spanning license plate readers, AI-enabled drones and surveillance cameras -- the largest single Flock commitment recorded in this dataset, adopted with promises of transparency and ethical data use. This felony case is that rollout's first. How it surfaced matters for every misuse count on this map: Flock has deployed an AI audit-assistance feature that flags queries falling outside a department's stated policy and routes them to supervisors instead of leaving misuse to manual log review, and company spokesperson Paris Lewbel has pointed to the resulting wave of firings as the system working as intended. If detection improved, some share of the 2026 misuse surge is better auditing rather than more abuse -- and departments without the tooling are not cleaner, only blinder.
Fort Bend lieutenant ran plates for personal useTX
Data misuse
Documents obtained by ABC13 show a Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office lieutenant used Flock cameras to look up one license plate 41 times and another 148 times between January 2022 and December 2025, admitting the searches were not tied to official work. A resident had complained the lieutenant was stalking them; internal affairs found a violation of general orders tied to a contentious family relationship and suspended the lieutenant for two days. No criminal charges were filed and the lieutenant was not named.
Junction City weighs Flock trial amid oppositionOR
Wrongful stop
Junction City is considering a 90-day free trial of eight Flock cameras, drawing civil-liberties objections at a mid-July 2026 council meeting where residents warned the system would build a searchable record of ordinary people's movements. It follows Eugene, Springfield and Lane County cutting ties with Flock and a 2026 Oregon law adding data-retention limits, encryption and sanctuary-law compliance for plate readers. No decision was made; the council set further discussion for August 11.
ACLU sues Huntington over $2.1M Flock contractWV
Wrongful stop
One day after the Huntington City Council approved a $2.1 million Flock Technologies surveillance contract on a 6-4 vote -- following a meeting that ran past 4 a.m. and more than 50 public comments against it -- the ACLU of West Virginia, the Haslam Law Firm and Glazer, Saad and Anderson sued the city in Cabell County Circuit Court on behalf of resident Greg Jimison. The suit seeks to void the deal, arguing the city ignored its own procurement rules and that city code bars letting a private company use city property for commercial purposes without public notice and a hearing. The contract covers plate-recognition cameras, vehicle-fingerprint technology, live video, gunshot detection and automatically dispatched drones.
Officer fired over a plate-reader searchAL
Data misuse
Moody Police Chief Reece Smith confirmed that an officer was terminated on Jul 16, 2026 after an internal investigation opened Jul 10 found a violation of the department's license plate reader policy. The officer was placed on leave immediately and fired three days later; the findings went to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency, which decides whether criminal charges follow. The department declined to name the officer or describe the violation, citing personnel policy, so what the search was FOR is not on the public record. Smith said Moody has run the cameras since 2019 and called this the city's first breach, while defending the system as a valuable investigative tool. Mayor Nick Rutledge issued a statement backing the chief and the department. Recorded as an outcome, not an allegation: the discipline is confirmed, the underlying conduct is not disclosed, and the ALEA review was still open when this was written.
Milwaukee, WI -- officer ran Flock 179 times on an ex and her ex-partner; probationWI
Data misuse
PROBATION FOR A FORMER MILWAUKEE OFFICER, AND NO AUDIT CAUGHT HIM. Former Milwaukee police officer Josue Ayala, 34, an eight-year veteran at District 2, searched the department's Flock plate readers 179 times for personal reasons over about two months -- more than 50 searches of an ex-girlfriend's plate and more than 100 of her ex-partner's, a fellow officer -- entering the reason investigation every time. The department did not find it: one of the two victims looked up her own plate on HaveIBeenFlocked.com, a site built from released Flock search logs, and alerted police. He was charged with misconduct in public office and resigned on Mar 4, 2026, the day of his first court appearance; the district attorney said the resignation was part of plea talks. A March no-contact order covers both victims, and a court commissioner granted them restraining orders in June. He pleaded guilty and was convicted in June 2026 of misdemeanor attempted misconduct in public office, and on Jul 15, 2026 Judge Kristela Cervera sentenced him to one year of probation and a $500 fine, staying a term at the county reintegration center; the maximum was nine months and $10,000. Afterwards MPD said every Flock user must re-request access and sign a pledge, access requests are now vetted, and the Fire and Police Commission will audit a random sample of searches; the city runs more than 30 Flock cameras. Shepherd Express reported the department logged investigation as a search reason more than a thousand times in 2025. NOT ESTABLISHED: the dates of the searches, whether the original charge was a felony, and the probation conditions.
SF approves $3M Larsen gift to expand RTICCA
Wrongful stop
On July 15, 2026 the San Francisco Police Commission approved a $3 million gift from billionaire Chris Larsen's San Francisco Police Community Foundation to expand SFPD's Real Time Investigation Center, which tracks plates via hundreds of street cameras and dozens of drones and runs the city's 400 Flock cameras. The money funds drone docking stations, counter-drone technology and center infrastructure. The approval came days after WIRED reported that feeds from five SFPD surveillance drones had been left accessible on the open internet for more than seven months through a mishandled Skydio sharing link.
The contract lapsed; the cameras kept recordingCA
Wrongful stop
When the nation's third-largest police force let its Flock Safety contract expire on Jul 11, 2026, the 138 pole-mounted cameras in Los Angeles did not switch off. LAPD Cmdr. Randy Goddard told the Police Commission on Jul 14 that the cameras continue capturing plates and storing the results in Flock's cloud while city attorneys negotiate new terms, that the department cannot access any of it during the lapse, and that letting them run is deliberate -- once a new agreement is signed LAPD could go back and retrieve footage from the gap for investigations. Why this matters beyond one city: on this map, 'let the contract expire' is recorded dozens of times as an ending, and the assumption behind every one of those records is that expiry stops the collection. Here it did not. It stopped the department's ACCESS while the vendor's collection continued uninterrupted on public infrastructure, with the backlog explicitly preserved for retroactive retrieval. Pair it with Littleton MA, where cameras a town had ordered powered down were found switched back on by the vendor without notice: in both cases the municipality discovered that the switch it thought it controlled sits on the vendor's side. Any community whose campaign ends at non-renewal should ask what happens to the hardware and the feed on the day after.
Racine, WI -- two officers under investigation; DA reviewed three sheriff's cases, declined twoWI
Data misuse
FIVE OFFICERS IN ONE COUNTY, TWO DECLINED SO FAR. Racine police confirmed in July 2026 that two officers are under investigation for alleged misuse of the department's Flock plate-reader system, TMJ4 reported on Jul 13; both have hired lawyers and were not named because neither has been charged. Racine County District Attorney Patricia Hanson is reviewing the case for prosecution. She was also sent three alleged misuse cases involving Racine County Sheriff's Office staff: she declined to charge two and had not decided the third. That makes five Racine County officers investigated. Racine police run 37 Flock cameras and keep data 30 days. NOT ESTABLISHED: what the officers searched, and any charging decision since July. Ask the DA's office for the status of all three open files.
LAPD lets Flock contract expire over privacyCA
Wrongful stop
On July 11, 2026 the Los Angeles Police Department -- the nation's third-largest police force and once one of Flock's largest government customers -- let its Flock Safety contract expire. Chief information officer Dean Gialamas said the decision was not about cost but about serious civil-liberties and civil-rights concerns over the privacy of the data the cameras collect. Thirty-nine Flock contracts were reported terminated nationwide in the first five months of 2026.
The Inspector General's count: 161 correctly read cars that were not stolenCA
Wrongful stop
WHAT THE INSPECTOR GENERAL ACTUALLY COUNTED. The Inspector General's review (letter dated July 10, 2026; posted July 14) covered August and September 2025: 50,183 alerts on 5,911 plates. In 161 cases officers confirmed the camera had read the plate correctly and investigation then found the car was not stolen; over the same period readers led to 337 stolen-vehicle recoveries, 24 stolen plates and 74 arrests. The IG attributes stale hits to records not being updated in time -- a plate stays on the hot list after the car is recovered. Three things this map said that the report does not: it gives no denominator of 498 (that is 161 plus 337, computed by others), no 32 per cent or one-in-three rate, and no cause-by-cause breakdown of the 161. The finding stands in its plainer form: for roughly every two recoveries, one correctly-read car was flagged stolen when it was not. The IG warned such alerts risk wrongful stops but did not count any. It also found LAPD lacks formal contracts covering data security and access with all its ALPR vendors, and recommended pausing new deployments. LAPD's Flock contract lapsed in mid-July (ABC7 reported the non-renewal on Jul 11); its Axon and Motorola contracts remain active. CORRECTION: earlier versions of this record, and a duplicate now merged into it, carried '161 of 498', '32.3 per cent' and 'one in three' -- figures other outlets computed, not the report's.
Henry County, GA officer fired and arrested after auditGA
Data misuse
FIRED, ARRESTED -- AND POINTING BACK AT THE DEPARTMENT. Henry County, Georgia police officer Patrick Isbell, 41, was fired and arrested on Jul 10, 2026 and charged with misuse of license plate data after an internal audit found he used Flock for non-police purposes. He told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution there are substantial questions about whether the department itself complies with plate-reader rules. That claim is his, unproven, and worth asking about: what audit and retention rules does Henry County follow, and are they published? NOT established: whose plates he searched, how many times, and the outcome of his case.
Officer resigned after searching a relativeAL
Data misuse
Springville Police Chief Jason Mize said an audit opened Jun 23, 2026 showed one of his officers had run multiple plate-reader searches on a family member in a single day. The relative was notified, and when the investigation closed the officer was called in and resigned on Jul 8, 2026. The findings were referred to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency for a charging decision; the officer has not been publicly named. This is the cleanest form of the misuse pattern on this map -- not a wrong plate or a bad hit, but an officer using a city surveillance network to look at someone he knew. It surfaced through a routine audit rather than a complaint, which is the argument for mandatory audit trails and also the reason the true rate is unknowable in departments that do not run them. Springville is the second St. Clair County department in the same month to lose an officer this way.
Five officers arrested for misusing Flock dataGA
Data misuse
Five former Albany Police Department officers -- Tytianna Davis, Jade Jackson, Nicholas Richardson, Brittney Smith, and Issac Whitus -- were arrested on July 6, 2026 and charged with Misuse of License Plate Data and Violation of Oath of Office after an internal audit found they had accessed the city's Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes; Richardson faced the most counts, 11. All five were fired and booked into the Dougherty County Jail. Flock called it the first publicly confirmed case in which its Audit Assistance records surfaced officer misconduct.
Deputy arrested for personal use of Flock camerasGA
Data misuse
Greene County, Georgia deputy Quinsha Goss was arrested July 7, 2026 and fired after a June 30 audit found she had queried the county's Flock system for personal reasons, running searches on at least one license plate over a three-month period with no law-enforcement justification.
Detective charged for Flock misuse after investigating a colleagueWI
Data misuse
Suspended Milwaukee police detective Tehrangi Chapman was charged in July 2026 with felony misconduct in public office for using the department's Flock license-plate system to track two people's movements 20 times, logging the fake search reasons 'test' and 'training.' Chapman had been one of the internal-affairs detectives who investigated former officer Josue Ayala's Flock misuse. Ayala, who searched an ex-partner and her boyfriend more than 200 times, was set to be sentenced a week after Chapman was charged.
The vendor swap: 53 cities drop Flock -- and Axon wins the contractsUS
Wrongful stop
The numbers behind the wave this map tracks city by city, and the denominators matter. Counting Flock alone: 53 municipalities have canceled or rejected Flock Safety contracts -- 39 terminations in the first five months of 2026 alone, per an Institute for Justice tally, across 28 states -- driven by unauthorized data access, changed terms, immigration-enforcement lookups, and cameras that stayed on after cities ordered them off. But most departures are vendor swaps, not surveillance retreats: Axon is winning the replacement contracts, and Denver is the model -- fewer cameras, shorter retention, no national database, mandatory audit trails, and the tracking continues under a fresher logo. Two January 2026 rulings, Schmidt v. City of Norfolk and State v. Simonson, upheld limited ALPR use while flagging scale, retention, and sharing scope as the constitutional variables -- exactly the ones contract language cannot lock across vendor cycles. New Hampshire's three-minute deletion rule and Vermont's approval regime are the standing proof that only state law survives a vendor swap. The independent Who Approved This tracker now documents 168 contracts across 46 states, 55 of them ended. The corporate backstory sharpens the point: Flock and Axon were previously integrating their technologies before a public split when Axon launched its competing plate reader -- and while Axon markets itself as running no national camera network, it holds multiple Department of Homeland Security contracts of its own. As one security researcher who documented Flock's vulnerabilities put it: 'I wouldn't see moving to Axon as an improvement.' The mechanics of the swap, documented July 2026: Flock crossed 100,000 cameras even as 53 cities canceled, and Axon -- which spent years feeding Flock plate data into its in-car systems before ending that partnership in early 2025 -- launched direct competitors to capture the exits: Axon Outpost, a pole-mounted reader, and Axon Lightpole, a streetlight retrofit built with Ubicquia, the same smart-streetlight vendor Flock uses. The pitch to cities is deliberate: similar capability, tighter contract terms, and seamless integration with the body cameras and Evidence.com cloud they already run. The civil-liberties case that the swap solves nothing rests on hard numbers -- the ACLU notes fewer than 1 percent of scanned plates connect to any alleged crime, and the LAPD's own inspector general flagged high rates of false stolen-vehicle alerts that put innocent drivers through stops. Jalopnik warns Axon's deeper integration may raise privacy risk rather than lower it, aggregating data far beyond a plate number. Counting every vendor, the tally is larger: on a July 8, 2026 press call the Institute for Justice put it at more than 113,000 ALPRs operating nationwide and at least 82 jurisdictions that have canceled ALPR contracts or taken the cameras down. Do not add those two numbers together or read one as a correction of the other -- 53 counts Flock cancellations and rejections, 82 counts ALPR departures across Flock, Axon, Motorola Solutions and the rest. IJ attorney Michael Soyfer, whose office brought both the Norfolk and San Jose suits, framed the Chatrie ruling as the Court focusing on the mass-surveillance character of these systems rather than on any single search. This map still adds only named, sourced places, which is why its own verified switch count stays well below every press figure above.
The credibility problem: Flock told cities it had no federal contracts. It did.US
Wrongful stop
The ACLU has assembled a pattern of Flock Safety giving false information to the city councils and police departments that buy its cameras. In Loveland, Colorado, told a police chief and the press that federal agencies had no access to local data and that federal sharing was moot because Flock held no federal contracts -- then admitted it had CBP and DHS pilot contracts granting direct access. In Oshkosh, Wisconsin, the council revoked approval one day after granting it -- the shortest approve-to-cancel span on record -- after concluding it had been given bad information. Denver's mayor negotiated secretly with what one council member called Flock's 'discredited CEO.' The through-line of the whole removal wave: cities aren't just worried about what the cameras do, they've stopped trusting what the vendor says they do.
At least 27 wrongful stops, and two thirds ended with guns already drawnUS
Wrongful stop
An Institute for Justice review of media reports and court records, published in July 2026, counted at least 27 cases since 2018 in which an ALPR error led to an innocent motorist being pulled over, detained or jailed -- the majority of them since 2023. The number that matters more than the count: in nearly two thirds of those cases officers did not realise the error until after they had drawn and pointed their guns. IJ attorney Michael Soyfer, who represents residents in the San Jose and Norfolk suits, put the stakes as every one of those stops being a high-risk encounter where a wrong move or a moment of fear can turn deadly, and nobody should have to prove their innocence at the roadside because a camera could not tell a zero from an O. The failure mode is mundane and mechanical: the readers confuse visually similar characters, 0 for O and 2 for 7, and get worse in rain, snow, mud and glare. Flock claims it captures 93 of every 100 plates accurately, which sounds tolerable until it is multiplied by the company's stated ambition of reading 20 billion plates a month -- that leaves well over a billion inaccurate reads in the same period. A police-conducted study in Vallejo, California found up to 37 percent of ALPR hits were erroneous. Separately, a six-month CBS News investigation verified more than a dozen wrongful stops plus several instances of the technology being abused outright. Read this alongside the individual records on this map: they are not isolated failures, they are the expected output of a system operating at that scale and that error rate. THE BREAKDOWN INSIDE THAT COUNT IS THE PART THAT REDIRECTS THE ARGUMENT: of the 27 cases, MACHINE ERROR ACCOUNTS FOR ONLY ABOUT A THIRD. The rest trace to stale government data -- recovered vehicles never cleared from hotlists, outdated theft reports, uncorrected entries -- and to officers acting on an alert without verifying it. So roughly two in three of the documented wrongful stops would not be prevented by a more accurate camera. Every debate this map records is about whether the technology reads plates correctly; the cases say that is the smaller half of the problem.
A cancelled contract is not a removed cameraUS
Wrongful stop
Every `removed` entry on this map records a decision. It does not establish that the hardware left, and across 2025-26 the two came apart often enough to be a pattern rather than a series of delays. DeFlock Dane puts it flatly: physical removal is a separate question from the vote. Verona's contract lapsed in December and the cameras were still standing in January, until the mayor covered them with black plastic bags and Flock began removal in February. Dane County's subscription ended May 31, Flock did not remove the cameras, and on June 6 deputies bagged all 26 themselves. Oshkosh's police chief bagged his too. UW-Madison's contract ended June 26 and removal was announced July 3, yet the solar-powered cameras were still in place and uncovered afterward, with police able to say only that they assumed the cameras were no longer collecting. Guthrie OK cancelled effective February 18, 2025 and Flock did not schedule the uninstall until July 21, five months of cameras running free of charge. Macon County NC lost access to all 16 cameras on July 14 and they were still standing on July 21, with the school district hosting four of them saying nobody had contacted it. Fort Collins voted in June and the last of 15 cameras came down July 23, about six weeks later. Cleveland, Cambridge and Eugene all kept cameras live past termination. Syracuse took eight months. TWO SEPARATE FAILURES ARE BUNDLED HERE, and they need different fixes: the vendor controls the removal schedule and has no deadline in most contracts, and a covered or unpowered camera is not a verified-offline camera. For anyone reading this map to judge whether surveillance actually stopped somewhere, the vote is the beginning of the answer and not the end of it. Practical test for any new entry: is there a dated confirmation that the hardware is down, and who confirmed it -- the agency, the vendor, or a reporter who went and looked. TWO CHEAP VERIFICATION TOOLS, both vendor-published: Flock's own transparency portal lists departed agencies as "[Inactive]" -- Natick MA PD reads Inactive today -- so a departure can be confirmed, or a stale `removed` record caught, without hunting local coverage. And the same portal publishes each agency's sharing counts, which is how UW-Madison's 168 outbound and 467 inbound agency relationships were established. SEPARATELY, AND LARGER: a municipal cancellation never reaches private cameras. Framingham City Council Chair George King, on his own city's exit -- the cameras are everywhere, Home Depot and Lowe's have them in their parking lots, so they come off city streets without leaving the city. Denver's privately owned Flock cameras kept operating after the city removed all 110 of its own. Every `removed` pin on this map means police-operated cameras, and nothing more.
The vote you never get to attendUS
Wrongful stop
This map is organised around public decisions, which quietly assumes there was one. Often there is not. After Denver's council rejected a $666,000 Flock renewal, the city signed a $498,500 extension instead -- $1,500 below the threshold that would have required a council vote. In Westland, Michigan the police chief declined to bring an expiring contract to the council at all, so no vote was held and no roll call exists. In Dane County, Wisconsin the sheriff had signed with Flock without board approval in the first place, which is why the board could only reach the money and not the capability. The Who Approved This tracker, which records how each contract was authorised, finds 168 contracts across 46 states, 55 of them ended, $50.8M documented -- and that only 14 of 164 records state a funding source at all (6 grants, 4 general fund, 3 asset forfeiture, 1 ARPA). The other 150 show an approval but not the money, which matters because grant-funded programs die when the grant does rather than when the politics change: Guthrie, Oklahoma's Flock system was bought with a federal DOJ grant and ended when the grant ran out. Contracts are subscriptions, typically 2 to 5 years at $2,500-$3,000 per camera per year. For scale, an Institute for Justice tally counts communities in 28 states terminating Flock contracts between August 2021 and May 2026, 39 of those in the first five months of 2026 alone. The practical lesson for reading this map: absence of a cancellation vote is not evidence a program is uncontested, and the spending threshold, the renewal date and the funding source are often more decisive than any council debate.
The cancellation wave, counted three waysUS
Data misuse
The aggregate the town-by-town pins add up to, recorded with each tally's method because the counts differ by what is being counted. By CONTRACTS: 82 Flock contracts terminated across 28 states between Aug 2021 and May 2026, 39 of them in the first five months of 2026 alone -- an Institute for Justice tally. By GOVERNMENTS: the ACLU of Georgia put it at nearly 60 local governments cancelling or declining to renew in the year to Jun 2026, and counts more than 26 US cities with CCOPS ordinances requiring public process before surveillance tech is adopted. By TRACKER: whoapprovedthis.org documents 168 Flock contracts across 46 states, 55 ended, $50.8M in contract value, with typical terms of two to five years at roughly $2,500 to $3,000 per camera per year -- which is why renewal dates recur: most communities get another vote inside two years. By CAMERAS: the DeFlock project maps more than 122,000 ALPR cameras nationally and counts 95 cities that have rejected them. Treat any single figure as one method, not a settled total. TWO CAVEATS BELONG ON EVERY NUMBER HERE. First, the counts move weekly -- in one mid-July fortnight Cleveland extended 9-6, Warren renewed 4-3, Huntington approved 6-4 and four Michigan cities left, so the wave runs in both directions at once. Second, the parallel surge in officer-misuse firings partly reflects new detection rather than new behaviour: Flock's AI audit-assistance feature now flags queries outside a department's stated policy and routes them to supervisors, and the company itself points to the firing wave as proof the auditing works. A department with no such tooling shows a clean record and proves nothing. This record is pinned at Washington, DC as a national aggregate; the coordinate is a convention, not a location.
CMPD officer arrested over an unauthorized queryNC
Data misuse
Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Officer Seth Elliott was arrested after investigators alleged he ran an unauthorized license-plate query using both the Flock system and CJLEADS, North Carolina's statewide criminal-justice data service -- the detail that widens this beyond one vendor, because it shows the same officer reaching into two separate government databases for the same improper purpose. Local reporting on the arrest warrants described the search as an illegal Flock favor. Chief Estella Patterson called misuse of law-enforcement technology a betrayal of the public's trust and a violation of everything the profession stands for, and said anyone found to have violated that trust would be held accountable. One of the North Carolina entries in the twelve-state pattern; date approximate to the month of the reporting.
Charlotte officer charged with passing plate data to an investigation targetNC
Data misuse
A Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer was arrested and charged over alleged misuse of the Flock system, accused of passing information to the target of a drug investigation. That direction is the one this map records least often: most documented misuse is an officer looking up a partner, an ex or an acquaintance, which is a privacy harm to a private person. Here the alleged flow runs the other way -- surveillance data moving OUT of the department to someone it was investigating. Charlotte-Mecklenburg released its Flock Safety agreement publicly after the arrest. NOT ESTABLISHED: the case has not been tried, and the reporting available here does not name what was passed or establish what followed from it. With Mooresville and the Greer SC firings, this is the third Carolinas plate-reader misuse case in the same period.
Two officers resigned after audit found repeat searchesOH
Data misuse
TWO RESIGNATIONS, NO PROSECUTION. A routine audit at the Reynoldsburg, Ohio police department found Officer Mark Nichols repeatedly searched a former domestic partner's plate between December 2025 and June 2026 -- some searches while he was on medical leave -- logged under an errand code instead of a case number; and Officer Alissa Birkhimer searched an unrelated plate 53 times from January to June 2026. Both resigned before internal-affairs interviews, per records reported by ABC6 on Aug 5, 2026. The chief recommended against prosecuting Nichols, citing a medical diagnosis. NOT established: why Birkhimer ran the plate and whether any referral was made in her case.
Vermont police searched other states' plate networks the state law never contemplatedVT
Wrongful stop
VERMONT'S LAW LIMITED ITS OWN CAMERAS; POLICE SEARCHED EVERYONE ELSE'S. Public records obtained by VTDigger show Vermont police ran more than 100 searches since 2023 of plate data from other states, through a regional police intelligence network and Flock's national network. Vermont State Police ran 30-plus; Berlin 15, Brattleboro 12, Colchester 10, Hartford 8, Rutland 5, Barre City 4. The state's plate-reader law, first passed in 2013, sets strict rules for local systems but, as VTDigger reads it, is silent on national networks that did not exist when it passed. State Police say they complied with the statute; Rep. Barbara Rachelson says the law needs to say so explicitly and the department should have asked. THE DEADLINE THAT MATTERS: Vermont's plate-reader statutes sunset in 2027, so the Legislature has to rewrite them anyway. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any search broke the law as written, and what the Franklin County Sheriff ran. How the changes that took effect in July 2025 (recorded under Manchester) bear on these searches is not established here.
She changed her identity to get away from him; he found her car anywayMA
Data misuse
SHE CHANGED HER IDENTITY TO GET AWAY FROM HIM; HE FOUND HER CAR ANYWAY. A woman who says she fled an abusive relationship with Stow police officer Jason Rogers about five years ago -- moving, changing her phone number and her identity -- discovered in summer 2026 that her plate had been searched in 2024 and 2025. She found it herself, by entering the plate on a public lookup site, not through any department audit. She complained on June 18. Stow's internal investigation found at least five unlawful criminal-record lookups and repeated Flock and CJIS vehicle queries with no law-enforcement purpose, logged with false or unsubstantiated reasons. The department filed a criminal complaint on July 17, now with the Middlesex District Attorney, and referred him to the state POST Commission. Rogers resigned on Aug 25, the day before his disciplinary hearing, and the chief ended the town's Flock contract. The case is the plainest illustration on this map of why retention and audit matter: identity change protects against every lookup except the one a camera network makes of your car. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether criminal charges have issued.
Decatur, AL -- officer on leave, ALEA asked to investigate Flock misuseAL
Data misuse
REFERRED TO THE STATE POLICE. A Decatur police officer was placed on administrative leave over possible misuse of the department's Flock plate-reader system, and Chief Torry Mack asked the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency to open a criminal investigation alongside the department's own, 1819 News reported. The alleged violation took place on Jun 12, 2026. Mack said officers are trusted with sensitive tools and significant authority and must use them responsibly. Decatur runs more than 40 Flock cameras, installed about three years ago. NOT ESTABLISHED: the officer's name, what was searched, and whether ALEA has finished its inquiry.
Village chief tracked six people via plate readersIL
Data misuse
The police chief of Holiday Hills, Illinois, who also worked part-time for the Prairie Grove department, was arrested in June 2026 and charged with official misconduct after prosecutors said he used Prairie Grove's Flock system and a state law-enforcement database to track six people he knew personally, including three women he had been in relationships with. The case, reported by the surveillance-industry outlet IPVM, extends a documented pattern of officers using plate readers to follow partners and rivals.
Geofence dragnet swept a neighborhood for one robberVA
Wrongful stop
To solve a 2019 bank robbery in Midlothian, Virginia, police used a Google geofence warrant covering a 150-meter radius that swept up every device near homes, businesses, and a church. Okello Chatrie was identified and convicted, and in 2026 his case became the first geofence-warrant dispute heard by the Supreme Court. Decided June 29, 2026: the Court held 6-3 that acquiring Google Location History through a geofence warrant is a Fourth Amendment search. Justice Kagan wrote for the majority, joined by Roberts, Sotomayor, Jackson, and Kavanaugh; Gorsuch concurred but would have reached the same place on a property theory, treating the location history as Chatrie's own even while it sat on Google's servers. Alito dissented, joined by Thomas and in part by Barrett, calling the majority an irresponsible escapade that would send seismic waves through Fourth Amendment doctrine while changing nothing about Chatrie's own case. The operative move is narrow and large at once: the Court dropped the temporal floor Carpenter had built in, so the question is no longer how many days of location data the government took. What the Court did not do is decide whether this warrant was any good. Particularity, probable cause, and the scope of the government's discretion all go back to the Fourth Circuit, and the good-faith exception -- which the lower courts split on -- was left untouched, meaning Chatrie can win the doctrine and still lose the suppression motion. For this map the relevant reach is sideways rather than downward: a geofence warrant and an ALPR network do the same thing, sorting everyone who passed a place at a time in order to find one person, and the ruling supplies the reasoning that warrantless plate-reader dragnets have so far avoided.
Chief used Flock 140-plus times to stalk a manIL
Data misuse
A Prairie Grove, Illinois officer who later became a nearby police chief was charged with official misconduct after using Flock to track a man 140 times, 86 of them while off duty. Audit logs also showed the agency ran roughly 2,600 searches labeled 'training' against the live national network over five months before the conduct was caught.
Out-of-state agencies searched SF data via a fusion centerCA
Data misuse
San Francisco police cut outside access to their Flock network after an audit found roughly 300 improper out-of-state and federal queries routed through the NCRIC fusion center and a regional information network, despite a California law barring such sharing. Earlier reporting had found more than 1.6 million out-of-state searches of the city's data, at least 19 flagged as ICE-related.
Class action over plate readers at UC MercedCA
Data misuse
A California class action alleges Motorola's Vigilant plate readers at the entrance of UC Merced recorded everyone driving by, and that an April 2026 audit found the data was shared with federal agencies including Customs and Border Protection in violation of state law.
Three deputies charged after an ALPR auditGA
Data misuse
Three Cherokee County Sheriff's Office deputies -- Lt. Chris Bryant, Sgt. Mike Creeden, and Deputy Cynthia Jodesty -- were fired, arrested, and charged in June 2026 with felony violation of oath of office and a misdemeanor license-plate-data offense after the agency's own Real-Time Intelligence Division audited the ALPR system and found they had run searches for non-law-enforcement purposes.
Regional center made 299 improper queries of city camerasCA
Data misuse
In June 2026, San Francisco's police chief disclosed that a compliance audit found the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center had queried the city's Flock network on behalf of federal and out-of-state agencies -- 299 improper inquiries over about a year, in violation of California's ALPR Privacy Act. SFPD cut off the access and opened an internal review.
Two supervisors charged over ALPR misuseGA
Data misuse
The Cherokee County, Georgia Sheriff's Office charged and fired two of its supervisors for allegedly misusing the county's automated license plate reader system, weeks before a similar case in Albany.
Journalist boxed in by police after a Flock plate errorMN
Wrongful stop
The Drive journalist Joel Feder was tracked for days by Plymouth, Minnesota police via Flock license-plate cameras and then boxed in by four squad cars, with a drone overhead, in a Kohl's parking lot in late June 2026. A manufacturer plate on his press-fleet Range Rover (34 10 DTM) was misread as a plate reported lost in Los Angeles that a police report had truncated to '34 DTM.' Flock's system flagged every Jaguar Land Rover fleet car sharing the 34 ## DTM format as stolen nationwide, and four other such cars were being tracked around Minnesota that week.
Blue Island PD -- NCIC 'Immigration Violator File' enabled in FlockIL
Data misuse
EFF investigator Dave Maass reported on Jun 25, 2026 that the Flock Safety ALPR administrative interface carries a drop-down where an agency subscribes to FBI NCIC topics, and that one of those topics is the Immigration Violator File. Blue Island Police Department was one of two agencies EFF confirmed had it enabled, so every plate its cameras read was matched against a federal immigration target list -- turning cameras a council approved for stolen-vehicle recovery into an immigration screening tool, without the checkbox ever appearing on an agenda. READ THE DENOMINATOR BEFORE READING THE FINDING: of at least 13 agencies that had answered EFF's public-records requests by Jun 25, 2026, two had this hotlist enabled and eleven had it switched off, across a Flock network of more than 5,000 communities with the investigation still open. Two confirmed cases and eleven confirmed negatives is not evidence of prevalence; the several thousand agencies that have not answered are the actual finding. HOW THE PLUMBING RUNS, because it is not a direct ICE feed: Flock told EFF that local agencies add and remove plates, that the FBI curates the NCIC list and pushes it to subscribing agencies, and that once it leaves the FBI the bureau sees only additions and removals rather than the alerts themselves. A hit goes to the municipal agency, which decides whether to call ICE. The Immigration Violator File is still populated exclusively by ICE -- the NCIC operator manual makes ICE the only agency authorised to enter or maintain records in it -- and its entries rest on administrative warrants issued by ICE agents without judicial review. That indirection is why the integration stayed invisible in procurement papers and transparency portals.
Sparks PD -- NCIC 'Immigration Violator File' enabled in FlockNV
Data misuse
EFF investigator Dave Maass reported on Jun 25, 2026 that Sparks Police Department had the FBI NCIC Immigration Violator hotlist toggled on in its Flock Safety configuration. The contradiction is the record: the department's own public ALPR transparency portal lists immigration enforcement among its prohibited uses, while its settings subscribed it to an immigration target list. One of two agencies EFF confirmed enabled. A written policy and a checkbox disagreed, and only the checkbox governed what the cameras did. READ THE DENOMINATOR BEFORE READING THE FINDING: of at least 13 agencies that had answered EFF's public-records requests by Jun 25, 2026, two had this hotlist enabled and eleven had it switched off, across a Flock network of more than 5,000 communities with the investigation still open. Two confirmed cases and eleven confirmed negatives is not evidence of prevalence; the several thousand agencies that have not answered are the actual finding. HOW THE PLUMBING RUNS, because it is not a direct ICE feed: Flock told EFF that local agencies add and remove plates, that the FBI curates the NCIC list and pushes it to subscribing agencies, and that once it leaves the FBI the bureau sees only additions and removals rather than the alerts themselves. A hit goes to the municipal agency, which decides whether to call ICE. The Immigration Violator File is still populated exclusively by ICE -- the NCIC operator manual makes ICE the only agency authorised to enter or maintain records in it -- and its entries rest on administrative warrants issued by ICE agents without judicial review. That indirection is why the integration stayed invisible in procurement papers and transparency portals.
Greer fires 2 officers after Flock auditSC
Data misuse
The City of Greer terminated police Corporal Kareem Lynch and Officer Sebastian Echeverry in late June 2026 after an AI-driven audit of the department's Flock license-plate system flagged that they had violated the agency's ALPR policy. The firings added to a growing national tally of officers disciplined for misusing plate-reader data.
Motorola/Vigilant class action: the OTHER ALPR giant in courtCA
Wrongful stop
Flock is not the only ALPR company being sued. On June 18, 2026 a class action was filed against Motorola Solutions and its subsidiary Vigilant, alleging the companies unlawfully shared California drivers' plate and location data across jurisdictions and with federal agencies -- naming Pleasanton, Sacramento, Modesto, Merced, and Livermore. Vigilant is the legacy ALPR heavyweight: EFF documented its database reaching up to 1,000 agencies and, via Digital Recognition Network, selling plate data to lenders, insurers, and debt collectors, while ICE has held a $22.8M contract for database access through 2026. The vendor names change; the surveillance model is the industry's, not one company's.
Ambushed over a test car's plateNE
Wrongful stop
Automobile journalist Tim Esterdahl was pulled over by police in Scotts Bluff after a Flock camera misread the license plate of a Range Rover he was testing. He wrote it up as being ambushed for no reason, and the significance is that he had the standing and the platform to trace the cause: systemic ALPR error rather than one bad read. A second automotive writer was tracked the same way in Plymouth, Minnesota the same month, also over a Range Rover test plate -- two cases in one month from the same niche, which says something about how many ordinary drivers experience this without ever learning why.
The Flock record held the proof he was five miles awayCA
Wrongful stop
THE EVIDENCE THAT CLEARED HIM WAS INSIDE THE FLOCK DATA, AND NOBODY LOOKED. San Diego police arrested Hugo Parra and 23-year-old driver Ariel Beltran on attempted-carjacking charges in November 2025 after a Flock camera captured a red Alfa Romeo. They had a car description but NO PLATE NUMBER, a witness who picked Parra out at a curbside lineup, and a plate-reader hit they treated as corroboration. THE HIT WAS RECORDED FIVE MILES FROM THE CRIME SCENE, AND BEFORE ANY POLICE PURSUIT BEGAN. Their attorney Alex Coolman argues the timestamp and location in the Flock record itself show the captured car could not have been the suspect vehicle -- the same system that produced the hit also held the metadata disproving it, and that metadata was not consulted before the arrest. The witness account compounded it: Parra was wearing a white hoodie when arrested and the suspect had been described in grey. Parra and Beltran sued in June 2026, seeking $1.5 million each. WHY THIS RECORD IS NOT ABOUT ACCURACY: the camera did its job. A hit is a location and a timestamp, which is all it ever is, and it was read as an identification. Every accuracy statistic on this map measures whether the plate was read correctly; this case measures what a correct read was allowed to substitute for. NOT ESTABLISHED: the suit has not been decided and the department's account is not in the reporting reviewed here.
'Deputy of the Year' quit after off-duty Flock lookup of exFL
Data misuse
ONE SEARCH, AND THE DEPUTY OF THE YEAR RESIGNED. Brevard County, Florida deputy Michael Fultz resigned on May 27, 2026 after an internal investigation found he ran his ex-girlfriend's tag through Flock while off duty, labelling it an investigation, and could give no reason for it. The complaint arrived the day he was named the agency's Deputy of the Year in March 2026. There is no sign of a criminal referral; News 6 made it public in August. The case is small by count -- a single search -- which is why it matters: most departments do not audit single queries at all, and this one surfaced only because someone complained.
All Flock devices placed in the one Black neighborhoodPA
Data misuse
An audit of nearly three years of Flock logs found New Castle, Pennsylvania placed all 31 of its surveillance devices in the city's only majority-minority census tract, with officers adding scores of people to permanent private watchlists that carried no case numbers and were set never to expire.
Deputy monitored an ex and her new partnerIL
Data misuse
Tyler Bryan, a former Winnebago County sheriff's deputy in Illinois, was charged with stalking and official misconduct after allegedly using the department's plate-reader system to monitor the locations of an ex-girlfriend and her new partner. The misconduct surfaced after the victims filed for an order of protection. It is among at least eighteen such cases compiled by the Institute for Justice.
Home Depot lots fed driver data to a police networkCA
Data misuse
A California class action alleges Home Depot's parking-lot plate readers covertly fed driver data into a national police database, and that Flock re-enabled nationwide sharing on Ventura County and Mountain View systems without authorization.
Flock demoed a playground, school, and kids' gym to other agenciesGA
Data misuse
A public-records request by Dunwoody resident Jason Hunyar revealed that Flock sales staff had tapped the Atlanta suburb's cameras -- including ones covering a children's gymnastics room, a playground, a school, a Jewish community center, and a pool -- to demonstrate the surveillance system to police departments around the country. Flock confirmed Dunwoody was part of its 'demo partner program.' The city renewed its Flock contract anyway.
EFF: without a warrant rule, police used ALPR hotlists for general trackingUS
Wrongful stop
An EFF analysis of millions of police searches of Flock ALPR data (May 2026) found a troubling pattern: with no warrant requirement to query the databases, agencies moved beyond specific investigations toward general, real-time tracking via 'hotlists' -- lists of vehicles flagged for live surveillance. It is the empirical backbone of the whole reform push: the problem isn't only who the data is shared with, it's that officers can watch anyone's movements without showing cause. No comprehensive federal ALPR statute exists; a 2025 Congressional Research Service brief confirms Congress has left the field to Fourth Amendment litigation and state law.
Flock's own lawyer: tracking an ex is "the most common thing"US
Data misuse
On a May 2026 radio appearance on Maine's Morning News, Flock Safety chief legal officer Dan Haley was asked about misuse and answered more plainly than the company's written statements ever have: very rarely, he said, someone does something stupid and uses it to figure out where an ex-girlfriend is, and that is actually the most common thing. IPVM caught it. Read against the record on this map, the concession matters twice over. It confirms from the vendor's own counsel that intimate-partner tracking is the leading misuse pattern, which is what the Institute for Justice's tally of at least 26 stalking cases already showed. And it sits awkwardly beside 'very rarely', given that departments almost never audit their own systems -- nearly every case on this map surfaced because a victim noticed, filed for a protective order, or went looking, not because anyone was watching the watchers. The exception proves the point: Joplin, Missouri only found its officer after the activist group DeFlock Joplin dug through records and found a single plate searched 395 times.
Officer resigned after 100+ searches of ex and her circleGA
Data misuse
103 SEARCHES OF AN EX, HER COLLEAGUE AND HER UNCLE. Alpharetta, Georgia police officer Dustin Bozzo searched a former partner's car 56 times between March and May 2026, a fellow officer's car 29 times and her uncle's car 18 times in nine days, entering reasons such as wanted person and traffic infraction, according to internal-affairs findings. He said some searches were to make sure she got home safely. He was placed on leave and resigned; the department opened a criminal investigation. NOT established: whether the GBI or DA has charged him, and the resignation date.
Kettering, OH -- 184 immigration searches in a month despite a 2022 pledgeOH
Wrongful stop
184 IMMIGRATION SEARCHES IN ONE MONTH, AFTER A PROMISE OF NONE. Outside agencies logged immigration as the reason for searching Kettering, Ohio's Flock cameras 184 times in January, according to an audit reported by the Dayton Daily News. When council approved the first 10 cameras in March 2022, the police chief told members the system would not be used for ICE. Kettering changed its internal practice on May 4 to shut off immigration-related access, and the mayor says access has been tightened -- but the written plate-reader policy still says nothing about immigration. Neighbouring Dayton covered its cameras in May 2026 over the same finding. NOT established: which agencies ran the searches, and whether the policy text will be amended. Ask council to put the ban in writing.
Richmond, VA sergeant gave Flock image to FBI, breaking state law; no prosecutionVA
Data misuse
ONE IMAGE, ONE FEDERAL AGENT, AND A STATE LAW BROKEN. A Richmond, Virginia police sergeant sent a Flock plate-reader image of a vehicle to the FBI for a Washington, D.C. homicide inquiry. Virginia law bars sharing plate-reader data with agencies outside the state, and Chief Rick Edwards said that applies even to a single vehicle. A routine audit of first-quarter 2026 searches caught it; the department announced it Apr 30, 2026, cut the sergeant's Flock access, and the Commonwealth's Attorney declined to prosecute. The case shows both halves of the argument: the quarterly audit worked, and the statute had no teeth when it did. NOT established: when exactly the image was sent and whether it remains in federal files.
Officer pleaded guilty after tracking a mistressCA
Data misuse
Robert Jay Josett, 35, a Costa Mesa police officer, pleaded guilty in April 2026 after making 13 unauthorized inquiries beginning in 2023 through the California Law Enforcement Telecommunications System on people and vehicles unrelated to his job -- including his wife, his mistress, and men she dated -- and using Flock camera data to locate their vehicles and follow them, according to the Orange County District Attorney. The case drove the community push that put the city's 46-camera Flock contract back before the council in July 2026.
State high court struck down a geofence warrantMN
Wrongful stop
In State v. Contreras-Sanchez, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled in 2026 that a geofence warrant violated the state constitution by giving police unchecked discretion over Google location data swept from everyone in an area.
Fifty days jailed despite an out-of-state alibiFL
Data misuse
Jalil Richardson was misidentified as a vehicle thief by Jacksonville Sheriff's Office facial recognition and held more than 50 days, even though time sheets showed he was at work in North Carolina. Charges were dropped.
ICE acknowledges using commercial phone-hacking spywareDC
Wrongful stop
In April 2026 ICE's acting director confirmed to Congress that the agency uses Paragon's Graphite spyware, which can silently compromise a phone with no user interaction and extract its contents; the Trump administration had reinstated the paused Paragon contract, and Democratic lawmakers pressed for answers about its use inside the United States.
Jailed 13 days for a fatal crash she was not atFL
Wrongful stop
Officers in Volusia County relied on a Flock capture to place an innocent driver's car at the scene of a deadly crash on Interstate 4. She was arrested and spent 13 days in jail before the charges were dropped. This is a human-error case rather than a misread: the camera recorded what it saw and officers drew the wrong conclusion from it. Thirteen days is among the longest wrongful detentions in the national tally, and it began with a photograph of a car.
2.5 million searches in six monthsCA
Data misuse
The number that shows what oversight is actually up against: data from San Jose's network of 474 Flock cameras was searched nearly 2.5 MILLION times in the last six months of 2025 -- an average of more than 15,000 searches per day -- with almost no oversight, per the Institute for Justice's complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief filed against the city in Apr 2026. At that volume, IJ's Fourth Amendment argument writes itself: no audit regime reviews fifteen thousand daily queries, so misuse detection at any scale is sampling, not supervision -- attorney Michael Soyfer's phrase is that it would be impossible to find all the misuse. The suit asks the court to treat plate-database mining as a search requiring a warrant, the same question the Kansas ALPR suit raises and the one Chatrie's geofence holding put on constitutional thin ice. Filed as an incident pending the case's outcome; date is the filing month.
Detective tracked his estranged wife and her suspected partnersKS
Data misuse
Kyle Rector, a detective in Bonner Springs, Kansas, allegedly used license plate readers to track his estranged wife and two men he suspected were her new romantic partners. He was charged with multiple crimes in March 2026. The case is part of the Institute for Justice's review of at least eighteen incidents of officers using automated plate readers to monitor people in their personal lives.
Orlando, FL -- police denied using facial recognition in a theft case; their own review found they had, and charges were droppedFL
Wrongful stop
ORLANDO POLICE DENIED USING FACIAL RECOGNITION IN A THEFT CASE; THEIR OWN INVESTIGATION FOUND THEY HAD, AND THE CHARGES WERE DROPPED. WESH reported Feb 18, 2026 that Beau Burgess of New Smyrna Beach was arrested by a Volusia County deputy in Aug 2025 on two Orlando warrants for fraud and theft over more than $4,400 in unpaid charges at Universal Orlando hotels in June 2025. An Orlando officer had run a body-camera still through FACES, the state face-matching system run by the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, which returned a decade-old booking photo of Burgess; a hotel employee then picked him from a six-photo lineup. In Nov 2025 the department's chief of staff, David Arnott, denied by email that facial recognition was used; an internal investigation later found it had been, and exonerated two officers of policy violations after Burgess filed complaints. The Orange-Osceola State Attorney dropped both cases. Police say a FACES match is an investigative lead, not probable cause, and that the employee's identification supported the judge-signed warrant. NOT ESTABLISHED: how long Burgess was jailed, the date the charges were dropped, and whether he has sued.
A six-week-old alone in the car while both parents were cuffed at gunpointAR
Wrongful stop
On February 11, 2026 a Flock camera in Sherwood, Arkansas misread the plate on an SUV and Sherwood police ran a felony stop on the wrong vehicle. Officer Seth Kinkade drew his weapon and ordered the driver out; the driver complied calmly and was handcuffed. Officer Joe Lackey then arrived, drew his own firearm, and pulled the driver's partner from the car at gunpoint, cuffing her in front of the children in the vehicle. A six-week-old baby was left alone in a car seat in the back throughout. The correction came over the radio while officers were still walking to the rear of the car -- the dispatcher read the actual plate as ending '52'. They uncuffed the couple several minutes later. One officer's explanation on camera is the part worth keeping: those cameras are placed everywhere and they hit license plates, and he was not going to say they are completely perfect, because that is modern technology. The stop happened not far from a pair of Flock cameras.
Deputy tracked and pulled over a strangerFL
Data misuse
Lamar Roman, a Monroe County sheriff's deputy in the Florida Keys, allegedly used an automated plate-reader system to track and eventually pull over a woman he had met while working a security detail on a television production set. He was arrested in February 2026 and charged with accessing a computer or electronic device without authorization. The Institute for Justice highlights the case as a rare example of an officer targeting a complete stranger rather than a former partner.
Deputy tracked a woman he met on a TV setFL
Data misuse
A deputy tracked and pulled over a woman he had met while working security on a TV set
Federal agencies accessed city data without authorizationCA
Data misuse
Mountain View, California shut down all 30 of its Flock cameras in February 2026 after an audit found the ATF, the Air Force, and a GSA inspector general had accessed the city's surveillance data without authorization.
Covert federal plate readers disguised as traffic barrelsCA
Data misuse
EFF mapped more than 40 covert plate readers, many disguised as traffic barrels, that CBP and the DEA placed along San Diego and Imperial County highways, bypassing California's 2016 ALPR law. One resident with legal status was interrogated by agents about her casino trips.
1.6 million out-of-state searches of city camerasCA
Data misuse
Two events, one system. In Feb 2026 the Oakland firm Gibbs Mura filed a class action in San Francisco Superior Court alleging Flock let out-of-state and federal agencies search the SFPD ALPR database more than 1.6 million times over a seven-month period -- attorney David Berger told KTVU the sharing is illegal under California law, which bars giving ALPR data to out-of-state or federal agencies. The suit puts nearby Los Altos above a million outside searches, seeks statutory damages of $2,500 per violation, and names ICE, CBP, the FBI and ATF among querying agencies; Mountain View terminated its contract on finding violations, and El Cerrito audits twice found federal access, once after settings should have prevented it. Then in Jun 2026 SFPD's own routine compliance audit confirmed the mechanism from the inside: the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center had queried San Francisco's Flock network on behalf of federal and out-of-state agencies, with the same requests hitting between 531 and 763 other agencies simultaneously. SFPD said neither ICE nor DHS was identified among the requesters, shut off the access, and opened a review -- record both the allegation and the department's narrower audit finding, because they do not fully agree. The line that carries furthest is Flock's own: spokesperson Paris Lewbel told KTVU the searches were not a malfunction, platform issue, unauthorized access, or any failure of the Flock system. Nothing broke. The sharing was the product working as configured.
Amazon Ring cuts ties with Flock after Super Bowl adUS
Wrongful stop
Days after Flock Safety's February 2026 Super Bowl advertisement showed millions of Americans the true scale of its nationwide camera network, Amazon's Ring terminated its partnership with the company. The planned integration would have made it easier to feed Ring doorbell video into Flock's law-enforcement ecosystem; the swift corporate retreat under public backlash became one of the most visible moments of the anti-Flock wave and helped push the tally of canceled municipal contracts past 50.
733,000 searches on a school district's 8 camerasTX
Data misuse
An investigation found that in a single month more than 3,100 police agencies ran over 733,000 Flock searches against eight cameras owned by one Texas school district, Alvin ISD. More than 620 searches were immigration-related, and agencies from Florida, Georgia, Indiana, and Tennessee ran immigration checks on a school parking-lot camera.
Former deputy charged with stalking via FlockGA
Data misuse
Chris Rozar, a former Coffee County sheriff's deputy in Georgia, was charged in 2026 with multiple criminal offenses after allegedly using the department's Flock system to stalk a woman he was romantically interested in. The case is among at least eighteen documented by the Institute for Justice of officers abusing plate-reader access for personal reasons.
Gwinnett officer arrested for tracking an exGA
Data misuse
Gwinnett County officer Renee Downer was arrested and relieved of duty in 2026 after allegedly using law-enforcement databases, including a license-plate reader system, to monitor the location of a former romantic partner. The case is among at least two dozen the Institute for Justice has documented in which officers used ALPR systems to track romantic interests. UPDATE, SEP 2026: Downer has been fired, and two more Gwinnett officers -- Derric Holmes (six counts) and Matthew Lau (one count) -- were fired and charged with misuse of license plate data after the department's June 2026 Flock audit upgrade. Gwinnett now requires a supervisor-approved reason for each search and cut retention from 30 to 15 days.
Pasadena TX sergeant resigned over Flock stalking claimTX
Data misuse
Pasadena, Texas police Sergeant Michael Palitz resigned in 2026 while under investigation for allegedly using the department's Flock cameras to track and stalk a female officer, according to officials cited by KPRC 2. The case is part of a documented pattern of officers misusing plate-reader systems for personal reasons.
Air Force engineer charged with sawing down 13 Flock camerasVA
Wrongful stop
In Suffolk, Virginia, Jeffrey Sovern, a 41-year-old U.S. Air Force engineer and mechanic, was charged with taking down 13 Flock cameras with a saw. He pleaded not guilty to 25 counts: 13 felony counts of destruction of property, six counts of petit larceny, and six counts of possession of burglary tools. The case shows how far frustration with unaccountable plate-reader networks has escalated -- and sits alongside the lawful route the same state offers, where Norfolk's Flock network faces a Fourth Amendment challenge (Schmidt v. City of Norfolk).
Bad plate entry got a driver pulled over again and againCO
Wrongful stop
In the Denver suburb of Cherry Hills Village, Kyle Dausman was repeatedly pulled over after his license plate was mistakenly entered into the ALPR system. 'I continually get pulled over,' he told 9NEWS. 'I can't really use my truck in any fashion. I believe my safety is at risk. They zipped out of nowhere and immediately got behind me with the lights flashing.' A single bad database entry turned an automated dragnet into recurring police stops of an innocent driver.
Deputy used Flock to track an ex-fiancee's friendCA
Data misuse
Alexander Vanny, a Riverside County sheriff's deputy in California, used the department's Flock system to track a friend of his ex-fiancee after he had been arrested for kidnapping the ex-fiancee. In December 2025 a jury convicted him on multiple charges. The Institute for Justice lists his case among at least eighteen in which officers allegedly used automated plate readers to monitor romantic interests; Flock says such misuse is rare and that it has internal safeguards.
Flock searches tied to protest crackdownsUS
Data misuse
An analysis of 12 million Flock searches by 3,900 agencies found hundreds tied to political protests, including the No Kings and Hands Off demonstrations.
Flock cameras left streaming on the open internetUS
Data misuse
Security researchers found dozens of Flock cameras streaming live to the open internet without passwords, exposing live feeds and about a month of archived footage. Some logins later appeared on Russian cybercrime forums, and Senator Ron Wyden called for an FTC investigation while Flock called it a misconfiguration.
Plate reader used to ticket a phone-holding riderGA
Data misuse
Georgia State Patrol ticketed a motorcyclist for holding a cell phone, with the citation noting it was captured on a Flock camera, despite the vendor's claim that its readers are not used for traffic enforcement.
Casino face scan leads to a wrong arrestNV
Data misuse
Jason Killinger was arrested after a Reno casino's facial recognition flagged him as a banned trespasser. He and the real man had different eye colors, and the match did not hold up.
Police expand face search to petty crimesTX
Data misuse
Dallas police contracted Clearview AI in 2024 and used it 156 times in a year, then moved to expand face searches from serious felonies to misdemeanors such as theft and trespassing. The ACLU warned that running minor cases against the world's broadest scraped-face database is dangerous and prone to misidentification.
People-tracking cameras left open online, exposing kids at a playgroundUS
Data misuse
In December 2025, researcher Benn Jordan found roughly 60 Flock Condor cameras sitting open on the public internet with no password. Unlike Flock's plate-reading units, the Condor model is built to pan, tilt, zoom, and track people; among the exposed live feeds was footage of unattended children at a playground. Jordan showed the footage could be used to identify people by face or plate. Flock called it a limited misconfiguration that has since been fixed.
Pulled over again and again because of a typoCO
Wrongful stop
A Boulder County driver was repeatedly stopped by police after officers mistakenly entered her license plate onto a Flock hotlist. Nothing was wrong with the camera or her car. The plate simply sat on a list of vehicles to be flagged, and every camera she passed generated a fresh alert until somebody worked out why. Colorado produced three of these in five months -- Boulder County, Jefferson County and Cherry Hills -- which points at the absence of any routine review of what goes onto a hotlist or how it comes off.
80-plus agencies searched with anti-Romani slursUS
Data misuse
EFF found more than 80 agencies used anti-Romani slurs as search terms in the Flock network
Border Patrol's secret nationwide plate-reader dragnetUS
Data misuse
An AP investigation found Border Patrol had secretly built a nationwide network of plate readers, supplemented by the DEA and private vendors including Vigilant and Rekor, flagging movement it deemed suspicious and having local police make pretext stops.
City runs 500 plate readers, searched without warrantsCA
Data misuse
San Jose police blanketed the city with nearly 500 plate readers, kept the data for a year, and let officers statewide search it without a warrant. EFF and the ACLU sued, arguing the warrantless searches violate the California Constitution.
Oklahoma: are ALPRs even legal outside insurance checks?OK
Wrongful stop
At an Oklahoma House Public Safety Committee interim study on Oct 16, 2025, Rep. Tom Gann (R-Inola) argued that ALPRs in Oklahoma may STATUTORILY be used only to check whether a motorist carries auto insurance -- the purpose the legislature authorized in 2013 with HB 1792, the Oklahoma Temporary Motorist Liability Plan, passed to cut the state's uninsured-driver rate. On that reading, every investigative Flock deployment in the state is operating outside its statutory authority. Note precisely what this is: a legislator's argument at a committee study, not a court holding and not an attorney general opinion -- no ruling has tested it. But it is a live legal question rather than a policy preference, and it applies statewide. Speakers included University of Tulsa law professor Shena Burgess and former Logan County commissioner Marven Goodman, who described how ALPR data combines with other records into a "mosaic" tracking a person's movements whether or not they are suspected of anything. This matters directly for the deferred Oklahoma City Flock renewal: OKC, Edmond, Harrah, Jenks and Tulsa all run ALPRs, and if the statutory argument has force it reaches all of them at once, which no single council vote can do.
Internal audit caught an officer tracking a colleagueFL
Data misuse
Coty Hall, a former Niceville, Florida police officer, pleaded no contest to several charges after using the department's Flock system to track another officer and that officer's spouse. Unlike most cases in the Institute for Justice's review, his misconduct was discovered through an internal audit; he was fired following his arrest in October 2025.
Three held at gunpoint over false Flock alertsNM
Data misuse
Three people, including two minors, were held at gunpoint after erroneous Flock alerts
State sued a city over out-of-state ALPR sharingCA
Data misuse
The California attorney general sued the city after it shared ALPR data with more than 100 agencies in other states; its data was used in immigration-related searches over 500 times in a year.
Police shared data despite a shield lawMA
Data misuse
Despite a Massachusetts shield law on abortion and gender care, police shared driver-movement data with Flock's network of 7,000 agencies.
Sheriff found violating state plate-reader lawCA
Data misuse
The Humboldt County, California Sheriff was found violating state license plate reader laws governing how the data is shared and protected.
State sued the city over nationwide data sharingCA
Data misuse
In October 2025 California Attorney General Rob Bonta sued the City of El Cajon for sharing license-plate-reader data with more than 100 out-of-state and federal law-enforcement agencies across 26 states, in violation of California's SB 34. The city refused repeated warnings to stop, and the attorney general filed a further motion to compel compliance in February 2026.
Police tracked an op-ed writer with plate readersKS
Data misuse
After Lenexa resident Canyen Ashworth published a Kansas City Star op-ed on Sept. 30, 2025 criticizing the police department's role in ICE operations, Lenexa police opened an investigation and used the city's ALPRs to track his movements, issuing a BOLO tying him to anti-ICE posters. He was never the person in the video and was never charged.
Sergeant ran plates to build a commercial productGA
Data misuse
Every other misuse record on this map is an officer looking up a person. This one is an officer mining the network as a business input. Sandy Springs reserve Sergeant Francis Esposito, with the department since 2016 and promoted in 2021, ran license plates on his city Flock login and, the city's investigation concluded, passed the data to Signal 8 -- a Canton-based public-safety software startup he also worked for, founded by a former Sandy Springs detective who did not respond to reporters. The inquiry began with a whistleblower, a former Signal 8 employee, who told investigators the Flock data had been used for beta testing and product validation. Investigators concluded Esposito may have violated several Georgia laws including corporate espionage. He declined to answer their questions and resigned in Aug 2025; the city records the outcome as a termination and referred him to the Georgia Peace Officer Standards and Training Council, which can bar him from law enforcement permanently. THE OTHER SIDE, recorded because a record is not a verdict: Signal 8 denies instructing him to run any plates, says he acted on his own, and states that no Flock or City of Sandy Springs data was ever shared, transmitted or transferred to the company. The resignation-versus-termination discrepancy is left as it stands in the documents. Why it generalises: the value of a municipal ALPR network to a private firm is a motive that audit rules written around personal snooping were not designed to catch.
Grant fraud and a false FBI compliance sign-offIA
Data misuse
After Iowa's Department of Public Safety investigated a complaint that Story County had applied a criminal-justice-information grant to a Flock contract without the required security compliance, Flock's security chief signed a federal CJIS certification despite knowing the company's devices failed basic requirements, and a state grant official backdated the missing paperwork while calling the complaint unfounded.
ICE face-scan app handed to local policeUS
Data misuse
A leaked DHS Privacy Threshold Analysis revealed the ICE Task Force Module (also called Mobile Identify), a phone app that lets roughly 1,300 local 287(g) officers scan the faces of people they stop and match them against more than 250 million government records, including visa and TSA traveler photos. It launched in September 2025 alongside ICE and CBP's own Mobile Fortify app.
Blamed for a string of thefts on a misread of the footageCO
Wrongful stop
An officer in the Denver area misinterpreted Flock captures and identified an innocent woman as responsible for a series of thefts. The camera worked; the reading of its output did not. IJ classifies roughly two thirds of the cases in its national review this way -- not machine failure but officers entering wrong information or drawing unsupported conclusions from what the system showed them, which is the part no accuracy percentage from a vendor can address.
One state audit of twelve departments paused federal access nationwideIL
Wrongful stop
A STATE OFFICER AUDITED THE VENDOR AND FOUND A STATUTE BROKEN -- THEN FOUND A SECOND VENDOR DOING THE SAME. Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias announced on 25 August 2025 that a sample audit of twelve local law enforcement agencies, begun in June, had found Flock Safety allowed US Customs and Border Protection to access Illinois plate-camera data, in breach of a 2023 state law that bars ALPR operators from sharing data for immigration or abortion enforcement and defines a private vendor as a party the Secretary can hold to it. He ordered CBP access shut off at once. THE DETAIL THAT MATTERS MOST: the audit found Flock had NO PROPER SAFEGUARDS for data sharing, compounded by a CBP PILOT PROGRAMME THAT FLOCK'S OWN LEADERSHIP WAS UNAWARE OF. The company then paused its pilots with CBP and other federal agencies not just in Illinois but NATIONWIDE -- so one state's sample audit of twelve departments changed federal access across the whole network. FLOCK'S POSITION, IN ITS OWN WORDS: chief executive Garrett Langley wrote that the company had communicated poorly and had not created distinct permissions and protocols in its system to ensure local compliance for federal users, and that some of its earlier public statements had inadvertently been inaccurate. The company ADMITS THE CONTROLS WERE INADEQUATE and DISPUTES THE LEGAL CONCLUSION. Both halves are on the record. THEN IT HAPPENED AGAIN WITH A DIFFERENT VENDOR. On 5 September 2025 the same office found the Village of Forest Park's police department giving CBP access to its camera data through MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS equipment; Motorola worked with the village to disable it. Two vendors, one audit programme, the same failure -- which moves the finding from one company's defect to a structural feature of how these networks share. Giannoulias urged every Illinois department to re-examine what access it grants, against the state's Trust Act, which bars local collaboration with federal immigration enforcement without a court warrant. Hundreds of out-of-state agencies hold access to Illinois readers. THE SEQUENCE IS THE REASON THIS RECORD SITS AT THE STATE LEVEL: Oak Park had already terminated over exactly this concern before the audit confirmed it; Evanston terminated the same week the audit was published, citing it directly. A council objection became a state finding, and the state finding then became grounds other councils cited. UPDATE: THERE WAS NO PENALTY TO IMPOSE. Capitol News Illinois reported two days after the audit that the 2023 data-sharing ban carries no specific penalty for violating it. The Secretary of State's leverage came from the statute treating a vendor that shares data as a regulated plate-reader user, which let his office demand the shutoff -- and Flock complied, pausing federal pilots nationwide. His office said it was consulting the Attorney General; no fine, suit or AG action has been reported since. That makes the Illinois model a disclosure-and-compliance power, not an enforcement one. COMPARED WITH OTHER STATUTES CHECKED: Virginia's 2025 law binds vendors more tightly on paper -- they may touch data only at the agency's request for maintenance, must certify they will not sell or share it, and the data belongs to the agency -- but it is enforced through each department's contract, with no state officer auditing the company. Idaho's 2025 law regulates only agencies. NOT ESTABLISHED: whether any other state gives an officer direct audit power over the vendor; a full 50-state review has not been done.
Border Patrol tapped local cameras without sign-offWA
Data misuse
Records obtained by the University of Washington Center for Human Rights found that U.S. Border Patrol had apparent back-door access from May to August 2025 to Flock plate-reader networks run by at least ten Washington police departments that had never authorized immigration searches, and that at least eight agencies enabled direct sharing with Border Patrol. Washington limits local cooperation with immigration enforcement; researchers warned that the national network let federal agents and out-of-state police search local movement data, including searches tied to immigration. Flock and CBP described some of the access as a limited pilot.
Border Patrol got back-door access to WA networksWA
Data misuse
Border Patrol gained front-door, back-door, and side-door access to at least ten Washington police Flock networks that never authorized immigration sharing.
Secret pilot gave CBP access to ALPR dataCO
Data misuse
An undisclosed Flock pilot let Customs and Border Protection pull ALPR data from agencies that never intended to share with federal authorities.
Arrested on a Florida FACES false matchFL
Data misuse
Beau Burgess was wrongfully arrested in August 2025 after Florida's statewide FACES facial-recognition system, run by the Pinellas County Sheriff, flagged him as a suspect. It was one of several Florida wrongful arrests traced to the same system.
A third Colorado driver on a hotlist by mistakeCO
Wrongful stop
A Jefferson County driver was repeatedly pulled over after officers mistakenly placed her license plate on a Flock hotlist -- the same failure that hit Boulder County four months later and Cherry Hills the following spring. Three separate Colorado jurisdictions, the same mechanism, no camera malfunction involved in any of them. The error is administrative and it is the kind that persists until the person it happens to complains loudly enough to get it traced.
Handcuffed in his driveway for his son's warrantWA
Wrongful stop
HANDCUFFED IN HIS OWN DRIVEWAY FOR SOMEONE ELSE'S WARRANT. Redmond police detained Thor Andrews Sr. after Flock flagged his Ford Fusion as 'associated' with his son, who had an outstanding felony warrant. The car was registered to the father. No character was misread: the system connected the right plate to the wrong person, and officers acted on the connection. KING 5 reported the case in November 2025; the Institute for Justice dates the stop to August 2025. Not established: whether guns were drawn, how long he was held, or whether he has filed a claim. Redmond's council voted in November 2025 to suspend the city's Flock program; accounts differ on how much this case drove that vote. Ask Redmond PD: what does an 'associated vehicle' flag require before officers act on it, and who can add one? SOURCING: KING 5's report could not be opened; the facts here come from two advocacy sites that reposted it, and the date is the Institute for Justice's.
Officer tracked an ex hundreds of times in two monthsKY
Data misuse
Roberto Cedeno, a Louisville, Kentucky police officer, was charged in 2025 with multiple felonies after allegedly using the city's automated plate-reader system to track an ex-partner and her friends hundreds of times over two months. His case appears in the Institute for Justice's review of at least eighteen incidents of officers using plate readers to follow romantic interests.
Axon's AI hides who wrote police reportsUS
Data misuse
EFF found that Axon's Draft One, which writes police reports from body-camera audio, deletes its drafts so no record shows what the AI wrote versus the officer. King County, Washington and others barred police from using AI to write reports.
Nearly 3,000 searches used ICE-related termsVA
Data misuse
Network audit logs in Bridgewater and Mecklenburg County, Virginia showed nearly 3,000 Flock searches using terms like 'ICE,' 'ERO,' and 'deportee.'
Sheriff ran plate searches for Border PatrolCA
Data misuse
An audit of plate-data searches showed the Orange County Sheriff ran queries on behalf of Customs and Border Protection or the Border Patrol, among ten Southern California agencies searching plate data on ICE's behalf.
Sheriff ran plate searches for CBPCA
Data misuse
An audit of plate-data searches showed the San Diego County Sheriff ran queries on behalf of Customs and Border Protection, part of a pattern of Southern California agencies searching plate data for immigration enforcement.
Federal immigration queried Bend's plate readers 279 timesOR
Data misuse
Reporting found that federal immigration authorities queried the Bend Police Department's Flock ALPR database 279 times in June 2025, in apparent violation of Oregon's sanctuary law barring local agencies from assisting immigration enforcement. The disclosure helped drive Bend's move to end its Flock program and fed the push for a statewide ALPR law.
Deputy searched 83,000 cameras to track an abortionTX
Data misuse
A sheriff's deputy in Johnson County, Texas used Flock's national lookup to search more than 83,000 cameras nationwide for a woman his office suspected of a self-managed abortion, logging the reason as a missing-person check. The searches swept up plate data from agencies in states where abortion is legal, including Washington. After 404 Media reported it, Flock added filters blocking abortion and immigration searches, and a bipartisan group in Congress called it a gross misuse of surveillance technology. The sheriff said his office was trying to protect the woman's safety. THE ILLINOIS END. The Texas search reached into Mount Prospect, Illinois: in June 2025 Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias said the Mount Prospect police department's Flock data had been available to the Johnson County search and to 262 immigration-related searches in early 2025, both barred under Illinois law. His office opened an audit of all Illinois departments, at least 46 out-of-state agencies were cut off from Flock's Illinois network, and Mount Prospect left Flock's national lookup. Chief Michael Eterno said the department never had any agreement with Texas.
Flock searched nationwide over a self-managed abortionTX
Data misuse
A Johnson County, Texas sheriff's office searched more than 83,000 Flock ALPR cameras nationwide while investigating a woman who had a self-managed abortion, logging the reason as 'had an abortion, search for female'. Records later showed deputies had consulted prosecutors about charging her.
ICE ran 4,000-plus Flock lookups with no contractUS
Data misuse
ICE, which holds no Flock contract, had local police run more than 4,000 nationwide Flock lookups on its behalf for immigration enforcement.
Plate readers used for school-residency checksOH
Data misuse
Delhi Township police in Ohio ran 35 plate-reader searches tied to students at five schools over three months to check residency, and defended the practice.
489,000 searches of one county's plate data in a monthCA
Data misuse
An audit of the Riverside County, California Sheriff's Flock system showed roughly 489,000 searches in a single month, including searches referencing Customs and Border Protection and Homeland Security Investigations cases.
Private network runs live face scans on Bourbon StLA
Data misuse
For two years New Orleans police secretly received real-time facial-recognition alerts from Project NOLA, a private nonprofit running more than 200 face-scanning cameras around the French Quarter, circumventing a city ordinance that barred live face surveillance. After the Washington Post exposed it in 2025, the department paused the automated alerts.
Police ran plate readers to check school residencyGA
Data misuse
Police in Buford, Georgia ran license plate reader searches across more than 5,800 networks nationwide to verify whether families lived within a school zone, exposing where people worship, seek care, and travel.
Held two days despite an obvious mismatchNY
Data misuse
New York police arrested Trevis Williams on a facial-recognition match even though he was about eight inches taller and seventy pounds heavier than the actual suspect. He spent two days in jail, and civil-rights groups demanded a review of NYPD facial recognition.
Out-of-state agencies ran ICE searches of KyleTX
Data misuse
Agencies from 10 states ran at least 117 immigration-related searches of Kyle, Texas Flock cameras, more than half flagged 'ICE.'
Flock photo led to false arrest in CumberlandRI
Wrongful stop
A FLOCK PHOTO LED TO A FALSE ARREST IN CUMBERLAND, AND THE ACLU ASKED THE TOWN TO CANCEL. The ACLU of Rhode Island wrote to the Cumberland Town Council urging it to end its Flock Safety contract after an image from the system led to the arrest of the wrong person; the Valley Breeze reports a lawsuit over the arrest. Coverage suggests the case turned on a photo of a car's occupants rather than a plate misread. NOT ESTABLISHED: the date of the arrest and of the letter, the lawsuit's status, and whether the council acted. Ask the council whether the contract was renewed.
Flock told police to hide case numbers from recordsCA
Data misuse
In a form email, Flock advised the Ridgecrest, California police department to keep search reasons as vague as permissible, and the department disabled case numbers in its public transparency portal, obscuring whether ALPR searches were tied to real investigations.
Chief stalked women seeking protective ordersGA
Data misuse
Braselton, Georgia police chief Michael Steffman resigned and was arrested in 2025 after several people, including women who had sought protective orders, accused him of using Flock cameras to follow them through neighborhoods and even send them maps of their own movements. Prosecutors charged him with stalking and related counts.
Sheriff searched for his wife's vehicle hundreds of timesID
Data misuse
Jerome County, Idaho sheriff George Oppedyk used a Flock system to search for his wife's vehicle hundreds of times. The state attorney general found no crime, and he retired in 2026, two years before his term ended.
Officer indicted on 23 counts of Flock misuseTN
Data misuse
Former Oak Ridge officer Zachary Gauthier was indicted on 23 counts of official misconduct, including 18 for misusing the Flock system for personal reasons.
Drones flown proactively over crowds and protestsNY
Data misuse
New York City's Drone as First Responder program flies proactively over parks, large gatherings, and demonstrations. In a November 2024 briefing a deputy commissioner said that when no 911 call is pending he expects the drone team to launch over runners, crowds, and protests -- which the ACLU warns turns emergency drones into routine aerial surveillance.
Officer ran an ex's plate dozens of timesFL
Data misuse
Orange City, Florida officer Jarmarus Brown ran his ex-girlfriend's license plate through Flock at least 69 times during the summer of 2024, plus her parents' plates dozens more, court records show, so often that a colleague noticed him doing it from his cruiser. He was arrested and charged in 2025 with stalking and improper computer access. It is one of at least 18 cases the Institute for Justice documented of officers using plate readers to track romantic interests, most surfacing only after victims complained.
Flagged for a crime 300 miles from homeFL
Data misuse
A Pinellas County FACES facial-recognition search flagged Robert Dillon, a Fort Myers man who lives more than 300 miles away and had never been to Jacksonville Beach, as a suspect in a 2024 child-enticement case. An ALPR search showed his car was never near the scene. Charges were dropped and he sued in June 2026. THE PLATE READERS CLEARED HIM AND THE WARRANT APPLICATION LEFT THAT OUT. According to the federal complaint filed June 10, 2026 in the Middle District of Florida, a license plate reader database search showed no hits on Dillon's car anywhere near the Jacksonville Beach restaurant in the days around the crime -- and the police omitted that result, with other key facts, when they applied for the warrant that led to his August 2024 arrest. Every other plate-reader record on this map is about the system implicating someone; this one is about the system exonerating someone and the exoneration being withheld from the judge. The suit names Jacksonville Beach police, the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office and the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office. ASK: whether departments treat a negative ALPR result as material to disclose in a warrant affidavit.
Guns drawn in a Chick-fil-A drive-throughIN
Wrongful stop
Lafayette police detained an innocent man at gunpoint in a Chick-fil-A drive-through after a Flock camera misread his license plate. He sued the department. The location is worth recording rather than treating as colour: a felony stop executed in a queue of cars at a fast-food window puts bystanders inside the encounter, and the decision to run it there followed from a computer hit nobody had confirmed.
Evansville, IN -- officer resigned after personal Clearview AI face searchesIN
Wrongful stop
AN OFFICER HID PERSONAL FACE SEARCHES UNDER A REAL CASE NUMBER. An Evansville, Indiana police officer resigned after an audit of the department's Clearview AI facial recognition use found searches with no link to any real incident, Chief Philip Smith said in June 2024. The audit was run in March during talks on renewing the subscription, when officials noticed one officer's very heavy use did not match his work output. The searched images were unlike the live or CCTV images used in real investigations, and the officer attached a genuine case number from an actual incident to disguise them. Smith said department rules already limited the tool to official use. NOT ESTABLISHED in the cited reports: the officer's name, how many searches, and whom he searched.
Teenager handcuffed at gunpoint over a reader stopSC
Wrongful stop
In May 2024, Myrtle Beach, South Carolina police held a Black teenager at gunpoint and handcuffed her after a license-plate reader led officers to stop her vehicle. She filed a civil-rights lawsuit alleging the officers wrongfully detained her and knew before drawing their weapons that they had pulled over the wrong vehicle.
Mauled by a police dog after a plate misreadOH
Wrongful stop
In April 2024, Toledo, Ohio police pulled over Brandon Upchurch after a Flock plate reader misread a 7 on his license plate as a 2 and flagged his vehicle. He was attacked by a police dog, accused of resisting, and spent time in jail before the error came to light. Business Insider and the Toledo Blade documented the stop as one of several wrongful detentions caused by plate-reader misreads.
Man hurt by K-9 after Flock misread his plateOH
Data misuse
A man was hospitalized with police K-9 wounds after Flock misread his plate, and later lost his job and home
York County, SC -- veteran held at gunpoint after a Flock misread; suit removed to federal court, sheriff moves to dismissSC
Wrongful stop
AN INNOCENT MOTORIST WAS HELD AT GUNPOINT IN YORK COUNTY AFTER A FLOCK CAMERA MISREAD ONE CHARACTER OF HIS PLATE; HIS LAWSUIT IS NOW IN FEDERAL COURT. On Feb 14, 2024 York County deputies stopped Steven Melvin, 42, an Iraq War veteran from Lake Wylie, after a Flock alert flagged his black BMW as stolen; the sheriff's internal records say a tinted or obstructive plate cover caused the camera to misread the first character. The sheriff's office attributed the misread to the cover, an accessory sold legally in most states, which shifts responsibility to the driver while conceding that the system's output can put someone at gunpoint. According to the complaint, Deputy Kyle Brogden approached with his gun drawn, ordered Melvin out and had him kneel with his hands above his head for about five minutes while deputies checked the car; he was released with a warning for the plate cover. The sheriff's own internal affairs report, issued nine months after the stop, concluded the stop came from erroneous information associated with a Flock alert. Melvin sued in state court in June 2026 (Melvin v. York County Sheriff's Office et al.), naming three deputies and claiming excessive force, false imprisonment and negligence; the case was removed to the U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina, and the county's lawyers, David Holler and Ross Campbell, have asked the federal judge to dismiss, arguing a mistake of fact leading to a seizure is not a constitutional violation, Military.com reported Sep 16, 2026 citing the Rock Hill Herald. Sheriff Tony Breeden defends the system: access is restricted, case numbers are required, and he credits camera hits with more than 250 case resolutions. No trial date is set. NOT ESTABLISHED: the federal case number, the ruling on the motion to dismiss, and Melvin's counsel.
Police chief tracked an ex 228 timesKS
Data misuse
Lee Nygaard, then police chief of Sedgwick, Kansas, used Flock plate-reader cameras to track his ex-girlfriend's vehicles 228 times over more than four months in 2024, and at one point followed her and her new boyfriend in his police car. The case is among several in Kansas and nationwide in which officers in positions of trust turned the surveillance network on people they had personal grievances with.
Father and daughter handcuffed after a plate typoFL
Wrongful stop
On New Year's Day 2024 in the Tampa Bay area, a father and his daughter, who has epilepsy, were handcuffed and held at gunpoint after an officer made a typo while running their license plate through a plate-reader database, according to WTSP. The error wrongly flagged their vehicle before officers realized the mistake.
Officer ran hundreds of searches for an ex-partnerIL
Data misuse
Matteson, Illinois officer Jaila Cole-Clark ran hundreds of Flock searches for a former domestic partner and that person's new partner, and resigned during the investigation.
Retail face match jails an innocent man, assaulted in custodyTX
Wrongful stop
Harvey Eugene Murphy Jr., a 61-year-old grandfather, was wrongly jailed after facial-recognition software used by Sunglass Hut's parent EssilorLuxottica and retail partner Macy's falsely identified him as the gunman in a January 2022 armed robbery of a Houston Sunglass Hut. Murphy had been living in Sacramento, California at the time; when he returned to Texas to renew his license he was arrested in October 2023, denied bond, and held in the Harris County Jail, where three men sexually assaulted him before prosecutors verified his alibi and dropped the charges. His January 2024 lawsuit seeking $10 million spotlighted the dangers of low-quality footage, decades-old mugshots, and private companies steering police with unaccountable face matches.
A specialty plate that shared its number with a stolen truck's temporary tagKS
Wrongful stop
THE PLATE WAS REAL, THE NUMBER WAS NOT UNIQUE. Matthew and Leah Spurlock's KU Alumni specialty plate reads 7007. So did the temporary tag on a stolen GMC pickup, and Flock reads characters, not plate designs. A Colwich officer and a Sedgwick County deputy stopped Leah on the alert and spotted the mix-up quickly. The entry was said to be corrected. About a month later a Flock alert in Catoosa, Oklahoma brought a high-risk stop: guns drawn, both on their knees and handcuffed. KAKE reports that Kansas reuses plate numbers across more than 100 designs, so a stolen-car entry can match an innocent car in another state's reader network. The danger ended only when the stolen-vehicle entry expired. A Wichita police captain called a Flock hit 'more like the hunch'. KAKE reported the case on Jan 30, 2024; the stop dates are not given. Not established: any lawsuit, or whether Kansas has changed its numbering. Ask the Kansas Department of Revenue.
Deputy tracked his ex-wife more than 100 timesTN
Data misuse
Thadius Gordon, a Shelby County sheriff's deputy in Tennessee, was relieved of duty in 2024 after allegedly using an automated plate-reader database to track his ex-wife's location more than a hundred times. The case is one of at least eighteen documented by the Institute for Justice in which officers allegedly used plate readers to monitor partners or exes; most came to light only after victims reported being stalked rather than through internal audits.
Wrongful arrest despite clearing evidenceMO
Wrongful stop
ABOUT 17 MONTHS IN JAIL, AND NOW AMAZON IS A DEFENDANT. Christopher Gatlin was arrested in St. Louis on Aug 14, 2021 for a December 2020 assault on a MetroLink guard after a search on the region's mugshot face-recognition system pointed police to him. He could not post a $75,000 cash bond and spent about 17 months in jail before a judge threw out the witness identification in February 2024; prosecutors dropped the case the next month. He sued the officers, the city and St. Louis County in January 2025, and in October 2025 the court let his main claims proceed, including failure to train officers on face recognition. In August 2026 he added Amazon Web Services, alleging the system ran on Amazon Rekognition. AWS says its terms bar police from using that feature in criminal investigations and that it does not know how St. Louis used it. NOT ESTABLISHED: the damages sought and a trial date.
Miami wrongful arrest from a face matchFL
Wrongful stop
Jason Vernau was wrongfully arrested in Miami after being misidentified by face recognition, and jailed despite available evidence that he was not the correct match. The local department had told Congress it does not arrest on face recognition alone.
Handcuffed after a plate-reader dragnet for a car modelMI
Wrongful stop
Detroit police knew a shooting involved a Dodge Charger, then used plate readers to list every Charger in the area. Officers went to Isoke Robinson home, handcuffed her, placed her two-year-old in a patrol car, and impounded her car for three weeks, even though it had been recorded two miles from the shooting.
23 million Californians' plate data sold by repo-truck vendorTX
Data misuse
A California class action, Mata v. DRN, alleges Digital Recognition Network -- Motorola's commercial plate-scanning arm and Vigilant's sister company -- broke state law by mounting cameras on repo and private vehicles and selling roughly 23 million Californians' location data to insurers, lenders, and repossession firms.
Guns drawn on two 19-year-olds in the wrong CamaroTX
Wrongful stop
GUNS DRAWN ON THE WRONG CAMARO. On Aug 3, 2023 Harris County sheriff's deputies stopped two 19-year-olds in a Cypress neighborhood, drew weapons and handcuffed both. A Flock camera had logged a stolen Camaro's plate in the area. Deputies then stopped a similar-looking car whose plate neither they nor a helicopter crew had read. The camera did not misread anything. The stop went ahead without anyone confirming the plate. Neither man was charged. The sheriff's office said supervisors would review the body-camera footage, and the men were told how to file internal-affairs complaints. Their family said it would hire a lawyer. Not established: the outcome of any complaint, and whether a suit was filed. Ask HCSO: must a deputy confirm the plate before a high-risk stop on a Flock alert?
Child handcuffed after a plate misreadNM
Wrongful stop
Police in Espanola detained Jaclynn Gonzales at gunpoint and placed her twelve-year-old sister in a patrol car after a plate reader misread the last digit of the plate, a 2 read as a 7, according to a lawsuit against the city.
Family held at gunpoint after a plate-entry typoTX
Wrongful stop
In July 2023, Frisco, Texas police held an Arkansas family at gunpoint on the Dallas North Tollway and handcuffed a child after an officer mistyped their license plate's state when running it, wrongly flagging their car as stolen. A sergeant arrived, caught the error, and called off the high-risk stop. The police chief apologized and opened a review, saying the department would not hide from its mistakes; the family, who were driving to a youth basketball tournament, hired a lawyer.
A teenager at gunpoint after officers typed it in wrongNM
Wrongful stop
In the same month that Espanola officers stopped two sisters over a misread digit, a separate stop in the same town put an innocent teenager at gunpoint -- this time because officers had entered incorrect information into the ALPR system themselves. Two gunpoint detentions of young people in one small New Mexico city in one month, one caused by the machine and one by the people operating it. The sisters sued; their case is recorded separately on this map.
Family stopped at gunpoint with a toddler aboardTN
Wrongful stop
In June 2023 in Morristown, Tennessee, a Flock plate reader misread an O as a 0 and flagged the Herron family's vehicle, leading officers to pull them over at gunpoint with their three-year-old granddaughter in the car. The family, on their way to a doctor, said they posed no threat. Business Insider and local reporting cited the stop among cases where plate-reader errors put innocent drivers at gunpoint.
A plate left on a hotlist after the reason was goneOH
Wrongful stop
Jackson Township officers pulled over and detained an innocent driver because they had failed to remove a license plate from a hotlist. The case is documented in federal court filings rather than only in news coverage, which makes it one of the better-evidenced examples of the pattern: a hotlist is easy to add to and nobody owns the job of taking things off it. The same failure produced the Greenville and Hercules detentions.
Pregnant woman wrongly arrested via face matchMI
Wrongful stop
Porcha Woodruff, eight months pregnant, was wrongfully arrested in Detroit in February 2023 for carjacking and robbery after a face-recognition match. She was detained for hours before being released, and the charges were later dropped.
Arrested for an out-of-state crime via face matchGA
Wrongful stop
Randal Reid was arrested near Atlanta in November 2022 for a Louisiana purse theft he did not commit, after a Louisiana agency used a face-recognition match. He spent several days in jail before the warrants were withdrawn.
Arrested in one state for a crime in anotherLA
Data misuse
Georgia police arrested Randal Quran Reid on a Louisiana warrant after a Clearview AI face search wrongly matched him to a theft. Reid had never been to Louisiana and spent nearly a week in jail before release.
Kechi, KS -- lieutenant lost his certification after tracking his wife on Wichita's camerasKS
Data misuse
KANSAS REVOKED THE POLICE CERTIFICATION OF FORMER KECHI LIEUTENANT VICTOR HEIAR. Heiar, 32, of Park City, served with the Kechi Police Department from Mar 24, 2019 to Oct 26, 2022, the day he was arrested. From Sep 23 to Oct 23, 2022 he used Flock plate-reader cameras on the Wichita police network to follow his estranged wife's movements, and told a detective he knew he was misusing the system. Wichita police cut off Kechi's access to the city's Flock database after the search. He pleaded guilty to misdemeanor computer crime and stalking and was sentenced in April to 18 months of probation. The Kansas Commission on Peace Officers' Standards and Training (KS-CPOST) then revoked his certification, so he cannot serve as an officer in Kansas. His case is in the Institute for Justice tally of officers using plate readers to track partners. NOT ESTABLISHED: the year of the sentencing and the date of the revocation, which the report read does not state.
Sisters held at gunpoint in a rental recovered weeks earlierSC
Wrongful stop
A CAR RECOVERED 18 DAYS EARLIER WAS STILL ON THE LIST. On Feb 15, 2022 three Greenville police officers drew guns on sisters McKenzie and Kennedy Bryan, handcuffed them and put them in a patrol car. A plate reader had flagged their rental as stolen. Best Rent A Car had reported it stolen on Jan 27 and recovered the next day, but the stolen-vehicle entry was never cleared. The sisters were released once an officer called the rental company. They sued. Their lawyer argues a stop over an unreturned rental is not high-risk and did not justify drawn weapons. Greenville PD says trained dispatchers manage the database and it refreshes every six hours. That did not help here, because nobody removed the entry. Not established: any ruling or settlement. Ask GPD: who must clear a recovered-vehicle entry, and how fast?
Face-recognition match leads to wrongful jailingMD
Wrongful stop
Alonzo Sawyer was wrongfully jailed in Maryland in 2022 after face-recognition software identified him as the man who assaulted a bus driver. He was held for nine days before the real suspect was identified.
Stopped because her car was the same colourNC
Wrongful stop
A WHITE SEDAN, A FEW MINUTES AWAY, AND THAT WAS ENOUGH. Cameras caught a white sedan at the scene of a Fayetteville shooting that hospitalised a 19-year-old. The city's plate readers -- a Rekor system, not Flock -- spotted Jacqueline McNeill's white Nissan Versa a few minutes away, and according to a police affidavit that link alone was enough for detectives to issue a be-on-the-lookout alert for her car. She was surrounded by five or six cruisers in a convenience store car park while carrying food for her goddaughter's funeral, handcuffed, and accused of taking part in a drive-by shooting. THE MATCH WAS COLOUR AND BODY STYLE, NOT A PLATE. Her lawyer Patrick Anstead argues the technology was substituted for thinking critically about the case. North Carolina has paid roughly $70,000 in settlements across at least two such cases, one in Fayetteville and one involving Charlotte's separate network of more than 100 NDI Technologies cameras. TWO THINGS THIS ADDS TO THE MAP. First, the date: this happened in 2022, well before the wave these arguments are usually dated to. Second, the vendor: most records here concern Flock, and Rekor and NDI produce the same outcome, which means the problem is not one company's software.
Jailed nearly a year on a ShotSpotter alertIL
Data misuse
Michael Williams was jailed in Chicago for nearly a year on a murder charge built largely on a ShotSpotter alert. Prosecutors dropped the case in 2021 for insufficient evidence. His ordeal became a touchstone in the campaign against acoustic gunshot detection.
Teacher arrested at gunpoint over a plate-reader name errorNC
Wrongful stop
In June 2021, Charlotte-Mecklenburg police surrounded teacher Jasmine Horne outside her west Charlotte home and arrested her at gunpoint after a license plate reader linked her car to a wanted suspect because the system had been given the wrong name. She was handcuffed and held before officers realized they had the wrong person; the actual suspect was arrested two days later. An internal review found the officers acted within department policy and in good faith, while Horne, who filed a complaint, said the experience left her traumatized; the department later said it would check plate-reader entries more often and bring in outside review. SETTLED FOR $10,000: Charlotte paid Horne $10,000 in July 2023, admitting no wrongdoing but apologising, per The News & Observer (syndicated copy). The paper says officers had entered the wrong name into the reader system and that she was held about 15 minutes.
Held at gunpoint after a plate-reader letter mix-upCA
Wrongful stop
In Atherton, California, police pulled over Jason Burkleo on his way to work on suspicion of driving a stolen vehicle and ordered him at gunpoint to lie on his stomach to be handcuffed. The plate reader had misread an H as an M. Officers acted on the alert without confirming the plate, one of a string of documented reader misreads that have put innocent drivers at gunpoint.
Arrested at a laundromat over a phantom gunshotIL
Wrongful stop
Daniel Ortiz was doing his children's laundry when Chicago police, responding to a ShotSpotter alert for gunfire that never happened, detained and arrested him on charges that were dismissed the next day.
Boy killed after a ShotSpotter responseIL
Wrongful stop
Thirteen-year-old Adam Toledo was shot and killed by a Chicago police officer responding to a ShotSpotter alert in March 2021. The case became central to the city's decision to decommission the gunshot-detection system.
Officer pleaded guilty to tracking his estranged wifePA
Data misuse
Michael McSherry, a police officer in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, pleaded guilty in 2021 to stalking charges after using plate readers to track his estranged wife and other family members. It is one of the earlier cases in the Institute for Justice's review of officers misusing automated plate-reader networks to follow people in their personal lives.
Predictive policing program harassed familiesFL
Data misuse
The Pasco County Sheriff's Office ran a predictive-policing program that generated lists of likely future offenders, then sent deputies to repeatedly harass roughly 1,000 residents and their families with late-night visits and code-enforcement fines. The office settled a lawsuit, admitted it violated residents' rights, and ended the program.
Family held at gunpoint over a plate-reader errorCO
Wrongful stop
Aurora police pulled over Brittney Gilliam and four children, including a six-year-old, at gunpoint and forced them face-down on the pavement after a plate reader flagged the SUV as stolen. The system had matched the Colorado plate to a stolen motorcycle with the same number from Montana. The city later settled the family lawsuit for 1.9 million dollars.
Drivers held at gunpoint over plate-reader errorsCO
Wrongful stop
License-plate-reader misreads have repeatedly put innocent drivers at gunpoint. In 2020 Aurora, Colorado police forced a Black woman and four children, the youngest six, face-down on hot pavement after a reader matched their plate to a stolen motorcycle from another state; the city paid 1.9 million dollars. CBS News verified more than a dozen US wrongful stops, including a 12-year-old handcuffed in New Mexico over a single misread digit and a San Francisco woman seized at gunpoint in 2009, and one study found readers misread the state on roughly 1 in 10 plates.
Spy plane filmed the entire city from aboveMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police ran a months-long aerial surveillance program in 2020, flying planes that continuously photographed the whole city to track people and vehicles. A federal appeals court later ruled the warrantless program unconstitutional.
Jailed nearly a year over a false gunshot alertIL
Wrongful stop
Michael Williams, 65, spent nearly a year in Cook County Jail after Chicago police charged him with murder based mainly on a ShotSpotter alert the system had first flagged as a firework. Prosecutors dropped the case, and in 2026 the city paid him 500,000 dollars; Chicago scrapped the system in 2024.
Auditor found ICE agencies in county plate dataCA
Data misuse
A California state auditor found that confusing Vigilant settings had left three different ICE agencies with access to the Marin County Sheriff's plate-reader data, frustrating a state law that limits cooperation with immigration enforcement.
Wrongful arrest from a face-recognition matchMI
Wrongful stop
Detroit police wrongfully arrested Robert Williams in January 2020 after face-recognition software matched him to surveillance footage of a shoplifter. He was held overnight; the case became the first widely known wrongful arrest tied to the technology and led Detroit to tighten its rules.
Border agency bought phone location data to skip warrantsUS
Wrongful stop
Customs and Border Protection paid millions to data brokers Venntel and Babel Street for commercial smartphone location data, running tens of thousands of queries to track devices without warrants as a workaround to the Carpenter ruling.
State handed a surveillance firm its databasesUT
Wrongful stop
Utah gave the firm Banjo a multimillion-dollar contract and access to state databases, including traffic cameras and 911 feeds, before a government audit found the company could not deliver the real-time crime detection it had promised.
Wrongful arrests from false face matchesMI
Wrongful stop
At least fourteen people in the US are publicly known to have been wrongfully arrested after police relied on a false facial-recognition match, beginning with Robert Williams in Detroit in 2020. Nearly all were Black; the cases include a woman who was eight months pregnant and several people jailed for months over crimes in states they had never set foot in.
Detroit man wrongly arrested by face matchMI
Data misuse
Robert Williams was arrested at his Detroit-area home after facial recognition wrongly matched him to a watch-store theft. He was held overnight on the strength of a bad match and a photo lineup built around it. His case became the first known US facial-recognition wrongful arrest and ended in a landmark settlement forcing Detroit police to curb the technology.
Detained over a stale stolen-car flagCA
Wrongful stop
Contra Costa sheriff deputies stopped Brian Hofer and his brother at gunpoint on Thanksgiving after a plate reader flagged the car as stolen, even though the vehicle had already been recovered and police had not updated the hot list. Hofer chaired a local privacy commission and received a settlement of about 49,500 dollars.
Face-recognition misidentification, charges droppedMI
Wrongful stop
Michael Oliver was wrongfully arrested in Detroit in 2019 after face recognition misidentified him as the person who threw a teacher's phone. Charges were dismissed once it was clear he was not the man in the video, and he later sued.
Perceptics: even the border agency's ALPR vendor got hackedUS
Wrongful stop
A cautionary tale from the ALPR industry's deep end: Perceptics, the plate-reader vendor for U.S. Customs and Border Protection -- arguably the best-funded law-enforcement agency in the country -- was hacked, and the stolen data, including traveler images and license plates, was published online. The EFF cites it as the definitive proof that ALPR databases are a breach waiting to happen: if CBP's vendor could be cracked and dumped, so can a small town's. The lesson holds across every vendor on this map -- Flock, Axon, Vigilant, Rekor, ELSAG, Jenoptik -- a plate database is only as safe as the least-secure company holding it.
Border plate-reader vendor hacked, traveler data leakedTN
Data misuse
Perceptics, the sole provider of license plate readers at US land border crossings, was hacked, exposing travelers' plate data and CBP photos of drivers that ended up online. CBP called it a major incident, and the vendor had been using the data to refine its algorithms.
Jailed ten days over a false face matchNJ
Wrongful stop
Nijeer Parks was wrongfully arrested in 2019 after New Jersey police relied on a face-recognition match tying him to shoplifting and an assault. He spent about ten days in jail despite being elsewhere at the time, and later sued.
Jailed six days over a Google location dragnetAZ
Wrongful stop
Police in Avondale, Arizona obtained a Google geofence warrant that swept up every device near a 2018 murder. Jorge Molina was arrested and held six days even after a detective quickly deemed him highly unlikely to be the killer; his stepfather was later charged.
Brothers held at gunpoint over a rental car already recoveredCA
Wrongful stop
A Vigilant ALPR in Hercules flagged a vehicle as stolen and officers detained the driver and his brother at gunpoint. The car had been recovered already; nobody had updated the hotlist. The driver was Brian Hofer, who chaired Oakland's privacy commission -- so the person the system stopped at gunpoint was among the few in the state best placed to explain publicly what had gone wrong, and he did. The New York Times covered it. IJ's review dates this to November 2018 and places it in Hercules, which resolves a disagreement in later accounts that put it variously in 2018 or 2019 and in Contra Costa County generally.
ICE pulled plate data from Irvine Company mallsCA
Data misuse
Vigilant cameras at Irvine Company shopping malls in Orange County fed plate data that ICE accessed through a fusion center, despite denials. The mall operator ended its plate-reader program after the practice was exposed.
ICE tapped Vigilant's plate database to track immigrantsUS
Data misuse
ICE gained access to Vigilant Solutions' database of more than 5 billion plate scans through a multi-year contract, letting over 9,000 officers reconstruct people's movements without a warrant to support deportations. The contract has since grown to $22.8 million.
Crime-prediction software hit under half a percentNJ
Wrongful stop
An analysis of more than 23,000 Geolitica (formerly PredPol) crime predictions for Plainfield, New Jersey found a success rate under half a percent, with fewer than 100 predictions matching a later-reported crime. The police captain said the money could have been better spent elsewhere.
Shot by police after a sound was reclassifiedNY
Wrongful stop
In Rochester, New York, Silvon Simmons was shot in the back by police after a ShotSpotter alert. The company's analysts had first classified the noise as a helicopter, then reclassified it as gunshots and raised the count on later reviews.
Police bought a cell tracker to watch protestersFL
Wrongful stop
Miami police purchased a cell-site simulator specifically to surveil political protesters, turning military-grade phone-tracking gear on demonstrators.
Palantir and PredPol drove chronic-offender scoringCA
Wrongful stop
The LAPD used Palantir's Gotham platform, PredPol hot-spot software, and Operation LASER's chronic-offender scores, built from arrest records, license plates, and social media. An inspector general and activists found the tools entrenched over-policing of Black and Latino neighborhoods; LASER ended in 2019 and the PredPol contract in 2020.
Fake cell towers used thousands of times in secretMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police secretly deployed cell-site simulators (Stingrays) more than 4,300 times to locate phones, routinely concealing the technology from courts and defense attorneys.
Face recognition and social media tracked protestersMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police used facial recognition combined with social-media location tracking to surveil and identify protesters after the 2015 death of Freddie Gray.
Plate readers concentrated in Black and Latino areasCA
Data misuse
An investigation of license plate readers in Oakland, California found them placed predominantly in Black and Latino neighborhoods, even though vehicle crimes occurred predominantly elsewhere.
Secret Palantir program ran for years off the booksLA
Wrongful stop
New Orleans police secretly used Palantir's Gotham predictive-policing software from 2012 to 2018 without the city council's knowledge, building target lists from criminal records, social media, and alleged gang ties under a philanthropic-partnership cover that bypassed procurement and oversight.
Plate readers used to surveil Muslim communitiesNY
Data misuse
The NYPD used license plate readers as part of its broad surveillance of Muslim communities across the New York and New Jersey area.
Handcuffed at gunpoint after a misread plateCA
Wrongful stop
San Francisco officers stopped Denise Green, a city worker, late at night and handcuffed her at gunpoint on her knees after a cruiser plate reader misread one digit and matched her car to a stolen vehicle. No officer confirmed the plate by eye. The city paid about 495,000 dollars, and the Ninth Circuit later held that a plate-reader hit alone, without human verification, cannot justify a stop.
Jailhouse exposure of secret cell trackersCA
Wrongful stop
The FBI used a Stingray cell-site simulator to locate Daniel Rigmaiden in his Santa Clara, California apartment in 2008. Working from a jail cell, he reverse-engineered the device and forced the FBI to publicly acknowledge the technology for the first time.
The DEA's national plate-reader networkUS
Data misuse
The Drug Enforcement Administration has run a national license plate reader network since 2008, expanding it into a nationwide tracking system with covert cameras, many using Selex and ELSAG hardware, strung along highways and accessible to other agencies.
Agencies buy app location data to skip warrantsUS
Data misuse
Federal agencies including ICE, CBP, the FBI, and the IRS bought app-harvested smartphone location data from brokers Venntel, Gravy Analytics, and Babel Street's Locate X to sidestep warrants. The FTC banned Gravy and Venntel from selling sensitive location data in December 2024.
Military buys app data to track people abroadUS
Data misuse
US defense contractors and agencies purchased commercial smartphone location data harvested from ordinary apps, including Muslim prayer apps via the broker X-Mode, to track people including in foreign jurisdictions for pattern-of-life analysis, sidestepping the rules that govern signals intelligence.